- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: Sourdough Bread Eaters
Posted on 3/10/26 at 5:46 am to SquirrelBones
Posted on 3/10/26 at 5:46 am to SquirrelBones
The wife and I stopped by Saturday morning and picked up a couple loaves. Vote for Pedro and Whiteout are both very very good. Had a good chat with rabbit very nice and look forward to going back and trying more. Definitely go visit it’s well worth it.
Posted on 3/10/26 at 8:09 am to SquirrelBones
Also Interested, I will be rolling through on my way back Sunday from New Orleans.
Posted on 3/10/26 at 10:07 am to SquirrelBones
Here you go:
This post was edited on 3/10/26 at 10:09 am
Posted on 3/11/26 at 12:19 am to BlueRabbit
I hate to muddy up the Blue Rabbit bread thread with an amateur loaf, but I just baked my first one of 2026 and thought I'd share for feedback. I baked a few last year but still very new and figuring this out.
3% rye (KA), 47% whole wheat (Bob's Red Mill), 50% bread flour (KA)
~75% hydration
Day 1:
- Overnight levain (20g starter, 40g flour, 50g water)
Day 2:
- Mix levain with remaining flour and water for 1 hr fermentolyse; Mix in salt
- Stretch and folds + coil folds over ~2.5 hrs
- Total bulk ferment ~4.5 hrs
- Pre-shape, shape, cold proof in fridge overnight 16 hrs
Day 3:
- Out of the fridge and 1hr rest while oven preheated
- Baked uncovered on aluminum sheet pan at 475 for 20 min then 445 for 30 min
- Tried to flick some water on the loaf and added boiling water to a pan on bottom rack to generate steam when putting the loaf in the oven
Overall, the color and shine is beautiful, and I seemed to have done a decent job with the fermentation time. I didn't get an "ear" on top and the bottom kind of busted / bulged. From what I've read, this could be due to the top crust hardening more quickly and the pressure needing to go elsewhere. This would've been influenced by it being uncovered and the absence of a pre-heated baking stone on the bottom. Or maybe I didn't score deep enough.
Any ideas? Feedback? Does the crumb indicate if under or over proofed?

3% rye (KA), 47% whole wheat (Bob's Red Mill), 50% bread flour (KA)
~75% hydration
Day 1:
- Overnight levain (20g starter, 40g flour, 50g water)
Day 2:
- Mix levain with remaining flour and water for 1 hr fermentolyse; Mix in salt
- Stretch and folds + coil folds over ~2.5 hrs
- Total bulk ferment ~4.5 hrs
- Pre-shape, shape, cold proof in fridge overnight 16 hrs
Day 3:
- Out of the fridge and 1hr rest while oven preheated
- Baked uncovered on aluminum sheet pan at 475 for 20 min then 445 for 30 min
- Tried to flick some water on the loaf and added boiling water to a pan on bottom rack to generate steam when putting the loaf in the oven
Overall, the color and shine is beautiful, and I seemed to have done a decent job with the fermentation time. I didn't get an "ear" on top and the bottom kind of busted / bulged. From what I've read, this could be due to the top crust hardening more quickly and the pressure needing to go elsewhere. This would've been influenced by it being uncovered and the absence of a pre-heated baking stone on the bottom. Or maybe I didn't score deep enough.
Any ideas? Feedback? Does the crumb indicate if under or over proofed?

Posted on 3/11/26 at 6:57 pm to Tigerbait46
Looks like it needs a big smear of Kerrygold butter on it.
That’s a great looking bread. And this thread is about sourdough not just me. Post more and I wish others would as well.
I score with the blade at an angle but don’t get caught up in the Instagram ear. Most people don’t like it. Nor do they like the big hole crumb. But they look great in a picture.
The crust will harden too fast if you don’t have enough steam. The first 20 minutes is when you get your oven spring and if you don’t have enough steam it hardens the crust and retards the rise.
If you have a Dutch oven try it in that. Preheat the oven and let the Dutch oven preheat with it. Spritz the top of your loaf or all of it. (I spray my plain loaves with a good bit of water-it makes them blister which I like and adds extra steam)
When ready to bake lower it in the Dutch oven on parchment and toss 3-4 ice cubes on each side of it then put the lid on. Bake for 20 minutes then take the lid off and finish baking. That last 15-20 uncovered gives you your color and crust.
If you don’t have a Dutch oven when you put the bread in toss a handful of ice cubes into the bottom of the oven and shut the door.
Looks to me like your aluminum sheet works well enough.
One other thing. Don’t let your bread sit and proof after you take it out of refrigeration. Spritz it, score it and put it in the oven cold.
That’s a great looking bread. And this thread is about sourdough not just me. Post more and I wish others would as well.
I score with the blade at an angle but don’t get caught up in the Instagram ear. Most people don’t like it. Nor do they like the big hole crumb. But they look great in a picture.
The crust will harden too fast if you don’t have enough steam. The first 20 minutes is when you get your oven spring and if you don’t have enough steam it hardens the crust and retards the rise.
If you have a Dutch oven try it in that. Preheat the oven and let the Dutch oven preheat with it. Spritz the top of your loaf or all of it. (I spray my plain loaves with a good bit of water-it makes them blister which I like and adds extra steam)
When ready to bake lower it in the Dutch oven on parchment and toss 3-4 ice cubes on each side of it then put the lid on. Bake for 20 minutes then take the lid off and finish baking. That last 15-20 uncovered gives you your color and crust.
If you don’t have a Dutch oven when you put the bread in toss a handful of ice cubes into the bottom of the oven and shut the door.
Looks to me like your aluminum sheet works well enough.
One other thing. Don’t let your bread sit and proof after you take it out of refrigeration. Spritz it, score it and put it in the oven cold.
Posted on 3/11/26 at 6:59 pm to Tigerbait46
One more thing-the color on that loaf is beautiful.
Posted on 3/11/26 at 7:39 pm to tigertown80
Since all you sum bitches got everything before I got there Saturday. I ended up with just some coffee and a sample.
I got a bag of beans from Rwanda from the Next Chapter Coffee lady. Pretty damn good stuff. I would definitely try others from her.
I won’t make it Saturday, as we are riding in the parade. I’ll have to wait one more week.
I got a bag of beans from Rwanda from the Next Chapter Coffee lady. Pretty damn good stuff. I would definitely try others from her.
I won’t make it Saturday, as we are riding in the parade. I’ll have to wait one more week.
Posted on 3/12/26 at 8:53 am to HebertFest08
quote:
Since all you sum bitches got everything before I got there Saturday. I ended up with just some coffee and a sample. I got a bag of beans from Rwanda from the Next Chapter Coffee lady. Pretty damn good stuff. I would definitely try others from her. I won’t make it Saturday, as we are riding in the parade. I’ll have to wait one more week.
I’ll have about 50 more loaves this week.
I’m trying a small French lentil and bacon. I tested it a few days ago and it’s good so I’ll roll it out this weekend and see what everyone thinks.
Our cheesecake girl will be back this week too. She was at Merry Market last weekend.
And Amy the NextChapter Coffee is installing her Jura Espresso machine I think today so she will have some great ones to go with a piece of cheesecake while I burn your ear about sourdough. I’m good at that so get a big coffee.
She does have some really good small farm single origin coffees and knows her shite. Hope everyone else tries them as well.
Posted on 3/12/26 at 11:33 am to BlueRabbit
Thanks, BR. I was really pleased with the color!
I think the lack of steam had an effect re: the crust hardening maybe too soon. I don't have a dutch oven but will be keeping an eye out. I think I have a pot that could flip upside down and fit over a boule. That might be worth a try, though I prefer the batard shape.
Hoping to bake another similar loaf this weekend and will post pics.
I think the lack of steam had an effect re: the crust hardening maybe too soon. I don't have a dutch oven but will be keeping an eye out. I think I have a pot that could flip upside down and fit over a boule. That might be worth a try, though I prefer the batard shape.
Hoping to bake another similar loaf this weekend and will post pics.
