re: Springfield vs. Colt - talking 1911s

quote:

---

The design of a revolver is inherently more reliable than a semi-auto if for no other reason than there are far less moving parts.

---

But when a revolver jams, it's probably going back to the factory.

When a semiauto jams, we do a TRB -- takes about two seconds.

quote:

---

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You do realize that most people working at a gun shop have no fricking clue what they are talking about right? I mean these are the same people that suggest to women that an air weight .38 spcl are a great first gun. These are the same people who say revolvers are super reliable (which is complete bullshite). Don't believe a word those idiots say. Both Springfield and Colt make quality guns its just what you decide you like better and if the price is right.

---

This is almost universally true.

Today's top tier semiautos are as reliable as today's top tier revolvers. Keep 'em reasonably clean and they are GTG. Getting all wrapped around the axle about one or the other is a fanboy issue.

The top tier semiautos that hold 15-18 rounds, and facilitate fast reloads, are (for many) a better choice than a revolver. Then again, if you have a skill set comparable to Jerry Miculek, I'd say you'll be fine with a six-shot revolver.

The real answer is to (1) buy a quality handgun, (2) get some serious training from a top-tier instructor and (3) practice regularly. This will separate the competent gun owners from the internet fanboys.