re: Game of Thrones S4:E8:"The Mountain and the Viper", HODORS ONLY no book readers

molsusports Member since Jul 2004



CocomoLSU Member since Feb 2004



Old fart Thunderdome...........lets get it on...

One things for sure GoT threads cause everyone to hate each other on the Movie/TV board for 11 weeks every spring/early summer.

#TeamSquashedViperHead

quote:

---

One things for sure GoT threads cause everyone to hate each other on the Movie/TV board for 11 weeks every spring/early summer.

---

And to a lesser extent The 13 walking dead threads in the fall and winter.

oh stop being such a dishonest drama queen.

I can tell from your post history you express considerable and consistent concern about information from the books being leaked into these threads... and yet you seem to post in places which no person with this type of obsession should be.

Namely your post history shows you post in (and therefore read) the book maesters threads. You seem like you are a dick and a hypocrite.

Yeah...I didn't think them both dying was crazy...I just thought it was lame and would not happen.

Fwiw we haven't seen that he's dead yet. We know he was stabbed and poisoned but his death isn't as sure as Oberyn's ( )

quote:

---

Fwiw we haven't seen that he's dead yet. We know he was stabbed and poisoned but his death isn't as sure as Oberyn's ( )

---

Oberyn might be ok.

That still gets me

Damn...if the Mountain isn't dead that will be shitty. Not sure how he could live through that though. He got gutted + poisoned.

quote:

---

oh stop being such a dishonest drama queen.

---

quote:

---

I can tell from your post history you express considerable and consistent concern about information from the books being leaked into these threads... and yet you seem to post in places which no person with this type of obsession should be.

Namely your post history shows you post in (and therefore read) the book maesters threads.

---

I post in Hodor threads. I posted in the bookreader thread one day to clarify something about me to someone and that's it. Other than that, I stay clear of that thread. I'm not sure I've ever posted in the Middle Ground thread, but I would have no problems doing so if I had a question that I wanted/needed answered by someone in that thread. Other than that, I am strictly in this thread. So I'm not sure where you're getting your baseless fricking bullshite accusations from.

quote:

---

You seem like you are a dick and a hypocrite.

---

You seem like you should go frick yourself. I won't say that I'm not a dick, especially on here sometimes. But I'm certainly not a hypocrite. You want to say all of these made up things that I'm doing, yet they're not true.

And let's not forget there were MASSIVE amounts of RAs on this thread because people were posting legitimate spoilers here and there. And that was LONG before I joined in on the thread (which wasn't until Tuesday I believe). And converstaion/discussion was going on just fine until people started bringing up other crackpot theories that they read on other sites and whatnot...and my only point with saying something then was to make sure we didn't cross into spoiler territory (not that we had already done so).

Also, as someone already pointed out, LOTS of things have been spoiled in the Hodor threads, so it's not like there isn't a reason for people to be gun-shy about things sometimes...and that includes readers posting in here pretending to be Hodors and magically "guessing" everything that is coming down the pipe.

And please also don't forget that I said one time, very briefly (less than a page?) to be wary of crossing into spoilers, yet others have bitched many times throughout this thread about it where I haven't even been around and posting.

But I guess you can keep ignoring the things I'm actually saying and keep focusing on the bullshite you're making up to try make your points. Either way, I'll be here to defend them if need be.

quote:

---

I mean if you have two posters, one a reader posing as a hodor and one a true hodor, who post the same "theories" that happen to come true then it's easy to say both guys spoiled you.

Truthfully, in this thread at least, you don't know what is or isn't a spoiler/correct theory until it happens on the show.

If you truly want to avoid what many here perceive to be "spoilers" then you should just avoid the GoT threads all together because with discussion comes speculation. And sometimes speculations is proven true. Doesn't mean it was a spoiler.

It was not a crackpot theory to suggest that both the mountain and Oberyn were/are going to die.

---

FWIW, I agree with all of that. And it's one reason why I don't read the GoT threads until after I watch the episode, if at all. And I also don't think it was out of the ordinary to think taht both Oberyn and Mountain could've died either. I don't want intentional spoilers to be posted, but that =/= someone guessing right...those are two different things. And believe it or not, I'm not on a witch hunt by any means...I'd just like to keep the discussion between people who haven't read the books at all and people who have completely separate (aside from the MG thread).