re: Crackpot ASOIAF Theories SPOILERS

quote:

---

So I was going through some theory's and one of them is rhaegar+ Lyanna= Dany
And Brandon + ashara dayne= Jon snow. And my favorite theorey is that quaithe is ashara dayne. What yall think?

---

I personally only see one of those being even half-way possible. I think it was hinted at that Brandon may have got Ashara pregnant at the tourney at Harrenhal. But I'm not sure if the timeline matches up with Jon's age. I guess at the very least, it is possible.

I think that Dany's birth is pretty well documented. And how would there have been enough time for Ned to carry Dawn to Starfell and Dany to Dragonstone before Stannis' assault on Dragonstone? That seems impossible.

And I don't know how Ashara could pull off being a Shadowbinder from Asshai who has visions. If Ashara is still alive (and I highly doubt that she is), then I would be more apt to believe she is Septa Lemore.

quote:

---

rhaegar+ Lyanna= Dany

---

As Tiger said, Dany's birth is fairly well documented. Queen Rhaella died in labor with her and part of the theory that she could be Azor Ahai lies with her "Stormborn" nature having been born at Dragonstone during a storm.

quote:

---

Brandon + ashara dayne= Jon snow

---

The baby being Jon Snow doesn't make a lot of sense, but I do think there's a good possibility Brandon knocked her up. And also think she could be Septa Lemore.