- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Advice: Can We Afford This House?
Posted on 1/7/26 at 1:42 pm
Posted on 1/7/26 at 1:42 pm
I am coming to the Money Board for some input on whether we should buy a new house.
Apologies for long post, but wanted to provide more information for better answers. Appreciate any input in advance.
Information:
Current Home
- Location: Heights of Houston, TX. Central location with good elementary schools but middle / high school are not great.
- Type of house: 3 story townhome with 3 bedroom with office that we use as a bedroom. There is basically 0 yard.
- Home value is ~$450K of which we still owe $260K
Wife & 2 kids (aged 4 & 2) with another kid on the way
Financial information:
- Combined annual income ~$275K (my salary is about 63% of this)
- Net worth is ~$1.3M (~$600K in investments and ~$600K in our 401Ks)
- Max out 401ks, invest ~$5K a month into personal accounts, and contribute to 529s
- No other debt other than wife’s car which we have ~2 more years on
Work information:
- My work can be longer hours and WFH, office, or client office (which the locations can vary).
- My salary could potentially increase substantially in 2-3 years and in the future.
- Wife works from home her work is relatively laid back / flexible.
- My wife’s salary isn’t likely to change much more than inflation. She may also take reduced work schedule (e.g. go down to 80%).
- She doesn’t plan to be a stay at home mom, but in the case she did could still make these payments (barely) although that would be less than ideal
We could certainly make the current house work for a couple of years, but its getting cramped with 2 kids (and will be worse with 3 kids) and with the layout. Plus, we would likely need to move in the next couple of years anyway because of schools.
We are struggling with the decision. Mainly because:
- In a good central location now, that works well for my work so hard to stomach hour + commutes each way. To get what we want (4 bedrooms and office, yard, and zoned to good schools) we would have to move out to suburbs and cost would be in the $800 - $850K range
- Our monthly payment is only ~$2K all-in now so hard to stomach monthly payment going up double + (probably be in the $5K range)
- Area has MUD tax so are property tax would be really expensive (in the ~$25K a year range) and I hate the idea of property tax so hard to agree to sign up for this
- We are used to investing a good portion of paychecks so hard to stomach reducing that (e.g. likely need to reduce from $5K a month in personal accounts to something like $1-2K a month in personal accounts for at least a few years)
- Our initial idea was to never touch these investments until retirement, but would likely need to pull out $100K - $200K for downpayment and such.
On one hand it feels like we can’t really afford an ~$800K house. On the other hand, it seems like we could easily afford it and we pass the rules of thumb I’ve heard about:
- $275K annual income / $850K house = 3.1 (which is right at the rule that says not to spend more than 3 times annual gross income)
- $5K monthly payment / $23K gross monthly salary = 21.8% (which is below the 28% rule)
I guess my questions are the below for those who have more experience than I do here:
- Input on whether a longer commute is worth it if the house works better for family?
- Can we afford an $800 - $850K house or would that be crazy?
- What are we not thinking about?
Apologies for long post, but wanted to provide more information for better answers. Appreciate any input in advance.
Information:
Current Home
- Location: Heights of Houston, TX. Central location with good elementary schools but middle / high school are not great.
- Type of house: 3 story townhome with 3 bedroom with office that we use as a bedroom. There is basically 0 yard.
- Home value is ~$450K of which we still owe $260K
Wife & 2 kids (aged 4 & 2) with another kid on the way
Financial information:
- Combined annual income ~$275K (my salary is about 63% of this)
- Net worth is ~$1.3M (~$600K in investments and ~$600K in our 401Ks)
- Max out 401ks, invest ~$5K a month into personal accounts, and contribute to 529s
- No other debt other than wife’s car which we have ~2 more years on
Work information:
- My work can be longer hours and WFH, office, or client office (which the locations can vary).
- My salary could potentially increase substantially in 2-3 years and in the future.
- Wife works from home her work is relatively laid back / flexible.
- My wife’s salary isn’t likely to change much more than inflation. She may also take reduced work schedule (e.g. go down to 80%).
- She doesn’t plan to be a stay at home mom, but in the case she did could still make these payments (barely) although that would be less than ideal
We could certainly make the current house work for a couple of years, but its getting cramped with 2 kids (and will be worse with 3 kids) and with the layout. Plus, we would likely need to move in the next couple of years anyway because of schools.
We are struggling with the decision. Mainly because:
- In a good central location now, that works well for my work so hard to stomach hour + commutes each way. To get what we want (4 bedrooms and office, yard, and zoned to good schools) we would have to move out to suburbs and cost would be in the $800 - $850K range
- Our monthly payment is only ~$2K all-in now so hard to stomach monthly payment going up double + (probably be in the $5K range)
- Area has MUD tax so are property tax would be really expensive (in the ~$25K a year range) and I hate the idea of property tax so hard to agree to sign up for this
- We are used to investing a good portion of paychecks so hard to stomach reducing that (e.g. likely need to reduce from $5K a month in personal accounts to something like $1-2K a month in personal accounts for at least a few years)
- Our initial idea was to never touch these investments until retirement, but would likely need to pull out $100K - $200K for downpayment and such.
On one hand it feels like we can’t really afford an ~$800K house. On the other hand, it seems like we could easily afford it and we pass the rules of thumb I’ve heard about:
- $275K annual income / $850K house = 3.1 (which is right at the rule that says not to spend more than 3 times annual gross income)
- $5K monthly payment / $23K gross monthly salary = 21.8% (which is below the 28% rule)
I guess my questions are the below for those who have more experience than I do here:
- Input on whether a longer commute is worth it if the house works better for family?
- Can we afford an $800 - $850K house or would that be crazy?
- What are we not thinking about?
This post was edited on 1/7/26 at 1:51 pm
Posted on 1/7/26 at 1:48 pm to POCKET
Stay where you at and keep doing what you are doing. Investing will pay off long term.
Posted on 1/7/26 at 1:53 pm to POCKET
Do you have any equity in your current house?
I’d have no issue reducing my after tax investments into increased housing costs to make a move like this. Just plan on being there a while and refi when/if rates come down. As your income rises it will get easier.
I’d have no issue reducing my after tax investments into increased housing costs to make a move like this. Just plan on being there a while and refi when/if rates come down. As your income rises it will get easier.
Posted on 1/7/26 at 1:54 pm to POCKET
quote:
Wife & 2 kids (aged 4 & 2) with another kid on the way
quote:
Central location with good elementary schools but middle / high school are not great.
They get more expensive the older they get, and schools generally do not get better with time...
How much equity in current home, do you have to pull from investments (I wouldnt)
- Input on whether a longer commute is worth it if the house works better for family? I would rather sacrifice more of my time to make my family more comfortable
- Can we afford an $800 - $850K house or would that be crazy? You can, but what if you or her lost your job...
- What are we not thinking about? Kids extras / sports, tuition possibly if schools go to shite.
Edit: My dad always tells me on big financial / life decisions make a list Pros/Cons take some time and think about each and decide if its worth it.
This post was edited on 1/7/26 at 1:56 pm
Posted on 1/7/26 at 2:12 pm to POCKET
Stomach it for another year if you can and save aggressively. You’ll likely get a better rate too. Short answer is yes, you can afford it now, but with another year of equity in your current place and a slightly lower rate, it won’t hurt near as badly. If you buy an $800k house a year for now, with proceeds from your current place and more cash, you shouldn’t have to finance more than about $550k
Posted on 1/7/26 at 2:34 pm to Mingo Was His NameO
quote:
stomach it for another year if you can and save aggressively
Put the money you would have paid monthly (minus current mortgage) over the year away for the new house into a HYSA and use it for the down payment. Then you’ll know you can afford it (because you just did it albeit not toward the house but financially) and you’ll have a chunk of your Downpayment. Plus you’ll see if you have enough left over to live the life / luxury you would want.
Great advice Mingo!
Posted on 1/7/26 at 2:46 pm to jpainter6174
quote:
You can, but what if you or her lost your job...
They have 600k in a brokerage account. They’d be fine.
To the OP, you can easily afford it. It sounds like you could pay cash for it with your equity and investments if you really wanted to.
If you’re pretending like that 600k doesn’t exist (planning FIRE?), then things are going to be a lot tighter with that bigger mortgage and your savings rate will go down a lot.
This post was edited on 1/7/26 at 2:47 pm
Posted on 1/7/26 at 2:53 pm to POCKET
What would your wifes commute be like? We decided to stay in the heights and do private school just because if there was an issue with a kid we wouldn't be an hour away as my wife and I both work downtown. Just something else to consider non-monitary. We decided our sanity of not commuting was worth more than additional money we would save in the burbs.
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:03 pm to POCKET
build your monthly budget first. Do you have enough discretionary spending at the end of the month to cover mortgage, home insurance, HOA, property taxes, maintenance, repairs and utilities for this house?
We can't do your monthly budget for you.
We can't do your monthly budget for you.
This post was edited on 1/7/26 at 3:06 pm
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:05 pm to POCKET
What is your net income?
Also, do you WANT this expensive of a house or do you NEED this expensive of a house?
Also, do you WANT this expensive of a house or do you NEED this expensive of a house?
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:07 pm to JL
How old are you? When do you plan to retire?
I'm guessing that you have 20+ years until retirement. If you didn't invest another cent, and just let what you have grow, you will probably have at least $4M in 20 years.
I'm not suggesting that you DON'T put away the $5K into a brokerage account or put money into your 401k, but if finances get tight for some reason, you could stop those payments temporarily, if needed.
It sounds like you have quite a buffer to utilize if you get too far out over your skis with the house, or in the event that your wife loses her job, etc. Especially since your income is likely to go up in the near future, and any shortfalls would only last until your income catches up.
I'm guessing that you have 20+ years until retirement. If you didn't invest another cent, and just let what you have grow, you will probably have at least $4M in 20 years.
I'm not suggesting that you DON'T put away the $5K into a brokerage account or put money into your 401k, but if finances get tight for some reason, you could stop those payments temporarily, if needed.
It sounds like you have quite a buffer to utilize if you get too far out over your skis with the house, or in the event that your wife loses her job, etc. Especially since your income is likely to go up in the near future, and any shortfalls would only last until your income catches up.
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:08 pm to notsince98
quote:
Do you have enough discretionary spending at the end of the month to cover mortgage, home insurance, HOA, property taxes, maintenance, repairs and utilities for this house?
He’s putting $5k a month into a brokerage account.
His kids are young so I’m assuming he’s less than 40 and already has over a million dollars saved.
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:13 pm to Mingo Was His NameO
quote:
He’s putting $5k a month into a brokerage account.
His kids are young so I’m assuming he’s less than 40 and already has over a million dollars saved.
The increased costs will come from something. Is that acceptable? Does the OP have any idea how much the change is going to be? Bigger houses are more expensive in every way, usually in ways people dont consider.
My post is not about what "can the OP afford" but do they really want to? Some people do less and want a nicer house. Some people want less of a house and spend more on other things. Everyone has a limit and have to decide what is best for them.
This post was edited on 1/7/26 at 3:14 pm
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:16 pm to Mingo Was His NameO
quote:
Stomach it for another year if you can and save aggressively.
And with your kids not even starting elementary school yet, I say stay a couple more years until maybe your oldest is in 2nd or 3rd grade. Continue to invest and save aggressively and then move
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:19 pm to POCKET
Like others have said, I would wait.
If you didn't have access to good schools for the kids currently, I would be more likely to move. High school is a ways away (even though it will fly by as a parent).
I would say keep saving and if the right opportunity presents itself (low rates, perfect house, etc.) then make your move. You will be more prepared.
If you didn't have access to good schools for the kids currently, I would be more likely to move. High school is a ways away (even though it will fly by as a parent).
I would say keep saving and if the right opportunity presents itself (low rates, perfect house, etc.) then make your move. You will be more prepared.
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:22 pm to Sterling Archer
quote:
And with your kids not even starting elementary school yet, I say stay a couple more years until maybe your oldest is in 2nd or 3rd grade.
It doesn’t matter when the baby is actually a baby, but having three mobile kids in a 3 story townhouse that is probably too small would suck.
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:30 pm to SquatchDawg
quote:
Do you have any equity in your current house?
Same homes in neighborhood are selling for $450K and more and we still owe $260K so we should get ~$200K out of selling current home.
Depending when we actually did this (thinking with in next 6 months), we would most likely pull ~$100K of the total ~$600K out of taxable investments
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:34 pm to jpainter6174
quote:
How much equity in current home, do you have to pull from investments (I wouldnt)
Would net ~$200k our of selling current come. We would most likely pull ~$100K of the total ~$600K out of taxable investments. I'd rather not, but wouldn't be close to all of it
quote:
Can we afford an $800 - $850K house or would that be crazy? You can, but what if you or her lost your job...
If wife lost her job, we could get by but it would be close. If I lost my job, we couldn't make it forever but could obviously pull from brokerage account (~$500K left) for awhile. I should not go without a job very long in my field
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:36 pm to jpainter6174
quote:
Put the money you would have paid monthly (minus current mortgage) over the year away for the new house into a HYSA and use it for the down payment. Then you’ll know you can afford it (because you just did it albeit not toward the house but financially) and you’ll have a chunk of your Downpayment. Plus you’ll see if you have enough left over to live the life / luxury you would want.
I think that is what we will do for the next couple of months at least to see how it feels
Posted on 1/7/26 at 3:40 pm to FieldEngineer
quote:
If you’re pretending like that 600k doesn’t exist (planning FIRE?), then things are going to be a lot tighter with that bigger mortgage and your savings rate will go down a lot.
I haven't really thought about it being FIRE, but that is essentially the way we have done it and planned to do it.
In my head, my idea was to start investing, increase the % we invest every year, and never touch the investments. We don't really care about being rich, but we never want to be uncomfortable and this is our (at least my) way to make sure that happens.
I think we can actually afford it, but the biggest thing I'm trying to mentally get over is not getting that investment strategy
Back to top

34









