Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message

Preseason expectations compared to reality.

Posted on 11/15/26 at 4:21 pm
Posted by NorthTiger
Upper 40
Member since Jan 2004
4019 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 4:21 pm
I remember thinking 9-3 with a shot at 10-2. I thought just make the playoffs and anything beyond a first round win would be a wait-and-see deal.

There were too many unknowns about individual players. Jackson Harris is the biggest positive surprise. Surprises in the opposite direction are Berry (202 yds) and Durham (36 yds) without an injury.

Finally, having a dual threat (key word, “threat”) QB serms to be less of a factor with each game.
Posted by DrSteveBrule
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2009
12659 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 4:23 pm to
In hindsight, they are a team with some great players, but not a complete team. So basically it turned out just like expected.

The most disappointing part is with all of that considered, coaching could have carried this team to 3 extra wins instead of losses.
Posted by Gings5
Member since Jul 2016
12565 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 4:25 pm to
No one predicted Leavitt to be this bad
Posted by Tiger Ugly
Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2008
19848 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 4:38 pm to
9-3 was a reasonable expectation and nothing I've seen makes me think it was not a reasonable expectation.

And that's why it's so disappointing we did not achieve it. We underachieved this year IMHO.

Hopefully we overachieve next year, that's what you expect from a coach that is getting paid what Lane is to exceed expectations and overachieve with the talent on hand.


Posted by JawjaTigah
Tejas
Member since Sep 2003
23167 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 4:43 pm to
9-3 my most optimistic hope
8-4 my reality based guess
7-5 my most pessimistic scenario

But a possible 6-6? Vols and Piglets? Lose to both???
Posted by Arbengal
Louisiana
Member since Sep 2008
3618 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 5:08 pm to
This was my exact scenario as well. Told my boys the same thing. I don’t believe we will win next week.
Posted by hall59tiger
Member since Oct 2013
3338 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 5:10 pm to
I think landing Seaton and Leavitt really fooled us on how mid this offenses roster is. They aren’t good to make up for being average everywhere but TE
Posted by Sofaking2
Member since Apr 2023
23664 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 5:11 pm to
Year 1 I was thinking 8-4. We are probably looking at 7-5. I actually thought Sam might progress some, but he has regressed. He’s shown us who he is and needs to find another school to pay his bloated NIL.
Posted by Tiger Ugly
Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2008
19848 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 5:22 pm to
So, our talent is mid? is that what you are saying? Do you really think Kentucky has more talent than us?

How about Ole MIss?

Do you think coaching matters at all? if so, do you think our mid talent could be coached up enough to beat teams of comparable or less talent like KY and Ole Miss?

LK will have time to prove his worth. But it's also fair to judge him on this year and IMHO say his coaching was mid.

Posted by hall59tiger
Member since Oct 2013
3338 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 5:33 pm to
OM has better talent on offense at almost every position

LSU vs UK

QB - wash
RB - wash
OL - UK
TE - wash
Wr - slightly LSU
Posted by BadatBourre
Member since Jan 2019
1467 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 5:39 pm to
quote:

thought just make the playoffs and anything beyond a first round win would be a wait-and-see deal.


Nah, that was just a REALLY REALLY dumb take. You thought a team with 42 new players, literally 9 new starters on offense, an OL that has never played together, a QB who has never thrown to any of the receivers and also is brand new to a Lane Kiffin offense was going to make the playoffs?
Posted by Tiger Ugly
Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2008
19848 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 5:42 pm to
quote:

OM has better talent on offense at almost every position


Now do Ole Miss's defense

And it seems you are trying to make an argument KY's talent is as good asours? if so - how do you explain a new coach at KY was able to stock a roster as good as ours under worse circumstances than our first year coach at a basketball school?
This post was edited on 11/15/26 at 5:46 pm
Posted by chadr07
Rapides Parish
Member since Jan 2015
15643 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 6:06 pm to
quote:

You thought a team with 42 new players, literally 9 new starters on offense, an OL that has never played together, a QB who has never thrown to any of the receivers






You do realize Lane and LSU will be in this same exact situation this next offseason right? I don’t honestly know how next year will be any different when Lane has to build an entirely new team yet again. He will have yet another Oline that will have never played together.
Posted by BadatBourre
Member since Jan 2019
1467 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 6:38 pm to
You realize only 2 players walked across the field on Senior night correct? Most of the players will return. The only absolute losses on the OL or Seaton and Moore. I'd expect an entire new OL, but odder things have happened.
Posted by hall59tiger
Member since Oct 2013
3338 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 6:44 pm to
quote:

Now do Ole Miss's defense


Not sure if your reading comprehension is bad or you just aren’t too good at the whole thinking thing. Not sure what this question has to do with my original statement.

quote:

if so - how do you explain a new coach at KY was able to stock a roster as good as ours under worse circumstances than our first year coach at a basketball school?


Very easily. They had a lot of buy in for Stein. Their fans and boosters were super bought in, at least relative to what they are capable of.

Stein built from the same recruiting playbook as Stoops: recruit size because he would never be able to recruit the same guys who can move sideline to sideline as the bama, Georgia, LSU’s of the world. It’s a high floor and low ceiling philosophy which is exactly what they are. Their size on the front 7 and ability to lean on the run game won it for them vs us. They are more cohesive team than most other CFB programs especially earlier in the season.

