re: *Armand Williams commits*

RS is one player...who else do we have that is FAST?

im not buying this shite people are saying. I still look back when saban was here and there were plenty of times and situations we lacked depth. the onnly position we have lacked under miles is oline. but the dline was so deep it didnt fricking matter. I will support any kid who suits up for lsu and gives it their all.

cant wait for this kid to tear it up

quote:

---

Barkley's upside is much much higher than JJ's. With Barkley, we would be a contender, not a pretender.

---

yeah you could say if we had tebow we would be a contender or if we had mallet we would. news flash the only two qbs we had that were highly rated were jmarc and perrilloux.

quote:

---

Good try, but surely you don't believe that yourself. Lets see who makes the most improvement next year, a sophmore, or junior. Barkley's upside is much much higher than JJ's. With Barkley, we would be a contender, not a pretender.

---

I was comparing the talents between them...USC has a better O-line (mostly Juniors and Seniors) and LSU has mostly Juniors...can you really consider Jefferson as a "sophomore"?? he started a full season at QB...just like Barkley

quote:

---

are you freaking dumb? TH had enough touches

---

I will not admit to being dumb but I feel Holiday was wasted as a player at LSU. He should have been a 10 touch per game guy not counting returns.
Look at the Arkansas game. He got 9 touches out of the RB position and ran for 60 yards and a TD.

quote:

---

How quickly people forget that in 2003 we had a freshman rb and a freshman safety starting.

---

and in 2003 saban was still building the program

quote:

---

and lets not forget daniels getting his rs taken off the last game of the year.

---

the SEC title game was not the last game

quote:

---

Does anyone remember clayton playing both sides of the ball?

---

for 1 game, and he got burnt

in 2002 we did not have the benefit of many years of top recruiting

quote:

---

but yet saban gets a pass and miles doesnt.

---

saban didn't take over LSU in 2005 like miles did

quote:

---

But we have no guys with pure gamebreaking speed on offense, seriously.

---

Russell Shepard?

quote:

---

Good try, but surely you don't believe that yourself. Lets see who makes the most improvement next year, a sophmore, or junior. Barkley's upside is much much higher than JJ's. With Barkley, we would be a contender, not a pretender.

---

And you know this how? Barkley had 15 TDs and 14 INTs this year playing against Pac 10 defenses. Jefferson had 17 TDs and 7 INTs against SEC defenses. Jefferson also had a better QB rating. Both have almost the same amount of experience. Maybe we would have been better with Barkley at QB, but there's zero chance that you can claim that for a fact.

quote:

---

Both have almost the same amount of experience

---

not even close, bub