Posted on 3/15/26 at 11:04 am to Tigerbait46
Add my latest attempt to this thread.
Total loaf was 1150grams. 60% hydration.
I stretched and folded 4 times 30mins between. I then let it sit for 30mins before going in the fridge over night for 14 hrs.
Baked at 450 in a preheated cast iron Dutch oven. For 30.mins Added 3 cubes of ice.
Uncovered and finished at 400 for 20 mins
Taste is good and tangy, but as my precious attempts still comes out super dense.
Total loaf was 1150grams. 60% hydration.
I stretched and folded 4 times 30mins between. I then let it sit for 30mins before going in the fridge over night for 14 hrs.
Baked at 450 in a preheated cast iron Dutch oven. For 30.mins Added 3 cubes of ice.
Uncovered and finished at 400 for 20 mins
Taste is good and tangy, but as my precious attempts still comes out super dense.
This post was edited on 3/15/26 at 11:06 am
Posted on 3/15/26 at 12:00 pm to mchias1
Doesn't look like you're letting it ferment long enough and your shaping needs some practice.
Posted on 3/16/26 at 11:22 am to mchias1
quote:
Total loaf was 1150grams. 60% hydration. I stretched and folded 4 times 30mins between. I then let it sit for 30mins before going in the fridge over night for 14 hrs.
First move up to 65% hydration. That is a really good starting point for a workable dough and then you can move up as you feel going forward. Or not. 65 is a sweet spot. Most of mine are between 70 and 78 depending on the flour, flour blend, ambient temperature, water temperature etc….
Second are you saying after your 4 stretch and folds it sat another 30 minutes before cold proof? So 2.5 hours of bulk fermentation. Your bread is under-proofed by the picture and this is why. You probably needed another 2 hours bulk fermenting before shaping, a little bench rest, put in basket and then refrigerator.
Don’t worry about shaping. That comes along. Bulk fermentation is 80% of the outcome. If you don’t get it within a margin of error you end up with what you have. I would rather be a bit on the over-proofed side than under proofed. If it is too far over I can put it in a loaf pan for structure.
LINK
This is the guy you and anyone else who wants to learn it needs to follow. He has everything you need, answers submitted questions quickly and all of his content including his charts are free. I’m not a good teacher. And neither is 99% of the ones online. Learn from him and once you get his basics you will be doing a lot of it by intuition. It’s not hard. It’s just persistence and patience. But even over proofed or under proofed bread can taste great so you get product out of your mistakes.
LINK
One tool that I find useful is a bread PH meter. It’s only one tool, but using it with temperature, time, and the actual feel and look of the dough helps me get pretty damn close each time. The Hanna Instruments Halo2. Not terribly cheap but works very well.
But that in itself is a learning curve. Different flours, different inclusions require different ph values. But once you have used it for a while it just becomes another helpful resource.
LINK
For shaping I pre-shape into a boule. Bench rest 10-20 minutes (depending on proofing) then I use the “caddy clasp” to final shape and put into the batard basket. It is the simplest and easiest way without all the other stitching etc…which just aren’t necessary.
I’m trying to push 150-175 loaves so I need something efficient and it works great.
Pull up Wayne Caddy or Sourdough Slingers on Instagram and Facebook and follow Jim’s as well. Great content. And learn his caddy clasp. But learn it from him. Not the other 20 people out there trying to show you.
Keep going. Post more. Good luck.
Posted on 3/16/26 at 12:54 pm to BlueRabbit
Thanks.
I didn't shape it because all I have is a round Dutch oven anyway. I don't have an oblong one to use.
I'll try letting it bulk ferment longer next time. Time before I let it go too long and it ended up a sad flat bread.
I didn't shape it because all I have is a round Dutch oven anyway. I don't have an oblong one to use.
I'll try letting it bulk ferment longer next time. Time before I let it go too long and it ended up a sad flat bread.
Posted on 3/19/26 at 7:59 am to BlueRabbit
I am addicted to the dips now, I hope you have some of the chorizo I didn't get last week. Love the new location.
