- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: Who's the better QB: Mahomes or Peyton Manning
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:40 pm to boomjosh
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:40 pm to boomjosh
I'm saying Manning at this moment but when Mahomes is done he'll be thought of as better he's already got more SB's.
playoff record
Mahomes is 17-4 .810
Manning 14-13 .519
playoff record
Mahomes is 17-4 .810
Manning 14-13 .519
1
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:41 pm to boomjosh
We'll see how Mahomes ends up but he's already been far better in the playoffs where it really counts.
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:44 pm to whatiknowsofar
quote:
He didn't have to play prime Brady
Brady did beat Mahomes in the playoffs twice, including a year he won NFL MVP in
This post was edited on 11/5/25 at 10:45 pm
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:46 pm to bcoop199
quote:/thread
Mahomes is 17-4 .810
Manning 14-13 .519
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:56 pm to JohnnyRebel
quote:
so how is Peyton Manning a better QB than Mahomes?
I don't see mahomes taking over the game mentally like Peyton did in his 30s. Once his athleticism fades he's gonna be pretty mid. Hell he's been middle of the league in passer rating the past 3 years already
Posted on 11/5/25 at 11:01 pm to whatiknowsofar
Alright. So longevity is your argument. I know as much as you do. So we’ll have to wait and see.
So far through their careers, it’s Mahomes.
So far through their careers, it’s Mahomes.
This post was edited on 11/5/25 at 11:01 pm
Posted on 11/5/25 at 11:01 pm to Saint Alfonzo
quote:
Manning. How much of Mahome's success is because of Andy Reid?
Time machine....that's what people "whispered" some said, about McNabb.
Posted on 11/5/25 at 11:02 pm to boomjosh
I've got Manning around 4th and Mahomes around 7th in the Super Bowl era. If Mahomes' career ended today, Manning would have the argument for better career. In five years I expect Mahomes to be top 3.
But if the question is, "Who do you want starting at QB for your dream team"? It's Mahomes all day. He has no weaknesses and is the closest thing to a "natural" at the position since John Elway. Rodgers too. They make it look easier than the rest.
But if the question is, "Who do you want starting at QB for your dream team"? It's Mahomes all day. He has no weaknesses and is the closest thing to a "natural" at the position since John Elway. Rodgers too. They make it look easier than the rest.
This post was edited on 11/5/25 at 11:04 pm
Posted on 11/5/25 at 11:14 pm to JohnnyRebel
quote:
I agree, but the point is, Mahomes is beating the best competition in his era, and Peyton didn’t.
The chiefs have had a top 10 defense 6 out of Mahomes 7 seasons. Your argument is dumb.
Posted on 11/5/25 at 11:22 pm to vidtiger23
Okay, so that makes him worse than Peyton how?
Posted on 11/6/25 at 3:55 am to boomjosh
I’m taking Mahomes. His game is more dynamic if you include his running ability. In addition I think Manning has played with better groups of offensive weapons than Mahomes.
Posted on 11/6/25 at 7:14 am to The Boat
quote:
Mahomes is only 30 and already fading
So you just say whatever and don’t care how wrong it is?
Posted on 11/6/25 at 7:36 am to TheePalmetto
It's not wrong. Mahomes had been fading until this year. A lot of that is lack of weapons, but his statement is not wrong
Posted on 11/6/25 at 7:41 am to castorinho
Ehh it’s pretty wrong.
Posted on 11/6/25 at 8:09 am to JohnnyRebel
quote:
Payton Manning is the king of hospital balls, and the fact he couldn’t deal with prime Brady, but his little brother could on the biggest stage… well, I rest my case.
Little known fact:
Tom Brady never won a super bowl without a top 10 defense. No doubt he was a baller and still had to deliver his end to win all those super bowls.
On the other side, Peyton Manning had one, the 2007 team.
Also, I have no idea how Patrick Mahommes has a freaking belly. He allegedly works out all the time and yet he looks like your average plant baw coming off a 2am shift when you saw him on that netflix show. probably why he'll flame out earlier than Brady or Manning. Really seems to me all the working out is a show and he isnt as fastidious about taking care of himself as he would like you to believe.
Posted on 11/6/25 at 8:17 am to boomjosh
This isn't even a conversation, it's Peyton Manning.
Eli and Patrick would be a better conversation. And Eli still has the edge there.
Eli and Patrick would be a better conversation. And Eli still has the edge there.
Posted on 11/6/25 at 8:41 am to TheePalmetto
quote:
Ehh it’s pretty wrong.
We can bust out the advanced stats too. But the trend is clear.
As already mentioned, some of it can be attributed to lack of weapons.
Posted on 11/6/25 at 9:04 am to castorinho
They are trending up this year. Pretty sure he is content with taking the Tom Brady path of throwing it 30-35 times a game and letting the defense do work.
Posted on 11/6/25 at 9:09 am to TheePalmetto
quote:
They are trending up this year.
Page 2 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News