re: Navy officer applies to become the first ever woman to join the elite SEALs

quote:

---

If we're going to talk about it, you should at least read it. If you aren't willing to do that, just say so.

---

Why don't you tell us the results that prove women should be in combat arms.

GI Jane, baws




BTW, no woman is going to make it through BUD/S without help or special treatment. The Marine Corps already has two separate boot camps. I suspect we'll see that with the SEALs one day (which will completely ruin the SEALS just as the Marines have been ruined).

quote:

---

Are you going to read it, or not?

---

Intellectual laziness is not an attractive trait lady.

What I'm getting at, is this report that has been trumpeted by several people in this thread, is something most of them haven't even looked at.

Let her apply and try to pass the test with no special qualifications. If she makes it, good. If she doesn't, it's not because she didnt't try.

quote:

---

I'm getting at, is this report that has been trumpeted by several people in this thread, is something most of them haven't even looked at.

---

that's a nice Dodge but you're on a message board having a discussion and rather than point to the evidence you believe exists you want people to halt discussion so that they can read a 978 page document before you'll go any further

It's pretty obvious when you're doing. You are certain you have supporting evidence in the document. Then point to it

I don't think it's unreasonable to ask someone that called me a liar to read this report.

quote:

---

I don't think it's unreasonable to ask someone that called me a liar to read this report.

---

You've lied about more than just the report.

quote:

---

Another dodge. Surprise.

---

The report is 978 pages. The summary is four pages. You really expect me to go through it with you page by page?

The whole study discussion is a farce anyways. If it were true than women could perform on male teams requiring physical prowess without degrading the operational capability of the male teams then we would have women in the major leagues women in the NFL and women in the NBA

At least a couple of them. But heck we don't even have women men's soccer.

The reality is that the best female football player alive couldn't start for any Division 1 program much less the NFL

The best female baseball player alive would be completely non-competitive at the College World Series

And the best woman's basketball player alive would be a liability on even mediocre college basketball teams

I'm not entirely sure what I study can tell you that real life hasn't already told you