Started By
Message

re: Honey Badger's punt return blunder

Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:51 pm to
Posted by Sasquatch Smash
Member since Nov 2007
25845 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:51 pm to
quote:

That's if the ball went out the back of the endzone which it didn't.


It went out of bounds through the endzone, still would have been UGA's ball had it been called a fumble.
Posted by Good Times
Hill top in Tn
Member since Nov 2007
24454 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:52 pm to
quote:

I read on ESPN that it did go out the back of the endzone



Technically it went out on the side of the end zone near the ref with his hands up.
Posted by FamousAmos
Member since Feb 2010
3276 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:52 pm to
Its just payback for the Brad Wing call.
Posted by LSULaw2009
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2008
1734 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:53 pm to
quote:

would have been UGA's ball had it been called a fumble.


It would have been called an illegal forward pass as he threw it forward, the move was controlled.
Posted by bleedpg
Hot Springs Village, Arkansas
Member since Dec 2006
1234 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:54 pm to
quote:

Wasnt a block in the back- if u watch the end zone view u see he caught his shoulder. Dont be a hater.


Not a hater. I only saw the play twice and it looked like it could have been called a block in the back.

LSU won big. I'm just making conversation.
Posted by Grandmike
Houston, TX
Member since Jul 2009
693 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:56 pm to
Actually,looking at the replay, I thought he flipped the ball a smidge after the ball broke the plane of the goal line, ergo touchdown. In any event, it wasn't reviewed.
Posted by Good Times
Hill top in Tn
Member since Nov 2007
24454 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:56 pm to
quote:

It would have been called an illegal forward pass as he threw it forward, the move was controlled.



Or intentional grounding, since there was no receiver in the area?
Posted by windhammontanatigers
windham-stanford, montana
Member since Nov 2009
4993 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:56 pm to
Thank you for clearing this matter up and whoever said the ball went out of the back of the enczone is flat out lieing so Tigers bal l back at 10 or 15 and we score anyway. Thanks and Tiger fans please enjoy the victory.
Posted by tygertooth
Raleigh, NC
Member since Oct 2011
172 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:58 pm to
What if the punt return was called back. What if Oregon would have not have fumbled. What if Bama could kick a field goal. What if West Virginia could score touchdowns. What if Brantly wasn't injured. I am so sick of the lack of disrespect to our Tiger. LSU is undefeated and that is what counts SEC CHAMPS not what if's.
Posted by Godfather1
What WAS St George, Louisiana
Member since Oct 2006
87413 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:58 pm to
quote:

If that play had been reviewed it would have been Georgia's ball on the 20 yard line.


And Gary and Verne were practically pissing their pants pointing it out 20 minutes after the fact.
Posted by TheDude321
Member since Sep 2005
3244 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 8:58 pm to
All of you are wrong. The official had already signaled touchdown, and Mathieu was responding to the official when he released the ball. A replay cannot overturn players' responses to officiating. A common example of this is when an official accidentally whistles a play dead prematurely; the play is dead when the whistle blows, and a replay can't reverse that even if the player with the ball kept running long after the premature whistle was blown. A kind of similar situation occurred last year when T-Bob Hebert threw his helmet after the first "final" play (against Tennessee). Since the officials signaled "game over", he was allowed to commit an infraction without penalty, even though the game ended up being extended...
This post was edited on 12/3/11 at 9:04 pm
Posted by USMCTiger03
Member since Sep 2007
71176 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 9:00 pm to
quote:

If that play had been reviewed it would have been Georgia's ball on the 20 yard line.


What all these "analysts" fail to know:

"RULE 4, SECTION 1, ARTICLE 3. A live ball becomes dead and an official shall sound his whistle
or declare it dead: c. When a touchdown, touchback, safety, field goal or successful try occurs..."

As soon as the Ref signaled touchdown the ball was dead, play over, touchdown.
Posted by IceTiger
Really hot place
Member since Oct 2007
26584 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 9:00 pm to
He only pitched th e ball when the ref threw his hands up
Posted by bleedpg
Hot Springs Village, Arkansas
Member since Dec 2006
1234 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 9:01 pm to
I will enjoy the victory. Didn't mean to get the rant all fired up.



And if we play BAMA again we will win.

Good Night Yall
Posted by moneyg
Member since Jun 2006
61896 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 9:04 pm to
quote:

Actually,looking at the replay, I thought he flipped the ball a smidge after the ball broke the plane of the goal line,


You are either out of your mind or blind.
Posted by Tiger Dominance
Bossier City, LA
Member since Oct 2007
525 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 9:04 pm to



The replay camera wasn't in line with the goal line so it's hard to tell with 100% certaintly if the Honey Badger gave up the football before he crossed the goal line. If the play was reviewed, there is a good chance that the call on the field (touchdown) would have been upheld.
Posted by RockChalkTiger
A Little Bit South of Saskatoon
Member since May 2009
11022 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 9:06 pm to
Maybe illegal touching on the ref. he was standing out-of-bounds.
Posted by FamousAmos
Member since Feb 2010
3276 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 9:06 pm to
Posted by Lou the Jew from LSU
Member since Oct 2006
5221 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 9:20 pm to
I thought all plays are reviewed in cfb. Thus, there was no evidence to overturn. The ref had. True angle, you cannot always tell from a camera angle. Unless mounted Nd in direct line, a camera lens will bend light. That is why golf shots never look straight, even when they are.
They can dis this team all they want to. They just keep whippin arse an overwhelming opponents. We beat bama by 14
Posted by Hausko57
Big Ditch Road
Member since Oct 2011
7 posts
Posted on 12/3/11 at 9:25 pm to
Ok, maybe he dished the ball a bit early, but no one as said anything about the official right in front of him already signaling TD, maybe he saw him doing that and assumed he was in. If he dished it early, the official called it early! Either way its a W. nuff said
first pageprev pagePage 2 of 3Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram