re: Settle an argument for me. Who was the best receiver at LSU among these...

You continue to hone in on one specific stat to push a bias. A stat btw that has never been used to comprehensively rank WRs by anyone. It’s your own personal agenda and that’s fine but I didn’t argue your opinion, I simply pointed out that Reed had more yards. Your reaction to that correction was emotional.

Landry
Chase
Clayton
Carson

quote:

---

Lmfao yes I can read and yes that statement is still false.

---

When Reed had 94 catches how many yards did he have?

1740

How many did chase have through 84 catches?

1780

Reed had 24 more touches.
Fact is Chase did more with his catches than Reed did. We just threw more to Reed because we had less options.

And if you want to talk about traditional stats.

How about TDS?

Is 20 more than 7?

Oh yeah Chase had more TDS in 2019 than Reed had in his entire career.

This isn’t bias. This is just looking at the numbers. Chase did more with the ball in his hands. He scored more.

This is how silly the YPC argument is. Reed went for 239 yards on 14 catches and that brought his YPC down. That’s how stupid that argument is.



Btw spamming the board with downvotes just proves you’re acting like an unhinged pre teen girl

quote:

---

This is how silly the YPC argument is. Reed went for 239 yards on 14 catches and that brought his YPC down. That’s how stupid that argument is.

---

Here’s how silly you’re argument is. Reed caught 94 carches and still only had 40 less yards than Chase. Putting the ball in chases hands got you more yards and more TDS.

quote:

---

Btw spamming the board with downvotes just proves you’re acting like an unhinged pre teen girl

---

I’m sure some third party is downvoting my posts. Change your tampon.

Well Sammy says he had 250 targets in 2001 so with about 400 targets in 2019 he’d probly have 160 catches for 3,000 yards.

Any list that doesn’t have Josh Reed in the top 2 is flat out wrong.

He doesn’t care about the actual on field production. He adds and subtracts numbers and games to try and create a narrative that doesn’t fit the facts. It’s explicit bias with zero objectivity. That’s Sammy in a nutshell

You mean like you refuse to acknowledge the fact that we threw 150 more passes in 2019 or that Reed had more yards in fewer games, the rules were different and the offense was different? Plus I never refused to acknowledge the TDs, once again you’re deflecting and making straw men. Do you understand that Chase and Reed basucally played different positions? Reed was the #1 option and had much more expansive route responsibilities than Chase, who was mainly a boundary WR and the #2 target in that offense. Of course not you can’t be objective since you have no interest in an honest comparison.

“Try and find another WR with that many catches while maintaining a 21 YPC average.”


Did you try to find another WR who averaged 18+ YPC on 114 catches or is that statement just another double standard?