500 days of summer vs silver linings playbook vs garden state

ive seen 500 days like 500 times

i need to let silver linings sink in more

I think most people really really liked 500 Days of Summer, but its not on Silver Linings' level, even though Silver Linings had some plot wholes that I didn't like.

500 Days should be compared to something like Garden State, imo.

they're both very good but give me SLP

Any man who has slept with a crush can relate to this scene.

Silver Linings is better imo, but I really like 500 days also. I understand what the OP sees when he's trying to compare them. They both are perceived as Romantic Comedies, but they're not. SLP does have romantic ending,but 500 Days depresses the shite out of me. The dialogue between the two main characters in both movies is phenomenal.

If :

quote:

---

500 days of summer vs silver linings playbook

---

Are as awful as:

quote:

---

vs garden state

---

I am glad I have never seen them

Just watched 500 Days of Summer today for the first time. I feel like Silver Linings Playbook is so much better.

SLP is Oscar worthy. The other 2, though good movies are not.

Way late to the game, but the wife dragged me into SLP yesterday. I was thinking that I was going to be miserable in some stupid romantic comedy. Boy was I wrong.

Somebody is going to win an oscar for that movie.