My wife liked the beet hummus, but the queso or the cheese are mine. The brie and apple bread is very good, too.
My wife liked the beet hummus, but the queso or the cheese are mine. The brie and apple bread is very good, too.
This post was edited on 3/19/26 at 8:05 am
Posted on 3/19/26 at 8:55 am to BlueRabbit
Focaccia Sour Dough with Italian herbs and garlic. Damn tasty!


Posted on 3/19/26 at 9:55 am to jmon
Focaccia Sour Dough looks great. If I can make a suggestion, I was about to bake some mini-muffaletta buns so I could bring these:
to a party. I had an idea, instead I baked a pan of Focaccia, sliced it in half, then put in all the muff stuff. Then I cut it into finger sandwich sizes, worked great. I wish I had taken a pic.
to a party. I had an idea, instead I baked a pan of Focaccia, sliced it in half, then put in all the muff stuff. Then I cut it into finger sandwich sizes, worked great. I wish I had taken a pic.
Posted on 3/19/26 at 5:57 pm to andouille
welp I goofed up my loaf this week but was able to salvage it into a strange miche/foccacia hybrid. Flour mix was ~50% whole wheat, 5% rye, and 45% bread flour and I think I accidentally got the hydration up to 80%+.
Either my starter was too acidic or week or the hydration was too high (or a combo of these issues). I had trouble strengthening gluten from the start. It was super slack and sticky, but instead of tossing it, I let it ferment until bubbly and then cooked it in a preheated cast iron with olive oil and butter. It's a flat loaf, but the crumb is consistent (no gummy spots), and the crust added a ton of flavor. Slicing and toasting it later in the week now and the nutty flavors are really coming out.
Not a photo-worthy loaf or something I'd share with a neighbor, but it's feeding me for the week!
Either my starter was too acidic or week or the hydration was too high (or a combo of these issues). I had trouble strengthening gluten from the start. It was super slack and sticky, but instead of tossing it, I let it ferment until bubbly and then cooked it in a preheated cast iron with olive oil and butter. It's a flat loaf, but the crumb is consistent (no gummy spots), and the crust added a ton of flavor. Slicing and toasting it later in the week now and the nutty flavors are really coming out.
Not a photo-worthy loaf or something I'd share with a neighbor, but it's feeding me for the week!
Posted on 3/19/26 at 8:42 pm to jmon
That’s a great looking focaccia.
Good hummus slathered on, good turkey, bacon, fresh tomatoes, some greens. I’d go to town.
Good hummus slathered on, good turkey, bacon, fresh tomatoes, some greens. I’d go to town.
Posted on 3/20/26 at 12:37 am to BlueRabbit
Does anyone bake a sourdough baguette that can be bought locally?
Posted on 3/20/26 at 10:30 am to tonydtigr
LINK
He makes great baguettes and sells at the downtown farmers market Saturday morning.
Better get there early because they go fast. But they are good. Real good.
I am hit or miss making them. I’ve never quite got the shaping technique down and sometimes they are pretty good and sometimes you can put them behind the door in case of intruders.
I’d love to really work on them but time is an issue for me.
He does the Pennington market on Thursday too. Go get one. Support your local baker, farmer, sandwich maker, etc…
If people just look a little bit they would be surprised at the talented craftsman and small, local businesses that are out there everyday and everywhere making and selling some amazing products-from food to furniture.
It’s a good time of the year to search them out. Enjoy.
He makes great baguettes and sells at the downtown farmers market Saturday morning.
Better get there early because they go fast. But they are good. Real good.
I am hit or miss making them. I’ve never quite got the shaping technique down and sometimes they are pretty good and sometimes you can put them behind the door in case of intruders.
I’d love to really work on them but time is an issue for me.
He does the Pennington market on Thursday too. Go get one. Support your local baker, farmer, sandwich maker, etc…
If people just look a little bit they would be surprised at the talented craftsman and small, local businesses that are out there everyday and everywhere making and selling some amazing products-from food to furniture.
It’s a good time of the year to search them out. Enjoy.
Popular
Back to top


1






