re: Why not in favor of playoff.

quote:

---

Regular season is the playoff

---

Also, the playoff just isn't practical. Fans aren't going to travel to multiple playoff games. It's just too expensive now. I think the excitement and controversy that the BCS creates is fun and enjoyable. Even if we had a playoff, there would still be EXACTLY the same complainers that we already have. The person who said the comment about someone in the SEC not going to Atlanta but then getting into the playoff is right. I think that possibility is ridiculous. Leave the playoffs to FCS and basketball.

LINK

can't see asking kids to risk injury in extra game and losing shot at NFL, because fans think they are justified in demanding playoff.

also, I became big time fan in my late forties, due in large part to all the controversy. like it they way it is.

People, what you all fail to understand is that the BCS IS in fact, a playoff. Hear me out, rantards...Think about it, every week of the season is a playoff, but even better. You can actually lose an early game and still play for a championship. In a playoff, its lose and go home. I know im in a minority, but I happen to love college football EXACTLY the way it is. Take care of business in the regular season and you play for the crystal ball. Its that simple.

quote:

---

Playoff would be bad for the SEC. That is what we play for, not the MNC. Win the SEC (or die trying), then see where you are when the smoke clears. I dislike the fact that you could be left out of Atlanta but be in the playoffs.

---

You would have to win your conference to get in the playoffs. Obviously. This is not an issue.

quote:

---

First of all, how do you decide which teams get in? Are we talking about the top 4 teams or the top 8 teams? What about the 5th and the 9th who might be .0001 points behind the 4th or 8th place teams? Computer formulas will still be used to calculate which teams get in; they have to be. Coaches poll is so damn stupid: coaches don't watch every damn game to determine who's the better teams. Sportswriters are biased. West Coast Press sucks West Coast Team Dicks. ESPN sucks USC dick.

---

You have an 8 team playoff. You take the 6 BCS conference champs and 2 non BCS conference champs.

No formulas. No unfairness. No press. No advertising.

Conference champions only.

quote:

---

Secondly, how much money do the fans have? Can you afford to take off of work and travel to see your team play in the playoffs for 3 games? If not, do you go to the first game only and not the others? Do you wait to see if your team wins the first round before traveling? What if they lose? How many people would make that decision? This does not bode well for teams with strong fan bases that follow the team, i.e. the SEC.

---

First, they do it is basketball.

Second you can watch it on tv. The tv revenue from this would be massive.

Third, they could have the first game at the higher seeded teams stadium if needed.

quote:

---

There's always going to be controversy, just deal with it

---

Why? There is minimal controversy in the basketball tourny. If you have an 8 team playoff, a team left out would have very little reason to cry. The necessary things to get into the playoffs are pretty clear.

A playoff system would minimize the controversy.

quote:

---

Regular season is the playoff

---

It is an insufficient playoff obviously. That is why we need a true playoff.

quote:

---

Leave it alone! I can't afford to go to 3 playoff games. This is not basketball with 2000 fans traveling to the NCAA regionals with 2 games in one building. This is 30000 fans trying to go to Miami, then Dallas, then Atlanta. It will never work.

---

Those who could go would go. Those that couldn't go would watch it on tv. Kinda like now. What is the big deal?

quote:

---

The only thing I have against a play off would be when in ends up three sec teams in it, we end up having to play eachother again to advance.

---

It couldn't happen. You have to win your conference.

quote:

---

You can't say it is magnified at all. Generally you have what...3 teams, 4 tops arguing for the 2 spots. You open it up to 4 or 8 and you have more teams arguing. There are always more 1-loss teams than there are 2-loss teams (obviously). So instead of having 4 teams vying for 2 spots you will have 10-15 teams shooting for 8 and considering they will have at most 2 losses, the argument becomes harder to make.

---

Not necessary. Win your conference or don't play. Easy. No controversy.

And this adds to the importance of the whole regular season. You have to win your conference.

No controversy. Just win and move one. That is how it should be.

quote:

---

they do it is basketball.

---

Stop with the basketball tournament crap. 30,000 fans don't travel to 3 different basketball sites over a 3 week period. Have you seen the 1st round NCAA arenas lately? 15,000 seat arenas aren't even full. Attendance for these games would be mostly local businesses and corporate sponsors. Yes, this is also the case with BCS games, but at least each team's school has 20,000 regular Joe fans in the stadium. It wouldn't be like that with a playoff.

quote:

---

in my opinion a playoff would take away from the "beauty" of college football. every game is a must win. so i vote no playoff

---

Finally, a good argument against a playoff. Personally, I'm in favor of a playoff, but I do see your point.