LK swung for the fences and it didn’t pay off. Leavit was our 4th choice at qb. We are a Georgia win va ole miss away from having Chambliss and Lacy. We would have 1 loss with them.

Don’t get me wrong, LK is responsible for building the roster and should be blamed for its holes but it’s just an objective fact that our offensive roster is very mid.
Posted by Tiger Ugly
Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2008
19848 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 6:30 am to
quote:

Now do Ole Miss's defense


Not sure if your reading comprehension is bad or you just aren’t too good at the whole thinking thing. Not sure what this question has to do with my original statement.



No it's fine, your statement was in case you forgot - Ole Miss was better on offense on almost every position the implication being therefore in the context of your discussion with me - We didn't have as good or better overall talent as Ole Miss, thus my statement - "Now do Ole Miss's defense" because your comparison was incomplete - you just mentioned offense. I didn't think it that difficult to understand - at all - but apparently it was, my apologies I'll do better next time.

quote:


Very easily. They had a lot of buy in for Stein. Their fans and boosters were super bought in, at least relative to what they are capable of.


And we didn't have a lot of buy in for Kiffin.....sorry that's laughable. I don't care how much buy in they had it was not as much as ours. Maybe they did better with their resources. That's debatable because I really think they've overachieved and are not as good as their record.

quote:

Stein built from the same recruiting playbook as Stoops: recruit size because he would never be able to recruit the same guys who can move sideline to sideline as the bama, Georgia, LSU’s of the world.


He recruited a good, not great offensive line - outside of that and the wide receiver we had that Lane didn't want I'm not seeing much from KY, their QB is middling and they will probably lose at least one of not 2 more games. We should not have lost to them. We were and are better than them.

quote:

LK swung for the fences and it didn’t pay off. Leavit was our 4th choice at qb. We are a Georgia win va ole miss away from having Chambliss and Lacy. We would have 1 loss with them.


Not entirely true in swinging for the fences at other positions, he chose just the opposite route at WR, he and Glasscock went with the more numbers at less money than a small number paid alot, they have been very public about that. I'm fine with the RB we have - he's performed better than Lacy overall this year to be honest, and he's played in every game unlike Lacy.

Would i would have like Chambliss - sure. I was hoping we would have developed Leavitt a bit more by this time, it was supposed to be Lane's specialty.

But bottom line if you are saying our roster does not stack up well enough to expect to beat Ole Miss and Kentucky, I don't agree - but if that were the case that's an indictment on Lane, which you did concede at the end of your post. But, IMHO having the team less prepared and coached up cost us those games more than comparable roster issues.
This post was edited on 11/16/26 at 7:01 am
Posted by hall59tiger
Member since Oct 2013
3338 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 7:06 am to
My original claim was that we were mid in terms of offensive talent, which is true.
You asked if we were mid compared to OM and UK.
I compared the offensive units, emphasizing the fact that OM has better offensive talent than us, which is true.

I never made any claims about any of those teams defenses at any point, and therefore I do not need to try and support a claim I never made. Your view may be incomplete but mine is to the point and supported by evidence.

quote:

And we didn't have a lot of buy in for Kiffin.....sorry that's laughable.


We had a ton of buy in for Kiffin. What’s your point?

quote:

He recruited a good, not great offensive line


Doesn’t need to be great, just better than ours to prove my point. Not sure why you keep bringing up other arguments when I’ve stuck to my original statement from the jump.

quote:

But bottom line if you are saying our roster does not stack up well enough to expect to beat Ole Miss and Kentucky


OM’s overall roster is probably better than ours given the significant edge at QB. Having a heisman quality player at the most important position in football sets them apart. Swap QB’s and we beat them by 3-4 touchdowns in the grove.
We have a better overall roster than UK for sure but it’s not as crazy as people are making it out to be. We spent about 10 million more than them and over 5 million was on our bench in that game (Treydez, Weeks, and Spears). Having 4-5 million more in NIL really doesn’t separate yourself from other teams near as much as people are making it out to be.
Posted by Tiger Ugly
Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2008
19848 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 7:12 am to
quote:

I never made any claims about any of those teams defenses at any point, and therefore I do not need to try and support a claim I never made. Your view may be incomplete but mine is to the point and supported by evidence.



But your statement comparing offenses and leaving it at that was incomplete when our discussion was about comparing overall team talent. You can't compare overall talent by just looking at one side of the ball. Ole Miss's defense sucks.
This post was edited on 11/16/26 at 7:18 am
Posted by hall59tiger
Member since Oct 2013
3338 posts
Posted on 11/16/26 at 9:34 am to
quote:

But your statement comparing offenses and leaving it at that was incomplete when our discussion was about comparing overall team talent.


I never made any claims about overall talent. I made a very specific and intentional claim and then backed it up. I knew people who don’t look too deeply into things would assume UK has less talent than us and I could easily prove them wrong.
I’m just tired of people accepting these over simplistic narratives touted on Facebook by people who know little to nothing about actual football and who know absolutely zero about running an organization as big as LSU. An example would be me immediately knowing people have small brains when they throw out the “LSU paid 50 million so we should be compared to this or that” narrative. It’s low level thinking or just parroting a media clickbait talking point without thinking at all
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•X•Instagram