re: Matt Corral, Sam Howell, Stingley and Desmond Ridder are all at 18. Who do you take?

Stingley would be the answer but no way is he dropping that far. Also, some boards have Sam Howell as 2nd round. I would grab Stingley and try to get Sam in the 2nd if possible.

Neither. You trade up to get Dean from Georgia and you send Payton Turner as well as next year's # 1 and this year's 3. Then if you haven't traded away this year's second you go for Ridder who is a better choice at QB long term. He's a smart player.

quote:

---

I think a lot of depends on how Stingely performs at his pro day... he runs in the 4.3s he's good.. He runs 4.45+ hand timed.. he may drop out of the top 10.

---

I'd be shocked if Stingley runs under a 4.4, he never struck me as a blazing fast guy. Great technique and skills, maybe.

Didn't he basically admit he couldn't stick with Palmer when they were both at LSU?

Based on what I saw in the Cotton Bowl, Desmond Ridder is not NFL caliber.

If you want a QB, you need to go after a top flight QB. Anything else is a complete waste of time and a waste of a pick. See Ian Book for an example of this.