Started By
Message

re: Sourdough Bread Eaters

Posted on 4/9/25 at 10:34 am to
Posted by KosmoCramer
Member since Dec 2007
79954 posts
Posted on 4/9/25 at 10:34 am to
quote:

What is it about that picture that tells you it is over-proofed rather than under or correctly proofed?


By looking at the crumb. It could be a variety of reasons why it's a little dense, not necessarily from incorrect proofing, but with his experience, that's what he's attributing it to.
Posted by BlueRabbit
Member since Apr 2025
133 posts
Posted on 4/9/25 at 11:40 am to
Well that’s pretty accurate too. This particular one was a bit longer bulk fermenting and the PH dropped a bit faster because the sun dried tomatoes have acid so they tend to proof quick and when I’m doing 40-50 at a time there is usually a few that tend to get away from me. Especially when it gets hot like it has been .

Those are friends breads. They are like cats doing figure 8’s under my feet looking for a free tad over-proofed bread. But they are my focus group and I trust their taste and judgement as too if one particular bread is good or not. And they ate a whole lot of crappy bread in the journey with me so it’s the least I can do.

The crumb can be manipulated a lot of ways the most typical is hydration. The higher the hydration the more open the crumb-hence more water to flour so more gas and openings in the crumb.

I bake the majority of mine at 70% hydration for several reasons-one I can use that percentage on almost all breads and depend on the outcome and two I can use that same
percentage and add inclusions both wet or dry and not really have to worry about changing. When I’m doing that many it’s hard to change and keep it consistent.

This bread not only has the acid from the tomatoes but the oil and liquid from the pesto and the extra salt from the Parmesan so the crumb typically stays a bit dense on this one.

I normally push the hydration up with fresh milled flours because they are able and need more water.

I’m not a big open crumb guy but I do like to try to get it pushed out to the water limits. Makes for some interesting bakes. Open crumbs and big ears make great Instagram pictures but if you want a sandwich your Mayo goes through the holes onto your counter. And the ears just rip my
bags. And it rips the dentures out of the little old ladies that buy it so I’ve got to keep my ladies happy. It’s their bread I’m making and their bread I’m taking.



Posted by BlueRabbit
Member since Apr 2025
133 posts
Posted on 4/10/25 at 10:06 pm to
I have a couple of smears I think add to sourdough really well.

Since the Masters is this weekend I’m making pimento cheese plain and smoked Gouda and this feta pistachio.

Man these are good.
Posted by BlueRabbit
Member since Apr 2025
133 posts
Posted on 4/13/25 at 2:12 pm to


Here is a 80% Red Fife Hard Red Wheat 20% Clarks Cream Hard White Wheat Heritage Grain bread. Flour milled fresh and nothing sifted so all bran and nutrition is intact. Amazing flavors of these old grains and as healthy as you can get. Easy to digest and great for gut health.

Nice to have fresh milled flours.
Posted by Tigerbait46
Member since Dec 2005
8050 posts
Posted on 4/16/25 at 10:37 pm to
Made time for another loaf this week. 15% KA medium rye, 45% Bob's whole wheat, 40% KA bread flour, ~75% hydration.

Had to cut BF short and throw it in the fridge for a day. Then let it sit out for a while before shaping and baking. No clue if I got the proofing right. It's a work in progress! Shaping was awkward. First time scoring with a lame didn't go as planned. Baked at 475 for 50 minutes uncovered. Tried adding boiling water in a pan to add steam but I think it all escaped before I closed the oven door. Final bread isn't "gummy" but does seem a bit moist and spongy if that makes sense. Is that normal when working with rye and whole wheat? In any case, it tastes decent enough, especially when toasted and slathered with butter. I've been using a rye starter but plan to revive my whole wheat one for the next loaf and leave out the rye flour to see what happens.




Posted by Tigerbait46
Member since Dec 2005
8050 posts
Posted on 4/16/25 at 10:53 pm to
Some inspiration... love these "day in the life" videos following artisans. The Japanese channel is a rabbit hole worth exploring.

This post was edited on 4/16/25 at 10:54 pm
Posted by Tigerbait46
Member since Dec 2005
8050 posts
Posted on 4/16/25 at 10:54 pm to
Posted by Martini
Near Athens
Member since Mar 2005
49618 posts
Posted on 4/18/25 at 10:54 pm to
Very nice.
This post was edited on 4/19/25 at 7:51 am
Posted by r3lay3r
EBR
Member since Oct 2016
2404 posts
Posted on 4/19/25 at 8:14 am to
Yes, rye will absorb more water and doesn't build glutens like other flours, so the resulting dough can be sticky and hard to work with. My last was a walnut with rye and whole wheat and it was sticky and hard to shape.
Posted by Tigerbait46
Member since Dec 2005
8050 posts
Posted on 4/19/25 at 1:34 pm to
quote:

Yes, rye will absorb more water and doesn't build glutens like other flours, so the resulting dough can be sticky and hard to work with. My last was a walnut with rye and whole wheat and it was sticky and hard to shape.


Yes, I experienced that when trying a 90% rye. It was a mess to work with.

My comment about it being on the moist and spongy side was about the final baked bread. In hindsight, I think I just cut into it too early.
Posted by BlueRabbit
Member since Apr 2025
133 posts
Posted on 4/20/25 at 5:34 pm to
That’s a great looking bread. My starter stays at 50% hard white wheat and 50% whole wheat. I only use rye when I want to just make it eat voraciously and then about 10%.

You can make them however you like the 50/50 just works well for me and has a lot of flavor plus I mix a hundred pounds at a time so it’s easy.

But keep using those flours and look for the others out there to try. The old ancient grains have so much flavor it’s hard to really tell people but once you taste them you are absolutely hooked. Fun to experiment with and if you don’t always get the oven spring you are looking for doesn’t mean the bread doesn’t taste good.

Here is a line I’m bringing out because I have a lot of people who just want great flavor and nutrition. So it’s an experiment with me too which is great.




Posted by BlueRabbit
Member since Apr 2025
133 posts
Posted on 4/20/25 at 8:06 pm to
How’s the bread?
Posted by tewino
Member since Aug 2009
2491 posts
Posted on 4/20/25 at 8:12 pm to
quote:


How’s the bread?


Excellent! Love the ancient grains. They have so much flavor and great crust and crumb. I’ve been eating it toasted with butter all day.

It was great to see you and I would encourage all bread heads to go visit.
Posted by BlueRabbit
Member since Apr 2025
133 posts
Posted on 4/20/25 at 8:15 pm to
Absolutely. I’ll be adding more of the ancient grains a bit at a time and with fresh milled flour they just taste amazing.

Great seeing you to. Come back anytime and enjoy.
Posted by Tigerbait46
Member since Dec 2005
8050 posts
Posted on 4/20/25 at 9:26 pm to
Thanks, definitely planning to try out ancient grains once I'm through with the flour I have on hand. Nutritious and a deeper flavor is the direction I feel pulled toward. I'm getting more comfortable with the general process and techniques now so it'll be good timing to dive into ancient grains and higher quality flour.

I have a 55% whole wheat proofing in the fridge right now and will post an update of the final bake.

One question for you all -- what batard shaping technique do you go with?

Also, if you're ever up in Tennessee, check out Niedlov's in Chattanooga and Dozen in Nashville.
Posted by BlueRabbit
Member since Apr 2025
133 posts
Posted on 4/21/25 at 12:51 pm to
Follow Wayne Caddy on YouTube Facebook or Instagram.

I use his double Caddy Clasp. Fast, easy and it works. No need to overthink it.
LINK
Posted by Tigerbait46
Member since Dec 2005
8050 posts
Posted on 4/21/25 at 4:28 pm to
Well I got the batard shaping down no problem but totally botched today's loaf. I didn't manage my time well and likely overproofed it. Then to add insult, the dough stuck to the banneton and deflated when I removed it. No photos of this one. Will try again later this week.
Posted by BlueRabbit
Member since Apr 2025
133 posts
Posted on 4/21/25 at 5:42 pm to
Dust rice flour in your banneton to keep it from sticking.
Posted by ApisMellifera
SWLA
Member since Apr 2023
694 posts
Posted on 4/22/25 at 11:12 am to
quote:

For both of you above I have a couple recommendations.

The Sourdough Journey

The Perfect Loaf





I tried the beginner's recipe on The Perfect Loaf and it turned out perfect. Lots of compliments from all the family this weekend.

After reading on that site and The Sourdough Journey, I'm certain I've always had my dough too warm and have been over proofing it. I'll go with that same recipe another time or 2 at least to make sure I'm replicating the process correctly then branch out to some of the others on there.

I appreciate the recommendation!
Posted by BlueRabbit
Member since Apr 2025
133 posts
Posted on 4/23/25 at 11:54 am to
quote:

tried the beginner's recipe on The Perfect Loaf and it turned out perfect. Lots of compliments from all the family this weekend. After reading on that site and The Sourdough Journey, I'm certain I've always had my dough too warm and have been over proofing it. I'll go with that same recipe another time or 2 at least to make sure I'm replicating the process correctly then branch out to some of the others on there. I appreciate the recommendation!


Great to hear. His dinner roll is a great one to make. Just double it up because you will eat one batch like you are going to the electric chair.

I modified his English muffin recipe for myself and make about 8 different flavors and sell probably 120 a week. He has some great videos and content and his discord group is very help and active but it is subscription based.

If you want to dial in your bulk fermentation and feel like spending a little money buy the Hanna Halo 2 Bread PH meter. Use it in conjunction with time and temperature and it really helps a lot.

LINK

I am making some Red Fife dough now and have iced my water to bring the temperature down since it’s getting hot.

Good luck and let’s see the bread.
first pageprev pagePage 3 of 9Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram