- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: Top 30 QBs of All-Time
Posted on 2/25/21 at 1:11 pm to J the tiger fan
Posted on 2/25/21 at 1:11 pm to J the tiger fan
quote:
Cam newton and Lamar Jackson should be on their too
Remember, active players will climb up the rankings as their careers progress. Currently, Cam Newton ranks #47 all-time. Lamar Jackson, after starting only 2 full seasons, is already up to #55.
These guys would be ranked higher if I weighted rushing yds more. But you don't need to be a great rusher to be a great QB (Marino, Brees and P.Manning all averaged less than 3 yds/gm). Certainly the league is moving in the direction of the more mobile QB. I love it. Maybe I'll weight rushing yds more in future rankings.
1
Posted on 2/25/21 at 1:13 pm to J the tiger fan
quote:
Cam newton and Lamar Jackson should be on their too
What about Warren Moon, Randall Cunningham, and Donovan McNabb??
Posted on 2/25/21 at 1:16 pm to PetermanFanClub
Brady too high.
Rodgers and Young too low
Tarkenton too low
Big Ben and little Russell too high (neither belongs on the list)
Warren Moon too low
Rodgers and Young too low
Tarkenton too low
Big Ben and little Russell too high (neither belongs on the list)
Warren Moon too low
Posted on 2/25/21 at 1:20 pm to TheRouxGuru
TheRouxGuru,
I listed the factors in a previous post.
To keep this answer brief, I can tell you I ranked All-Pro and All-Decade awards, career passer rating, Seasons w/ a Top 10 passer rating, 4th Quarter Comebacks relatively high.
I listed the factors in a previous post.
To keep this answer brief, I can tell you I ranked All-Pro and All-Decade awards, career passer rating, Seasons w/ a Top 10 passer rating, 4th Quarter Comebacks relatively high.
Posted on 2/25/21 at 1:29 pm to PetermanFanClub
Lol @ number 2 Peyton Manning:
5x MVP
3x MVP runner up
7x 1st Team All Pro
3x 2nd Team All Pro
5x MVP
3x MVP runner up
7x 1st Team All Pro
3x 2nd Team All Pro
Posted on 2/25/21 at 1:36 pm to TheRouxGuru
quote:
What about Warren Moon, Randall Cunningham, and Donovan McNabb??
Moon #30 (did you bother to read the original list?)
Cunningham #44
McNabb #51
I think Cunningham deserves Hall of Fame consideration. He was a trailblazer.
FYI, here are the black QBs on the list and their ranking:
#26 - Russell Wilson
#30 - Warren Moon
#31 - Patrick Mahomes
#44 - Randall Cunnigham
#47 - Cam Newton
#51 - Donovan McNabb
#55 - Lamar Jackson
#56 - Deshaun Watson
#67 - Steve McNair
#73 - Dak Prescott
#81 - Daunte Culpepper
#88 - Michael Vick
#116 - Colin Kaepernick
#128 - Jameis Winston
#129 - David Garrard
#130 - Tyrod Taylor
#132 - Robert Griffin III
#133 - Teddy Bridgewater
#137 - Kyler Murray
#147 - Jeff Blake
#148 - Aaron Brooks
#153 - Doug Williams
#166 - Vince Young
#173 - James Harris
#175 - Kordell Stewart
The young guys (Mahomes, Jackson, Watson, Prescott and Murray) are gaining ground quickly! That's great for the NFL!
Posted on 2/25/21 at 1:55 pm to VerlanderBEAST
Don’t you know? He’s the greatest REGULAR SEASON quarterback of all-time!
Posted on 2/25/21 at 2:07 pm to PetermanFanClub
I was mocking the other poster who was playing the ‘what about *insert favorite black QB here*’ game
Posted on 2/25/21 at 2:43 pm to ThePTExperience1969
quote:
Don’t you know? He’s the greatest REGULAR SEASON quarterback of all-time!
Peyton Manning playoff QB rating: 87 4
Tom Brady playoff QB rating: 90.4
Posted on 2/25/21 at 2:53 pm to VerlanderBEAST
Exactly
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:11 pm to ThePTExperience1969
quote:
Exactly
So you must have Matt Ryan #1 right?
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:16 pm to PetermanFanClub
quote:
Criteria used in this ranking (each was weighted differently to come up with a total):
OK... But MY list is from what I saw them do ON THE FIELD.... Stats aside... This about how each played based on the EYE TEST... IF you took the time to WATCH these QBS LIVE as it was going on you would be amazed at how much your list would change... Not sure how old you are but its a good point... Im not talking about NFL films highlights....
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:25 pm to PetermanFanClub
Elway has his detractors, but you always thought Denver had a chance when Elway was in the game.
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:26 pm to PetermanFanClub
quote:
Top 30 QBs of All-Time
quote:
Posted by Message
PetermanFanClub
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:29 pm to PetermanFanClub
Moon is one of the ultimate what-ifs. If he had gone straight to the NFL instead of all those years in the Canadian football league..
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:29 pm to PetermanFanClub
quote:
#148 - Aaron Brooks
#153 - Doug Williams
Are you even serious right now?????
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:31 pm to brmark70816
Kinda like Doug Flutie ; )
Seriously though... Flutie comes in at #76!
Seriously though... Flutie comes in at #76!
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:42 pm to PetermanFanClub
quote:
PetermanFanClub
Here ya go...
Ill give you my top ten for now...
1] Joe Montana
2} Tom Brady
3} John Elway
4} Steve Young
5} Roger Staubach
6} Peyton Manning
7} Dan Marino
8} Jim Kelly
9} Otto Graham
10} Dan Fouts
EYE TEST ......
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:47 pm to dukke v
quote:
1] Joe Montana
2} Tom Brady
3} John Elway
4} Steve Young
5} Roger Staubach
6} Peyton Manning
7} Dan Marino
8} Jim Kelly
9} Otto Graham
10} Dan Fouts
I can dig alot of that list, as I believe Young and Staubach tend to usually be undervalued in historical QB rankings. Not sure about Jim Kelly in Top 10, though.
As for Montana over Brady, as much as I'd like to say it being I grew up a huge Montana fan, what Brady has accomplished in both individual stats (with rotating in and out of receivers) and post season success is crazy.
Overall like your Top 10, though.
Posted on 2/25/21 at 3:52 pm to spiderman
quote:I hate stupid fricks like you. OP generated a ranking based on criteria and weight given to each criteria and opened it up for discussion. No need to be an arse.
Manning at 2 and Graham at 3 ahead of Montana at 5? And Elway at 12 behind Marino? GTFO.
Page 4 of 8
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News