Started By
Message

What's the deal with old TV shows using the same actor numerous times in different roles?

Posted on 11/1/26 at 2:51 pm
Posted by Tampa Ray
Member since Oct 2026
481 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 2:51 pm
Allan Melvin appeared on The Andy Griffith Show 8 times and played 8 different characters.
It was the #1 show on Television for years, it's not like they couldn't afford new actors for those roles.
Didn't people back then think it was stupid that one week he's the butcher, the next month he's an escaped convict etc.?

Just seems weird, I mean 8 appearances and 8 different characters?




Posted by Bestbank Tiger
Premium Member
Member since Jan 2005
84181 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 2:54 pm to
Sam Waterston was an opposing defense attorney and S. Epatha Merkerson was the mother of a baby who was killed when a tPOS shot up the wrong house.

The producers of Law & Order liked their performances so much they returned as regular characters.
Posted by indytiger
Krotz Springs
Member since Oct 2004
10291 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 2:57 pm to
When I ready your post title, I pictured Allan Melvin in my head.

Baywatch did it a lot too.
Posted by Tampa Ray
Member since Oct 2026
481 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 3:01 pm to
quote:

Baywatch did it a lot too


But Andy Griffith was an intelligent show, a classic.
Baywatch was brainless nonsense where people just tuned in for boobs.
Posted by genro
Member since Nov 2011
62777 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 3:01 pm to
quote:

Didn't people back then think it was stupid that one week he's the butcher, the next month he's an escaped convict etc.?
No people knew it wasn't real. They even called it the Andy Griffith show even though the character was Andy Taylor. This is a pretend play on television and everyone understands
Posted by Tampa Ray
Member since Oct 2026
481 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 3:05 pm to
quote:

No people knew it wasn't real.


People today know it's not real.
But to use the same actor 8 times for 8 different roles just seems retarded.
Posted by mauser
Orange Beach
Member since Nov 2008
28376 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 3:07 pm to
I read where some supporting actress said that you can work in this town if you can do 3 things, show up on time, know your lines, and don't cause any trouble. I assume an ability to act is taken for granted.

I assume Mr. Melvin was on time, knew his lines, and was easy to work with, which the producers appreciated and remembered.
Posted by genro
Member since Nov 2011
62777 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 3:14 pm to
Andy Griffith was already famous and they used his real name. "It's the Andy Griffith starring Andy Griffith!" and then his character's name was Taylor. It was well established right off the bat. No one thought it was real. I think you are backwards. Escapism, immersion and maintaining the 4th wall are more important now.
Posted by ouflak
Manchester, England
Member since Jul 2021
681 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 3:22 pm to
This happens a lot in the Star Trek franchise. I never minded it. Some of the range of these actors is impressive.
Posted by S
RIP Wayde
Member since Jan 2007
176404 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 3:26 pm to
Walker texas ranger had a few different actors play different supporting roles throughout the show. This dude played like 5 different villains.

Posted by coolpapaboze
Parts Unknown
Member since Dec 2006
22666 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 3:35 pm to
quote:

Baywatch was brainless nonsense where people just tuned in for boobs.


Posted by FredBear
Georgia
Member since Aug 2017
17882 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 3:47 pm to
The Fugitive did this some also. I know Richard Anderson appeared in several episodes. He also appeared in numerous Rifleman episodes
Posted by AtticusOSullivan
Member since Mar 2016
3181 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 4:04 pm to
Isnt that the bad guy from Roadhouse?
Posted by Kafka
I am the moral conscience of TD
Member since Jul 2007
160674 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 4:07 pm to
It's fascinating how this is such an issue w/the modern generation

Not only did the previous generations not give a frick, but they actually looked forward to seeing Frank Nelson or Mel Blanc w/Jack Benny.

A fave of mine was Richard Stahl, who played 9 different characters on The Odd Couple



IMHO this issue is due to:

1) binge watching, when people see an actor as a different character as soon as a few hours later instead of months having passed

2) serialized storylines, as in soap operas, which increase the audience thinking the actor is the character
Posted by Jay Are
Baton Rouge
Member since Nov 2014
6563 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 5:18 pm to
quote:

IMHO this issue is due to:

1) binge watching, when people see an actor as a different character as soon as a few hours later instead of months having passed

2) serialized storylines, as in soap operas, which increase the audience thinking the actor is the character


Was going to post something very similar.

Obsession with serialized continuity and lore is very recent.
Posted by MorbidTheClown
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2015
77360 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 5:24 pm to
Gunsmoke did this all of the time. One episode jack elam is a deadly gun fighter. Next episode he is a dirt poor nobody
Posted by molsusports
Member since Jul 2004
37885 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 5:26 pm to
MASH did this a lot. Including with the actor who would later become Sherman T Potter

It isn't the same thing but cartoons obviously do this all the time with voice actors too.
Posted by 9rocket
Member since Sep 2020
1877 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 5:27 pm to
I came here to say Gunsmoke. They are who I thought of when I read the thread title.
Posted by S
RIP Wayde
Member since Jan 2007
176404 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 5:29 pm to
Yup
Posted by putt23
Pingree Grove, IL
Member since Oct 2010
5600 posts
Posted on 11/1/26 at 5:29 pm to
quote:

Isnt that the bad guy from Roadhouse?


And the pilot of one of the shuttles in Armageddon.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•X•Instagram