What would you vote?

Team A and Team B should work out between them. If they can’t agree on resolution, then split pot.

Sucks for team A. I just don’t think it’s fair to ask league members to vote on these scenarios.

Will probably split pot regardless. But the bragging rights are the main concern. There can only be one champ. Shitty situation

That's pretty tough. I think I would do the reddit split based upon win percentage for the money.

Either that or those players scores from week 18.

Of those options, I’d choose rematch, but both are awful. Why can’t commissioners use logic when making a decision? Throw 5% of first place to team B and the rest to team A. That’s being generous as team A wins >99% of the time.

Use week 18 points for those players.

Team B could also acknowledge the 99.99999% chance they lose.

I saw a recommendation to use historical scoring on the year against the current situation. If there was any game where Buffalo kicker +3 points would have beaten Josh Allen + Chase, then you split the pot. Otherwise rule in favor of B

I wouldn’t factor games where Chase didn’t play due to injury

Easiest thing to do is use Week 18's scores.

Other options:
Call it a tie game.
Take the average game points for each player and decrease it by 25%.
Put all of the kickers scores in a hat and let the other team pull out a score.
Put all of JAs and Chase's weekly scores in separate hats and let other team pick a score.
Use these scores or week 18 scores.