re: Reality of Miles tenure at LSU

Most Players on NFL rosters = LSU

That proves Miles can't coach with anybody's players

There is so much good in this thread, especially the first post, that Im going to bump this for eternity to drive home what us "negatigers" have been saying for, in some cases, years.

Anchor away admin.
Heres the first one.


BUMP

Geauxgurt, I wish I could argue your point, but you nailed it.

quote:

---

This is just stupid.

LSU was 4-7 and then 2-8 in the two years prior to Saban's arrival.

You know you're comparing apples to oranges. You're just being retarded.

---

it's futile. stop wasting your time. they won't say we were 7-1 sec in 2003 though. they assume he would not win big with all the talent he left for les. it's laughable. if they think he would not have a better sec record than les, especially since 1-9 they are beyond help. Yep, he has not won big at bama either!

quote:

---

Larry Coker agrees with you. Won a NC. Never had a losing season. Only lost more than 3 games once. I have no idea why he was fired!!!!

Maybe, just maybe, it had to do with his teams slowly going backwards.

---

considering how Miami fared after firing Coker, I wonder if they regret that

quote:

---

Larry Coker agrees with you. Won a NC. Never had a losing season. Only lost more than 3 games once. I have no idea why he was fired!!!!

---

you should never fire a coach who has won a natty!

signed

larry coker
mack brown
gene chizik
phil fulmer

quote:

---

Eroded it from what point?

---

From where Saban had it when he bolted for the NFL. If you can't see the program is in decline, there's no sense in reading/responding to anything you type. I'm not trying to be an arse, just being honest. You're obviously in denial and can't be reasoned with.

quote:

---

He's had more success than any other LSU coach.

---

THis only proves my point. Besides the fact we've only won 1 BCS title and 2 SEC titles in 11 years, we've went 14-10 in the SEC over the past 3 years, 9-9 against the West. So explain to me how his past and overall record is helping us NOW.. ??

quote:

---

they won't say we were 7-1 sec in 2003

---

LSU accomplishment and I'll say it proudly, along with

Miles had one better SEC season, 8-0.

5-3, Saban has 3, Miles has 3
6-2, Saban has 1, Miles has 5


Bottom line is if Miles had never done any better than Saban at LSU, he'd be gone long ago.

Carry on with your Saban circle jerk.

quote:

---

Since then, without Jimbo trained QBs, he's proven to be worse than Miles despite starting in a better position.

---

Les is even worse than Les. You're reaching

quote:

---

, because I'm capable of rational thought.

---

So 16 losses and 12 sec losses is great because the rest of the sec sucked?

15 losses and 12 sec losses is crap because the sec has gotten better?


I find it hard to believe you all would be ok woth losing 3 games every year as long as we won the west.


Saban lost more games during his tenure tha miles has the last 5 years and the sec is far better than it was under saban. In 2001 the second place west team was 7-5. If miles could win the west with 3 lossed or less he would have 9 west titles.

Comparatively if you gave saban a natiobal title for every 2 loss or less season he had at lsu he would still just have 1 Natty.

Saban at lsu never once faced a sec program that even made the title game. Miles has either been the winner or faced the title game participant the last 8 years.


Look im on board to let miles go. There is no need for lsu fans to shite on its own accomplishments just because you dont like the coach. Its ignorant as frick.