Started By
Message
locked post

The transfer portal is a good thing for college football

Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:18 am
Posted by mike4lsu
Baton Rouge,LA
Member since Sep 2005
1723 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:18 am
First of all, the most significant players to have played for LSU in the past decade have been transfers: Joe Burrow and Jayden Daniels.

Second, we finished 2021 with 43 scholarship athletes with a WR playing QB in a 42-21 loss to a middle tier Big 12 school with one of our TDs coming in the last play of the game. That before the transfer portal era it would akin to the death penalty.

If we were recruiting 25 freshmen at a time like the good old days, we would have hit rock bottom in 2022 and 2023 and interest and money would have waned. The very fact that we went 10-4 next year, won the west and beat Alabama at home was because of the portal.

Third, we are at a disadvantage over the two Texas schools in NIL...you can now recruit a player of 1 year and he can switch his commitment for a few extra bucks on the last day because of NIL...The transfer portal helps us cushion some of these losses.

Fourth, the portal ensures no team is more than 2 deep at any position. That tries to restore some parity in an otherwise increasingly disparate world of "have mores", "haves" and "have nots".

Fifth, the portal makes every years team different from previous years teams. That makes pre-season rankings moot and increases unpredictability. Variety makes the game more fun to watch.

Sixth, it genuinely helps players stuck behind equal or better talent from moving on to somewhere else and showcase their talents. e.g., Joe Burrow and Jayden Daniels.

Posted by TigerBR1111
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2014
7604 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:20 am to
It’s a shite show. You could put lipstick on a pig, but it’s still gonna be a pig.

quote:

Fifth, the portal makes every years team different from previous years teams.


I miss the days when you could recruit a freshman into the program and look forward to his development until he became a leader and all-SEC caliber type of player
This post was edited on 12/22/24 at 11:25 am
Posted by Cleary Rebels
Member since Oct 2024
2899 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:22 am to
It’s good for the individual but bad for teams. It is anti-team. It is me, me, me.
Posted by mike4lsu
Baton Rouge,LA
Member since Sep 2005
1723 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:23 am to
Also, coaches could leave one program for another at whim. But players who had signed with them had to stay on and play for a coach with a different system where they did not fit. Now they can leave with the coach.

Also, programs would fire coaches on a whim, sometimes simply on the basis of likes and dislikes of key alumni or ADs. Now you fire a coach and his players leave with him and rosters collapse. So there are consequences for firing coaches who go 8-4 or 9-3 just because delusional fan bases think they should be winning a natty every year.
Posted by tconle2
Member since Sep 2011
4106 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:25 am to
The transfer portal was part of the 43 scholarship issue.
Posted by mike4lsu
Baton Rouge,LA
Member since Sep 2005
1723 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:25 am to
quote:

It’s good for the individual but bad for teams. It is anti-team. It is me, me, me.


So tell which team lost out when Joe Burrow transferred?

Ohio State made the playoffs and LSU made the playoffs and won a natty.

Was us going from 6-7 with 43 man roster to 10-4 with SEC-W title anti LSU?
Posted by mike4lsu
Baton Rouge,LA
Member since Sep 2005
1723 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:27 am to
quote:

The transfer portal was part of the 43 scholarship issue.


No....leadership was the issue. Those kids would have left no matter what...at least some of them got to play football after they left.
Posted by mike4lsu
Baton Rouge,LA
Member since Sep 2005
1723 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:29 am to
quote:

I miss the days when you could recruit a freshman into the program and look forward to his development until he became a leader and all-SEC caliber type of player


They are still developing. Just not at one school but at multiple schools.
Posted by Sofaking2
Member since Apr 2023
12559 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:33 am to
Marshall had to pull out of a bowl game because of the portal and opt outs, lol. It’s not a good thing at all.
Posted by Cleary Rebels
Member since Oct 2024
2899 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:34 am to
A blind hog finds an acorn every now and then. Overall, it’s individual based and anti-team. You have no loyalty anymore and that is anti-team.
Posted by mike4lsu
Baton Rouge,LA
Member since Sep 2005
1723 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:41 am to
quote:

You have no loyalty anymore and that is anti-team.


Loyalty does not exist in American life any more. Husbands and wives are not faithful and loyal to each other. Employers fire workers who want to stick with them and work hard and workers leave employers who are good to them . Coaches lie to players to recruit them and players are now lying to coaches to leave them. Nobody cares about anybody else but themselves....So why even assume loyalty.
Posted by Sampson
Drusilla and Jefferson
Member since Mar 2012
24947 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:44 am to
You’re just posting this bc of how LSU is currently doing in the portal. I ain’t mad it, but it’s still a certified shite show.
Posted by Tammany Tom
Mandeville
Member since Jun 2004
4157 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:48 am to
quote:

It’s good for the individual but bad for teams. It is anti-team. It is me, me, me.


Interesting how everyone is so hypocritical when it comes to sports and their own lives. No one wants to “have” to stay at a company for 3-4 years when other companies want you and are willing to pay you a lot more. But… everyone wants athletes to have to stay and not have options.

I look at it like this. LSU has major advantages that most schools don’t.
1. Talent Rich state & no in-state competition
2. They belong to the most prestigious and richest conference in the country.
3. They have a very passionate fan base that is very willing to go above and beyond to support the program.

Now… it’s all about building a winning culture where most kids don’t want to leave even when given the opportunity.

Lots of companies don’t lose top end talent, even when other companies come after their talent. Why? Great culture to work at.

It’s the same in football. You build a culture where the players thrive in, love being a part in, and they are making great money, most aren’t leaving.
Posted by Cleary Rebels
Member since Oct 2024
2899 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:48 am to
It’s still anti-team. Team used to be bleed purple and gold, sweat together, face ups and downs together and persevere. Work each year to get better as a player. Now you just jump ship. All the things you mentioned are true, but that doesn’t mean it’s not anti-team. Sports are socialism and portal is capitalism. I never said it was wrong, just that it’s anti-team first.
Posted by Cleary Rebels
Member since Oct 2024
2899 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:52 am to
How is saying it’s good for individual and bad for team any of that you mentioned? What’s good for the team isn’t always good for individual and vice verse. I’m not against portal, just stating is more for individual than team. Teams are socialism, just like your family. Capitalism is individual. Thats the way it is.
Posted by Tiger Prawn
Member since Dec 2016
23810 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:55 am to
Joe Burrow was before the transfer portal. He transferred to LSU via the old fashioned way. The only reason he was able to play immediately for LSU without having to sit a year was because he was a graduate transfer.
Posted by TigerBR1111
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2014
7604 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 11:57 am to
quote:

They are still developing. Just not at one school but at multiple schools.


Exactly. What a pleasure it has been to watch TJ Finley develop at five different schools.
Posted by Howyouluhdat
On Fleek St
Member since Jan 2015
8263 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 12:08 pm to
Nobody said the portal itself is bad numbnuts. It’s the ability to transfer as many times as you want with no penalty. Thats absolutely ridiculous that they allow this to happen. It’s even more bizarre that people pay these players that could be gone shortly after they arrive on campus and have provided zero product
Posted by bayou85
Concordia
Member since Sep 2016
9559 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 12:32 pm to
NIL and TP aren’t inherently bad for CFB. It’s the lack of rules around them. NCAA is intentionally not doing anything. Limit transfers. Set up enforceable rules around tampering. Set up rules around amounts players can earn. Hell, set rules around paying coaches too damn much.
Posted by The Hurricane
Gulf of Mexico
Member since Aug 2011
8881 posts
Posted on 12/22/24 at 12:34 pm to
Rules need to be established so that you don’t have student athletes transferring 4-5 times.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 4Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram