Started By
Message

Ecobee3 vs Nest in one story house.

Posted on 9/30/16 at 6:52 pm
Posted by LSU5508
New Orleans
Member since Nov 2007
3760 posts
Posted on 9/30/16 at 6:52 pm
Pulling the trigger in one of these this weekend, Which is better? I have no preference and will not be updating anything but the thermostat. There will be no smart vents. Thermostat is located in a central part of the house that nest will be able to learn. 2000 square feet. Will be pairing with a wink hub when the new one comes out.

Is this a Coke vs Pepsi type of thing?

What are the pros and cons of each?
This post was edited on 9/30/16 at 9:09 pm
Posted by Tami Taylor
713
Member since Jul 2016
74 posts
Posted on 9/30/16 at 7:56 pm to
I have a Nest and love it. It does what I bought it to do. Through my electricity company, I earn money back on my bill when I reduce my energy use during peak times so a smart thermostat was a no brainer. Nest was easy to set up and has worked great. I really think it's a Coke vs Pepsi issue
Posted by Booger96
Member since Sep 2016
32 posts
Posted on 9/30/16 at 8:23 pm to
Look up the "Lyric"
Posted by AnonymousTiger
Franklin, TN
Member since Jan 2012
4863 posts
Posted on 9/30/16 at 9:55 pm to
The remote sensors for the ecobee give it the advantage.
Posted by Venelar
The AP
Member since Oct 2010
1215 posts
Posted on 9/30/16 at 9:57 pm to
ecobee
Posted by ForeLSU
The Corner of Sanity and Madness
Member since Sep 2003
41525 posts
Posted on 9/30/16 at 11:29 pm to
ecobee 3
Posted by Signal Soldier
30.411994,-91.183929
Member since Dec 2010
8561 posts
Posted on 10/1/16 at 1:55 am to
Ecobee
Posted by LSU5508
New Orleans
Member since Nov 2007
3760 posts
Posted on 10/1/16 at 9:48 am to
Any reason the ecobee3 is better than the nest?
Posted by CAD703X
Liberty Island
Member since Jul 2008
92270 posts
Posted on 10/1/16 at 9:49 am to
It's a better product
Posted by LSU5508
New Orleans
Member since Nov 2007
3760 posts
Posted on 10/1/16 at 12:04 pm to
Will the ecobee work with older systems that contain a gas furnace?
Posted by CAD703X
Liberty Island
Member since Jul 2008
92270 posts
Posted on 10/1/16 at 12:59 pm to
I would call and ask.

I sound like a broken record but that's one of the nice things about those Honeywells is they support freaking every HVAC system known to mankind out of the box.

You may have to change some codes directly on the unit initially but they were designed to work with anything.
Posted by TigerWise
Front Seat of an Uber
Member since Sep 2010
35131 posts
Posted on 10/1/16 at 1:29 pm to
quote:

It's a better product


You owned a Nest ?
Posted by CAD703X
Liberty Island
Member since Jul 2008
92270 posts
Posted on 10/1/16 at 2:09 pm to
Nest supports remote sensors?
Posted by slapahoe
USA
Member since Sep 2009
7476 posts
Posted on 10/1/16 at 3:47 pm to
NEST BAWWWW
Posted by efrad
Member since Nov 2007
18702 posts
Posted on 10/2/16 at 12:33 am to
Go with the ecobee 3. The remote sensors are awesome.

Also Nest doesn't support Apple HomeKit or Siri if you're into that sort of thing.
This post was edited on 10/2/16 at 12:35 am
Posted by mctiger1985
Baton Rouge
Member since Oct 2009
3695 posts
Posted on 10/2/16 at 8:08 am to
quote:

Nest supports remote sensors?


No, but Wink does, and they are cheaper than the ecobee sensors
Posted by 632627
LA
Member since Dec 2011
14726 posts
Posted on 10/2/16 at 11:05 am to
I researched this a few months ago and everything I read pointed to ecobee
Posted by LSU5508
New Orleans
Member since Nov 2007
3760 posts
Posted on 10/2/16 at 12:14 pm to
I'm going with ecobee. Thanks everyone.
Posted by efrad
Member since Nov 2007
18702 posts
Posted on 10/2/16 at 2:41 pm to
You won't regret it.

One of the things that impressed me was that the ecobee3 was able to detect that my system was low on freon. One the hot summer temperatures kicked up, my A/C was taking a little too long to hit the desired temperatures. I noticed it because I am fairly well versed in the HVAC world, but I hadn't had enough time to get some freon so it went a week or so like that. At one point the ecobee3 popped up a notice on the screen saying that the A/C was running too long to cool compared to the temperature outside the house (based on forecast data it gets), and that I should have my system serviced. It also sent me an email saying the same thing.

I have no idea if the other thermostats do that too because I haven't seen that listed as a feature anywhere. But it impressed me because the system was still hitting the desired temperature, but the thermostat still knew it wasn't performing like it should be.
Posted by LSUdubai
Dubai, UAE
Member since Oct 2010
268 posts
Posted on 10/3/16 at 5:40 am to
I've got a Nest and 2 Ecobee 3's. I like the Nest better personally. The remote sensors for the Ecobees are not good at all in my experience, thus killing their advantage; to the point where I don't even use the remote sensors anymore.

The Nest app is also much simpler, nicer UI, and provides data in a much clearer presentation. If I did it all over, I'd go with 3 Nests rather than what I've got now. ...beware of users who just don't like products because they don't like them or their MO. IMHO you won't regret either...

ETA: the problem with my remote sensors is the temp readings were way too high compared to what the actual room temp was; by about 4 degrees. This made the AC run much longer than it actually needed to.
This post was edited on 10/3/16 at 5:43 am
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram