Favorite team:LSU 
Location:Gila River
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:19716
Registered on:1/25/2008
Online Status:
 Online

Recent Posts

Message
quote:

If anyone's ever used Westlaw's AI, it absolutely will confidently mischaracterize a case's holding, trying to tell you what you want to hear. It drive's me nuts, and i would definitely characterize that as being within the parameters of a hallucination. If anything is made up, shite is made up. . I can almost guarantee the SEC lawyers just looked at the AI summary without checking the cases, which the judge should actually be more aggravated by


Oh hell yeah. Harvey is better but it has its moments as well.

AI is a great tool. I use it all the time to help me find good cases. But you never cite a case unless you or someone you trust has read it to make sure it says what you say it does.
quote:

The SEC did not choose her.


Agreed. I did not see anything to indicate forum shopping.

I knew a guy who would file in federal court to see if he got the judge he liked. If he did not, he would dismiss it by notice and then file it in state court, knowing that the defendants would remove it, which gave him a second shot at getting the judge he wanted.
quote:

But trust me, they are just as nasty as anyone deep down.


Oh hell to the yes.
If somebody could AI this with the word "hallucination," that would be epic.
quote:

Tards don’t understand you are in licensing violations if you publish the contents you paid for.


You also don't do that to a court reporter. Ever.

I paid for it. I can summarize it. I can even quote from it if it is fair use.

But you don't just publish it.
quote:

Why?


She is a federal judge. All judges have some bias in one way or another. They are human.

But being bribed? A federal judge? I don't think so.
quote:

I thought I read in one of the X recaps that she gave the SEC attorneys a certain amount of time to explain why their cases cited were in fact relevant to the case. I didn’t see that referred to in your summary. Did she not order that?


Yes. I think he was given the opportunity to clarify his position in additional briefing.
quote:

When she referenced Harvey AI, was she acknowledging that they used it or was she just citing an example? Seems weird to get upset about them alleging hallucinations if she then acknowledges that the SEC lawyers did in fact use AI.


They acknowledged that they had used AI per local rules.

They also certified that they had verified the cites.

To them, and to the judge, that seems to have meant that there were no fictional cites.

The LSU defendants' point was that the portrayal of those real cites was more or less fictional, and that one explanation was that AI had provided that portrayal.
quote:

Alabama judge got butt hurt her buddies got found out and she had a hissy fit


I would have used different words, but that is pretty much the impression I got.

I think the Birmingham legal community views itself as genteel, and very much above the kind of mudslinging, sharp-elbowed practice you would see in some other major cities.

That is what I think you are seeing in Judge Axon's reaction. It is as though she is saying, "We don't do things like that here."

My guess is that she is reacting to the fairly strong personality of our attorney general as well.
quote:

that way you can tell these tards you posted lol


Never go full tard . . . .
quote:

just don't get this pomp and circumstance of our legal system. After reviewing information that the SEC provided, and noticing that something is misstated, you can't call that into question because it is "insulting" to the person who filed the misstated information with the court? WTF are we doing here?



It is one thing to say they got it wrong.

It is another thing to say AI made up the cite.

When you say "hallucinated," many people assume the latter. The judge here certainly did.
quote:

So, did the judge ever address whether the cases the SEC's AI used were relevant to the case? Or did she just complain that the other lawyer pointed it out?


No. She did not get into whether the cases supported the propositions for which they were cited.

quote:

what is the judge's name?


Judge Annemarie Axon
quote:

Go on.


The press reported that she had rejected LSU's claim and ordered a press release apology.

It did not capture the level of chewing out that I read. It was pretty bad.
It is, by the way, worse than I thought.
quote:

The downvotes are because he originally posted that its worse than we thought... but didn't include the summary. Just said he would add the summary shortly. So he got downvoted for basically pre posting his post with more to come. Took over 30 minutes for the actual post to be there


Ok. That’s fair. I’ll do it all at once next time.
quote:

The downvotes are baffling.


Pay for a transcipt.
Spend valuable billable time summarizing.
Get downvoted.

Kind of makes you wonder why you should do it anymore.
quote:

None of what I say has anything to do with who is ultimately right or wrong on the merits. Just for the pleadings at issue, don’t use the word hallucination.


Yeah. In retrospect, the LSU side probably should not have done that.
quote:

That was my thing isn't that a violation of 1st amendment rights? Seems pretty damn ironic.


It seems so to me.
quote:

Question judge. I thought the issue wasnt hallucinated cases, but a hallucination of what the actual cases sited held in their judgements?



That is the core of the argument.

The judge seemed to think that a hallucinated cite was entirely fictional. The LSU side was arguing that the cites might have been right but the holdings in those cases was far different than as represented.

It seemed like a sideshow issue to me at first. But now that it has blown up, it may actually improve the LSU folk's chances on appeal if this judge rules against them.
quote:

And then Liz and Jeff put the judge on blast on Xitter.

So do we expect a show cause hearing next?


Looks like it really is going to be a First Amendment case now!