re: Idaho Murders Thread (Links inside)

quote:

---

It would be really odd for someone to hate all 4 of these people enough to kill them. I could see a jilted lover killing the dude and the girlfriend but not the other two girls.

---

You never know. I wouldn't think girls would do some of the stuff they have. Like the twelve year olds that stabbed their friend nearly to death cause they thought they could go live with slender man.

Bitches be crazy too.

quote:

---

The local cops will try and do this themselves and botch the whole thing just like the Gabby Pitino fiasco

---

Yep, especially in a small town where shite like this never happens.

quote:

---

It takes some strength and a ton of conviction to shove a knife through a man’s chest or slice a throat through the trachea. It’s not like the movies. Whoever did this had a shite ton of hate for these people or is a flat out psychopath. I have my doubts that a college girl could pull it off (referring to the two living roommates).

---

Yeah that was my thought too. I’ve got a morbid curiosity about the nature of the wounds as well. To do it in such a manner that no one else would be awakened by the screams? And 4 times at that?

quote:

---

Yeah that was my thought too. I’ve got a morbid curiosity about the nature of the wounds as well. To do it in such a manner that no one else would be awakened by the screams? And 4 times at that?

---

And what kept the other two girls safe in their rooms? Locked doors? Sated killer?

I'm sure it's been said already, but here's my theory...the two roommates who were home orchestrated it. There was some divide between them and the other four, potentially related to guy who lives in the house (1 guy living with 5 girls?!) or something stupid like rent. The girls had one or two other guys come over when everyone was home and commit the murders. Because it's just too weird that:

1) They were home and not harmed, so what would link the four to get them killed but not the other two?
2) They allegedly didn't hear anything
3) They didn't call 911, or at least didn't until noon the next day
4) The girls were at one place and the couple was at a different place, so the killer had to know when all four were home (the roommates would've known when their other 4 roommates were back)
5) The killers did not force their way in, so the roommates theoretically could've unlocked the door or supplied the code, assuming it wasn't just open already

I mean, it would make as much sense as anything at this point.

quote:

---

The girls had one or two other guys come over when everyone was home and commit the murders. Because it's just too weird that

---

So 4 people know the truth? And they found not one, but two guys willing to viciously murder 4 other college kids because of late rent or drama?

I mean this isn’t hitman shite. This is vicious. Killing someone with a bladed weapon is messy and not always slow or simple or quiet.

And what were they giving in return for these brutal murders? A blowjob and some titty pics?


Just doesn’t make sense

They were saying on the news this morning that it was a large, fixed-blade knife, probably military style. They said they had spoken to a profiler, who thinks it is a pseudo military type, probably wearing bdu's, a vest, and probably some kind of high hiking boot.

They said they feel the knife was a recent purchase and were combing stores that sell that type.

You can get mail-order Kabars.

It could involve the fact that Kaylee just arrived the day of the murders with an new Range Rover auto to show it off to her friend Madison. Kaylee and Mafison were friends since middle school (from reports) they both went on trips together with family -- places sometimes far away. Maybe these two friends rubbed their stories a little too much for someone.
From the looks --- they had everything

Maybe someone did the job and was leaving , only to encounter the guy.
The killer gets him and then his girlfriend.

Jealousy could be the culprit

Man I mean I didn’t really entertain the idea of random psycho but it could be

I mean nothing else makes sense?

Just the fact that you were brutally murdered but earlier in the night some guy in a crowd acted a little strange around you means he’s the killer.

I mean think of how many weird guys are hovering around a group of girls at FmMs or Bogies.

I don’t think food truck man hovered around two girls; had a gregarious conversation with people right behind the girls; try to say goodnight to them…. Then off camera followed them home; butchered them and then two other people in the house just out of the blue.



Also like I said earlier. In regards to the profiler thinking the knife was a recent purchase.

There is like an outdoor supply store in town and the police have been there multiple times asking if they sell KABAR (?) brand knifes. They do not.

Psychotic schizo drifter?

Police rule out roommates, food truck bystanders as suspects