- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Router rec for small business and home
Posted on 12/9/21 at 6:44 am
Posted on 12/9/21 at 6:44 am
I need two routers. One for a small business and one for our home. I have been trying to research but it seems there are a gazillion options and they all get shitty reviews on Amazon.
Home router: att 300 download speed. Have a bunch of connected devices: switches, plugs, sonos, TVs, phones, thermostat etc. around 30 total. Home is 2400 sq feet with a central media closet that has Ethernet run to the bedrooms and tv locations.
Business (vet clinic): mediacom 1gig speed. Business will be running a cloud based practice management software. Not too many devices. Around 5 employees. Phone lines are traditional lines. Building is 2000 sq feet.
I was looking at just buying two of these LINK asus routers but not sure if it’s overkill for the house. I like the ports in the back and it would let me get rid of switches in both locations.
I appreciate any help. I just don’t want to spend a bunch of money and regret it immediately.
Home router: att 300 download speed. Have a bunch of connected devices: switches, plugs, sonos, TVs, phones, thermostat etc. around 30 total. Home is 2400 sq feet with a central media closet that has Ethernet run to the bedrooms and tv locations.
Business (vet clinic): mediacom 1gig speed. Business will be running a cloud based practice management software. Not too many devices. Around 5 employees. Phone lines are traditional lines. Building is 2000 sq feet.
I was looking at just buying two of these LINK asus routers but not sure if it’s overkill for the house. I like the ports in the back and it would let me get rid of switches in both locations.
I appreciate any help. I just don’t want to spend a bunch of money and regret it immediately.
This post was edited on 12/9/21 at 6:54 am
Posted on 12/9/21 at 9:42 am to tilco
That router is fine for both locations. It doesn't sound like your clinic needs the advanced features of a business class router. And if your clinic router fails, you'll have a backup at home. If WiFi coverage isn't great you can buy the AiMesh compatible mesh nodes.
Posted on 12/9/21 at 9:56 am to TAMU-93
quote:
That router is fine for both locations. It doesn't sound like your clinic needs the advanced features of a business class router. And if your clinic router fails, you'll have a backup at home. If WiFi coverage isn't great you can buy the AiMesh compatible mesh nodes.
Thanks. We are looking at expanding so having the ability to grow is a plus.
Posted on 12/10/21 at 7:50 am to tilco
For business I would do something that is not a consumer product. You should be looking at a business class firewall like a SonicWall, Fortinet, Watch guard, etc. They have smarts that can filter out bad stuff like Russians trying to hack your practice and steal your customer data. Or just get Cyber insurance for when it happens.
Posted on 12/13/21 at 6:07 pm to tilco
I use a Firebox flashed with Pfsense for my home (and would handle any small\med business). Not sure on your tech level, but I've ran these for years with no issues. Also cheap enough to keep a hot spare in my server rack to turn on in the event of a failure. And it has pretty much anything you would need.
Firebox XTM 5 series with an ssd and CF card. Gig connection.
LINK is the model I use, lag'd all the ports to an arbua s3500.
Firebox XTM 5 series with an ssd and CF card. Gig connection.
LINK is the model I use, lag'd all the ports to an arbua s3500.
This post was edited on 12/13/21 at 6:09 pm
Posted on 12/14/21 at 9:38 am to g650Tide
We ended up going with the watchguard and a ubiquiti access point at the clinic.
IT guy is trying to sell me on something similar for my house. Says residential stuff sucks especially when you start getting a lot of devices.
What would I need coming out of the att gateway? I’m not super tech savvy but not lost either.
I’m assuming I need some sort of router to attach to att gateway and then an access point to hook to the router?
IT guy is trying to sell me on something similar for my house. Says residential stuff sucks especially when you start getting a lot of devices.
What would I need coming out of the att gateway? I’m not super tech savvy but not lost either.
I’m assuming I need some sort of router to attach to att gateway and then an access point to hook to the router?
Posted on 12/14/21 at 10:04 am to tilco
i struggled to 'love' my ASUS aimesh system for probably the last 5 years and tossed it in the garbage this summer for eero.
eero has some issues but overall the router & 2 satellites have provided full WiFi across my entire house which was never the case before. I was constantly flashing firmware and rebooting an non-functioning node.
pros
- stupid easy install & ux
- wifi6
- much better WiFi coverage in my house than ASUS with the satellites in pretty much the same places
- notifications when new devices connect and easy to rename/categorize them so you can keep up with the 100+ thingies on the network.
cons
- no ethernet backhaul - wireless satellites only
- can't plug in my free DDNS service i've used for the last 15 years. you have to pay for the eero one
- confusing when setting up 2.4ghz devices since there's no option to change networks. (pro tip: there's a feature under troubleshooting that disables the 5ghz network for 10 minutes so you can set up 2.4 devices)
- overly simple UX lacks all the configuration options of something like ASUS but so far i haven't run into anything i cant do
- they put 'subscription' options in the UX to try & upsell you on stuff
- occasionally 'loses' WiFi devices but inexplicably come back an hour later. this wouldn't be as big of a concern if it wasnt the dang RING camera that drops out.
get your shite together amazon.
eero has some issues but overall the router & 2 satellites have provided full WiFi across my entire house which was never the case before. I was constantly flashing firmware and rebooting an non-functioning node.
pros
- stupid easy install & ux
- wifi6
- much better WiFi coverage in my house than ASUS with the satellites in pretty much the same places
- notifications when new devices connect and easy to rename/categorize them so you can keep up with the 100+ thingies on the network.
cons
- no ethernet backhaul - wireless satellites only
- can't plug in my free DDNS service i've used for the last 15 years. you have to pay for the eero one
- confusing when setting up 2.4ghz devices since there's no option to change networks. (pro tip: there's a feature under troubleshooting that disables the 5ghz network for 10 minutes so you can set up 2.4 devices)
- overly simple UX lacks all the configuration options of something like ASUS but so far i haven't run into anything i cant do
- they put 'subscription' options in the UX to try & upsell you on stuff
- occasionally 'loses' WiFi devices but inexplicably come back an hour later. this wouldn't be as big of a concern if it wasnt the dang RING camera that drops out.

This post was edited on 12/14/21 at 10:07 am
Posted on 12/14/21 at 9:16 pm to tilco
My modem plugs directly into my watchgaurd firebox (set up as wan in the config) gig ethernet, then have a bunch of configuration for all the ports. I have a DMZ for a few servers along with a wireless linksys router set up in bridge mode since DHCP comes from my router. Works great- I even pulled the default CPU it comes with and upgraded it for $10ish on ebay and added 16gigs of ram for another $15. The original cpu was a celeron, and I upgraded to a E8200.
Did you buy a legit watchgaurd or something used like me? You can flash a used one with Pfsense which is a free firewall/router software. Pfsense has dozens of set-up videos if it's over your head but it's pretty simple and rock solid once you get it going. You might want to get a better one than the one I linked so you can enable the AES-NI CPU encryption.
Did you buy a legit watchgaurd or something used like me? You can flash a used one with Pfsense which is a free firewall/router software. Pfsense has dozens of set-up videos if it's over your head but it's pretty simple and rock solid once you get it going. You might want to get a better one than the one I linked so you can enable the AES-NI CPU encryption.
Posted on 12/15/21 at 6:23 am to g650Tide
Lol you lost me bro. I’m sure he’s installing a new watchguard I’m not sure which model tho. Let me draw a diagram of what I’ve got and maybe you can dumb it down for me
pardon my beautiful artwork.
This is my current setup:
This is what I’m thinking I need?!?

This is my current setup:

This is what I’m thinking I need?!?

This post was edited on 12/15/21 at 6:36 am
Posted on 12/15/21 at 6:24 am to CAD703X
If this gets too complicated I’m gonna go mesh. Seems like a better solution for my needs than a single router.
Posted on 12/15/21 at 4:52 pm to tilco
Yeah, your 2nd image is what I do with a lot of extra stuff after due to the amount of server/devices/subnets I have.
You can get a real cheap 24 port (poe if needed) switch and connect to the firebox. Not sure how many devices you need. Get an unmanaged switch if you just need a simple network with no vlans.
Mesh isn't a bad choice. I personally don't do it and have heard of headaches with different devices from friends, but cannot speak on it as I have never implemented it myself.
You can get a real cheap 24 port (poe if needed) switch and connect to the firebox. Not sure how many devices you need. Get an unmanaged switch if you just need a simple network with no vlans.
Mesh isn't a bad choice. I personally don't do it and have heard of headaches with different devices from friends, but cannot speak on it as I have never implemented it myself.
Posted on 12/16/21 at 8:14 am to tilco
quote:
If this gets too complicated I’m gonna go mesh. Seems like a better solution for my needs than a single router.
when i moved to eero i bought a 24 port switch to sit next to it since the eero only had a single ethernet out and it was surprising how quickly i almost filled that switch up.
like you i still have 4 remote switches as well in my bar (arcade & virtual pinball machine needs to be wired), main tv room (tv, game console, sonos hub), basement (plex server and other key devices) and office.
it compliments the mesh setup nicely; its still better to run wire where possible especially for devices that can't afford WiFi hiccups.
Popular
Back to top
