- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message

LSU-Baylor postgame column now on home page
Posted on 5/31/09 at 1:40 am
Posted on 5/31/09 at 1:40 am
You can also read it at The Carl Dubois Blog.
Mike, are you still awake? Why do I think the answer is yes?
Anyway, enjoy the rest of the regional, everyone.
Mike, are you still awake? Why do I think the answer is yes?
Anyway, enjoy the rest of the regional, everyone.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 1:51 am to lsurulz1515
Carl, you are taking the rantards waayyyyyyyyyy to seriously on here.........good article but no one with a brain is underestimating NOLA.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 2:08 am to L S Usetheforce
I hear you. It's just an observation based on what I hear from players and coaches, who I think take it more seriously than I do. They are not regulars here, and therefore less equipped to discern relative brainpower.
The overriding point, in my opinion, is overlooked when comparing players of different generations. The talk is usually about whether a guy today would be as effective against the revved-up bats of the mid to late '90s and things like that. I think intangibles have changed a lot too.
The overriding point, in my opinion, is overlooked when comparing players of different generations. The talk is usually about whether a guy today would be as effective against the revved-up bats of the mid to late '90s and things like that. I think intangibles have changed a lot too.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 2:12 am to Carl Dubois
Hey Carl, you're up pretty late for an old guy.

Posted on 5/31/09 at 2:13 am to Carl Dubois
Another great job Carl. Thanks bud. 
Posted on 5/31/09 at 2:22 am to GeorgeTheGreek
quote:
It's just an observation based on what I hear from players and coaches, who I think take it more seriously than I do. They are not regulars here, and therefore less equipped to discern relative brainpower.
Well, I'm kinda dissappointed then in Coach Maneiri and our players if they are taking the opinions of this messageboard seriously.
I mean I'm almost 27 years old, grew up in the age of the internet, and I'd have to say that as a competitor the only opinions that matter are the ones from your coaches and your teammates.....
Don't get me wrong, I see what your getting at in your article.......
In fact, maybe Tigerdroppings rantards are responsible for Nola's clutch performances in the postseason thus far........
Keep up the good work my man.
This post was edited on 5/31/09 at 2:33 am
Posted on 5/31/09 at 3:54 am to Carl Dubois
It's great to read intelligent writing and good wit on the Rant again. It's been lacking. Thanks for all you do, Carl. 
Posted on 5/31/09 at 6:35 am to Carl Dubois
Thanks for calling out the rantards Carl, but trust me when I tell you, they will always be rantards.

Posted on 5/31/09 at 6:45 am to L S Usetheforce
quote:
Well, I'm kinda dissappointed then in Coach Maneiri and our players if they are taking the opinions of this messageboard seriously.
Just how seriously the coach and players take the opinions here is debatable. But to me, the key point is that no human being, especially a teenage athlete, reacts indifferently to "opinions" along the lines of "so-and-so is a piece of shite, I hope he breaks his leg so someone else can play." Tell me a string of those garbage messages wouldn't get your hackles up if they were directed at you.
Obviously, it's lost on some people (of dubious intelligence to begin with) that we're talking about teenage amateur athletes here. It's not that they need to be babied if they're not performing well, but neither should the "I hope he gets injured" messages be condoned.
If someone isn't cutting it on the field, isn't it enough to just say "it's time to try someone else at (position)?" By all means, give some intelligent analysis to back your point—but leave the witless sarcasms, the immature rage and the injury wishes out of it.
I'm not directing this at you specifically, and I'm not accusing you of being one of these moronic posters. I'm just making a general point to anyone who engages in this type of behavior: these messages say a lot more about the messengers than they do about the players.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 7:00 am to Carl Dubois
quote:
Warren Morris never had to read a message board questioning whether he was a liability while batting as low as the nine-hole in the postseason for LSU.
WM wouldn't have been there hadn't he had a major injury. Apples and Oranges. Bad comparison and irrelevant.
quote:
Some of the most spirited debates about college baseball are whether teams in the 2000s could stay on the field with teams from 15, 20 and 25 years ago. Texas coach Augie Garrido said yes, that today's teams are better, are filled with players who have been coached better for more of their playing careers, and that's why the champions of today would beat the champions of yesterday.
So baseball has become sooooo advanced since 2000? This is a joke. Maybe, MAYBE since the mid-90's, but to say the champions in the 90's couldn't beat any champion of this decade is pure hyperbole. Weak. I know how hard LSU baseball worked and how well they were coached in the mid-90's. I saw how hard they worked. No team on LSU's campus worked harder than the baseball team. I saw it w/ my own eyes. Baseball then T&F were the hardest working teams by far in the mid-90's!
quote:
Almost without exception, the players who built LSU to Program of the Decade status in the late 1980s and into the 1990s didn't ask themselves the questions that must creep into players' minds today when they're signing autographs.
So today's players are mentally weaker than the players of the 80's and 90's yet they can beat any of those teams? OK.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 7:07 am to DP40
quote:That's not what he said.
So today's players are mentally weaker than the players of the 80's and 90's yet they can beat any of those teams? OK.
College baseball was a mere curiosity in Baton Rouge until Skip's arrival. Even nationally, notwithstanding Texas/USC's collective history.
Plus, you didn't have message boards, wall-to-wall coverage, and nearly as many fans interested in what a freshman SS was doing with the bat.
His point makes sense to me.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 7:17 am to Ice Cold
I'll say again:
"MUST"? OK, so today's players are wondering every time they are signing a autograph if this is the guy who criticized me on a message board? I don't buy today's players are that big of mental midgets. Sorry, I don't. I also don't think these guys have a whole lot of time, maybe not desire either, to read the rant.
quote:
the players who built LSU to Program of the Decade status in the late 1980s and into the 1990s didn't ask themselves the questions that must creep into players' minds today when they're signing autographs.
"MUST"? OK, so today's players are wondering every time they are signing a autograph if this is the guy who criticized me on a message board? I don't buy today's players are that big of mental midgets. Sorry, I don't. I also don't think these guys have a whole lot of time, maybe not desire either, to read the rant.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 7:23 am to themunch
quote:
Thanks for calling out the rantards Carl, but trust me when I tell you, they will always be rantards.
You can lead a ranter to enlightened information, but you can't make him think.
Nice article Carl.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 7:53 am to Good Times
Good Times, you are right on the money. Carl excellent article as usual. Austin Nola will be a LSU great. The rantards will be telling their grandchildren they saw him play in college!
:geauxtigers: :geauxtigers: :geauxtigers: :geauxtigers:
Posted on 5/31/09 at 8:21 am to Carl Dubois
This is one of your best columns ever, Carl. I hope some people on this board will realize how they hurt these kids who are working their butts off to please them. Like Coach Mainieri said, they can't be perfect.
Thanks, Carl.
Thanks, Carl.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 8:35 am to Carl Dubois
Carl, thanks for the great article. You are, as I have always said, the best sports writer I've read and sorely missed on the Advocate's sports pages. What fools...but that's another story.
I know I will get killed for saying this but here it is: I started checking on this site years before I joined hoping to get an occasional insight on some aspect of the games and frankly, to learn about nuances from people who know alot more about the games than I do. I love it all but am nuts for baseball, thus my devotion particularly to Carl's writing.
This board has deteriorated to the point of being almost unbearable and - here's a shout-out to Chicken - you're losing us, man. Trash talk about Lee last fall, and now Nola, just is not helpful. In Nola's case particularly, it shows how little these 'tards know about baseball generally and about the contributions he (and others) have made particularly. Become a student of the game and show a little humility.
So here's the disclamer: yes, I am somebody's mama (not Nola's and not any current Tiger's mama) and while these boys may not take YOU seriously or this board seriously, they take the game very seriously. They work their tails off from the time they are about 8 or 10 years old just to get the chance to walk onto a baseball field in high school - the quality of play is that good around here. They then work their tails off to stay on the teams they have to try out for every year. Parents make enormous sacrifices to give them the chance and in the case of somebody like Big Baby, somebody else steps in and sees to it that they get to practice and have the equipment they need. Do you not think that every mistake these kids make is burned into their brains? Did you ever just sit quietly by a kid when he comes home after he blows a play - when he can't do anything but grieve? No, you are too busy running to the rant to call him a piece of shite, Big man. What could you say to someone like Hanover who is struggling right now - to make him feel worse? Can you show just a little tiny bit of respect for the game, the commitment, and the struggle? Critique away - by all means, but leave the personal ad hominem attacks off.
There you go boys. Swing away. But I've needed to say that for a long time. Good luck tonight boys, I'll be there for you win or lose, just like always.
I know I will get killed for saying this but here it is: I started checking on this site years before I joined hoping to get an occasional insight on some aspect of the games and frankly, to learn about nuances from people who know alot more about the games than I do. I love it all but am nuts for baseball, thus my devotion particularly to Carl's writing.
This board has deteriorated to the point of being almost unbearable and - here's a shout-out to Chicken - you're losing us, man. Trash talk about Lee last fall, and now Nola, just is not helpful. In Nola's case particularly, it shows how little these 'tards know about baseball generally and about the contributions he (and others) have made particularly. Become a student of the game and show a little humility.
So here's the disclamer: yes, I am somebody's mama (not Nola's and not any current Tiger's mama) and while these boys may not take YOU seriously or this board seriously, they take the game very seriously. They work their tails off from the time they are about 8 or 10 years old just to get the chance to walk onto a baseball field in high school - the quality of play is that good around here. They then work their tails off to stay on the teams they have to try out for every year. Parents make enormous sacrifices to give them the chance and in the case of somebody like Big Baby, somebody else steps in and sees to it that they get to practice and have the equipment they need. Do you not think that every mistake these kids make is burned into their brains? Did you ever just sit quietly by a kid when he comes home after he blows a play - when he can't do anything but grieve? No, you are too busy running to the rant to call him a piece of shite, Big man. What could you say to someone like Hanover who is struggling right now - to make him feel worse? Can you show just a little tiny bit of respect for the game, the commitment, and the struggle? Critique away - by all means, but leave the personal ad hominem attacks off.
There you go boys. Swing away. But I've needed to say that for a long time. Good luck tonight boys, I'll be there for you win or lose, just like always.
Posted on 5/31/09 at 8:58 am to panda
A great articale Carl, The players today not only have to be the best on their team at what they do in order to play they also have to be thick skinned. I played back in the sixties and seventies and did not have to read anything like what is being said today about these players. They do not desreve it at all, I know first hand at what it takes to be go home and not sleep because of a play I did not make that I should have. It hurts because you let your team down that believes in you. The players that have earned the right to play have also eaned the respect from their team mates and because of that respect is what causes the hurt that that player feels when they let them down by not making a play that they know they should have. They do not need some ranter saying they hope he gets hurt in order for them be removed from the line-up. That is why I think this is a great article that needed to be written. Thanks Carl and

