Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message

Serious question about coronavirus testing

Posted on 3/28/20 at 6:26 am
Posted by Geekboy
Member since Jan 2004
4961 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 6:26 am
They are saying Germany has around 0.6% death rate and Italy has over a 10% death rate. The reason Germany’s is lower is because of a stark difference in testing regimes.
My question is why does early testing help? If you’ve got the virus, you got the virus. Test or no test.
Posted by Powerman
Member since Jan 2004
162219 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 6:30 am to
quote:

They are saying Germany has around 0.6% death rate and Italy has over a 10% death rate. The reason Germany’s is lower is because of a stark difference in testing regimes.
My question is why does early testing help? If you’ve got the virus, you got the virus. Test or no test.

In theory you could test random people that have no symptoms and get some positives

If you add in a big chunk of asymptomatic but CV19 confirmed cases it makes the denominator a lot bigger

I think in most countries you only get tested if you are showing some symptoms
Posted by Fun Bunch
New Orleans
Member since May 2008
115738 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 6:30 am to
Another difference could be how they report deaths. What is actually a “coronavirus” death?

We are seeing that in Louisiana right now.
Posted by Hot Carl
Prayers up for 3
Member since Dec 2005
59072 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 6:31 am to
Perhaps you should stop starting threads this morning, guy. You just don’t have it today. Happy Saturday, though.
Posted by LSU1018
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2007
7220 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 6:32 am to
I think Germany is qualifying their deaths differently. If someone has a preexisting condition, they are using that as cause of death instead of corona.
Posted by Powerman
Member since Jan 2004
162219 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 6:33 am to
To clarify my previous post they might tell you in Italy to not even seek out a test unless your symptoms are pretty significant.

Germany on the other hand might be testing more mild cases in addition to the serious ones
Posted by 4cubbies
Member since Sep 2008
50142 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 6:36 am to
quote:

My question is why does early testing help? If you’ve got the virus, you got the virus. Test or no test.


Early testing helps for controlling the spread. If you know you have it, theoretically, you’ll self quarantine and not infect others.
Posted by dallastigers
Member since Dec 2003
5707 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 6:43 am to
More likely to pick up the infections that are mild and moderate that people thought were something else. Also more asymptomatic positive cases tested due to possible contact or some other reason. Rate is a % of infected totals. Increase those and rate goes down, but not necessarily actual deaths.

With early testing part due to high testing numbers (don't have to ration to just test most likely and most sick) you also are more likely to catch early enough to hopefully avoid mistreating as something else, and you stop more infected including mild and asymptomatic and beginning symptoms from infecting others but especially those with other conditions that are more likely to die from virus (as without test they don't know they have it or think it's a cold or allergies at first).
This post was edited on 3/28/20 at 6:48 am
Posted by Geekboy
Member since Jan 2004
4961 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 7:04 am to
THANK YOU!!!
Posted by aTmTexas Dillo
East Texas Lake
Member since Sep 2018
15055 posts
Posted on 3/28/20 at 7:11 am to
quote:

My question is why does early testing help? If you’ve got the virus, you got the virus. Test or no test.


I think this relates to undetected community spread and not knowing the number of infected individuals. A rigorous early testing program could possibly lead to more severe distancing and quarantining programs. It is to get the infected out of the population and quarantined before they can pass it along. I have no idea if this is the reason Germany has lower death rates. I suspect it has nothing to do with the genetics of Germans versus Italians.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram