re: True Detective S1E5 "The Secret Fate of All Life"

quote:

---

Re: Decatur's theory,

---

To be clear, my theory at the present time only goes so far as Marty being Dora's killer. Although I have speculated, I do not yet claim Marty is a serial killer or the head of a cult. I do not see enough support for that yet. There's still more evidence to come though. We'll have to see where it leads.

quote:

---

this poster on reddit sums it up:

---

quote:

---

Why do you think Marty killed Dora only?

---

I haven't settled on a motive yet but I can imagine a lot of possibilities. And I don't have enough info on Marty yet to technically classify him as a "suspect" (enough info to go arrest him), that's why I've referred to him as "person of interest". I still think he did it though. That's not saying I think for sure that he only killed Dora, just waiting for more support on the serial killer theory (which by the way requires at least three victims technically).

quote:

---

What about Reggie's GF with the same wounds and spiral mark?

---

I don't think Reggie did it. And I'm not sure that Marty did it (if it was indeed a murder). But it wouldn't be outside of the realm of the possible that Marty has seen that case file before or that Marty has some connection with Ledoux/Dora/Rianne that the audience hasn't been clued in on yet. Still more connections that need to be drawn on this.

quote:

---

after episode 8 is over will you please reveal your official theory for once and all? or will you need to test it some more?

---

It's posts like this that eat up space in these threads

Truthfully I have a theory that this Series will end with a puzzle and it may continue the speculation afterwards. While he was being smart arse, he has a point.

quote:

---

As opposed to the mountain of evidence supporting that he killed Dora? And what is exactly your support for that? All you have done is state that it is your theory and not why it is your theory. Also, you never responded to my inquiry about your seemingly forgotten dinner theory. Put up or shut up, yo.

---

I'm really hoping he is just trolling these threads, otherwise when the series ends he'll have to come to the realization that he is truly a moron.

quote:

---

All you have done is state that it is your theory and not why it is your theory.

---

You can read my post history on this board. I'm not repeating all of that in a single post.

quote:

---

your seemingly forgotten dinner theory.

---

Yeah, I had a problem with that scene until it became more apparent how mixed up the timeline is. I still think there could be something to that. Gilbough and Papania asked both Rust and Marty about it. Would not surprise me if they ask Maggs about it. I guess we'll see what she has to say about it if they ask her.

Could be the key to everything.

quote:

---

Put up or shut up, yo.

---

Hey, I don't see anyone else putting their nutsack on the chopping block

Talk about intuition, Rust supposedly can spend 5 minutes with someone and know if they are guilty. So he would have to know that Marty is guilty. So that kinda of blows up the whole they are working together theory.

quote:

---

So that kinda of blows up the whole they are working together theory.

---

I don't know if they worked together after they stopped being partners in 2002.

I do know that Gilbough and Papania looked at each other when Marty answered that he had not seen Rust in 10 years, as if they did not believe him. So it's possible they had further contact.

I'd venture to guess that just about every time Gilbough and Papania look at each other like that they think the interviewee is not being completely truthful with them.

quote:

---

I think I'm in your head now

---

Your stupidity is entrancing.

ETA: and it has been a nice respite from dealing with the FDA. Some of their questions and concerns were very tough to answer, so being able to deal with your dumb, ignorant bull shite gave my huge, amazing brain time to relax.