Posted on 5/31/09 at 9:26 am to CaseyMc2
Here's a little something, apropos of this thread, from CNN (used totally w/o permission so I'll probably get hauled off to Gitmo):
[Greene tells the story of an elderly lady remembering the patience of a local grocer each morning when sheand a friend came in his store and took forever to decide how to spend 5 cents. Then he comments:]
"Yet back then someone was gracious toward them --someone didn't rush them as they debated how to spend that precious nickel each Michigan morning. And now, in 2009, she sounded still thankful at the memory of it.
There's a lesson in that. In our current era, when offhanded cruelty at times seems to be the coin of the cultural realm, it may be worth giving a little thought to the idea that the small moments of people treating us with decency and empathy can last for a very long time -- that the echoes of kindness can be as loud as the echoes of callousness."
Read the rest of the essay on CNN.com
[Greene tells the story of an elderly lady remembering the patience of a local grocer each morning when sheand a friend came in his store and took forever to decide how to spend 5 cents. Then he comments:]
"Yet back then someone was gracious toward them --someone didn't rush them as they debated how to spend that precious nickel each Michigan morning. And now, in 2009, she sounded still thankful at the memory of it.
There's a lesson in that. In our current era, when offhanded cruelty at times seems to be the coin of the cultural realm, it may be worth giving a little thought to the idea that the small moments of people treating us with decency and empathy can last for a very long time -- that the echoes of kindness can be as loud as the echoes of callousness."
Read the rest of the essay on CNN.com
Back to top

8







