- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: Chris Carter was asked just now....
Posted on 8/26/10 at 11:07 pm to tubucoco
Posted on 8/26/10 at 11:07 pm to tubucoco
Point is that Rodgers is 6 years younger. It being either/or is a compliment to Brees because it's 50/50 which just means hes that good.
on a EDIT: I would still pick Brees, I'm a Saints fan. While Rodgers has more years, it's not 100% that he will turn out good, even though he LOOKS IT.
Plus hes a Viking at heart.
on a EDIT: I would still pick Brees, I'm a Saints fan. While Rodgers has more years, it's not 100% that he will turn out good, even though he LOOKS IT.
Plus hes a Viking at heart.
This post was edited on 8/26/10 at 11:19 pm
0
Posted on 8/27/10 at 2:06 am to JS87
He's clearly taking Rodgers' age into consideration... It's a pretty logical answer if ya ask me...
Posted on 8/27/10 at 2:12 am to JS87
I say you take the guy with the trophy
Posted on 8/27/10 at 2:51 am to JS87
Rodgers will be the best QB in the league starting in about 2 years... I love Drew Brees but he isn't getting any younger and Rodgers seems to just get better and better and better every damn day... He's my number 2 QB in the league and he's almost up there with Brees in my eyes.
If I wasn't biased and had to choose a QB, it would be Rodgers.
If I wasn't biased and had to choose a QB, it would be Rodgers.
Posted on 8/27/10 at 3:54 am to tubucoco
quote:
Rodgers learned a lot watching Favre all those years, if he was thrown to the wolves like Harrington was in Detroit, people wouldn't be singing or praising him now!
True, no QB who comes in and starts right away can be successful.
I remember this kid named Peyton Manning. Started as a rookie and threw 28 INTs. Poor guy, wonder what ever happened to him.
Posted on 8/27/10 at 3:58 am to shel311
that poor Sanchez kid...I don't even know if the team he's on can make it to the playoffs.
Posted on 8/27/10 at 7:05 am to JS87
quote:
CC said "either/or".
yeah he's dumb
i like when they say "if you're starting a team". well you want to win now, not in 5 years, so take the better player. in that case it's brees. 7 years of a top 1 qb or 15 of a top 5, hmmmm...
Posted on 8/27/10 at 9:14 am to jdrumdog
quote:
that poor Sanchez kid
quote:Sanchez has no place in this controversy. The Jets would've made the playoffs with a stale loaf of bread at QB. The made the playoffs in spite of his play.
I don't even know if the team he's on can make it to the playoffs
Posted on 8/27/10 at 10:49 am to JS87
As far as everyone talking about CC hating on the Saints, I dunno about that, but he was on M&M last Friday also, and when asked his SB picks for this season, he not only picked the Saints, but argued vehemently for them.
This post was edited on 8/27/10 at 10:51 am
Posted on 8/27/10 at 12:18 pm to Three 6 Italia
quote:
I say you take the guy with the trophy
so you'd take Dilfer over Marino?
Posted on 8/27/10 at 1:33 pm to shel311
quote:if you are comparing Rodgers to Peyton Manning that in it's self is assinine! Peyton learned from his rookie year and went on to become the dominant QB he is.
I remember this kid named Peyton Manning. He started as a rookie and threw 28 INTs. Poor guy, wonder what ever happened to him.
Rodger's on the other hand watched Favre on the sidelines for awhile and learned, if he had to start right away like Harrington did in Detroit his arse would be out the league also from being shell shocked from hearing footsteps. Instead, he watched and learned the biz from one of the best QB's in the game.
This post was edited on 8/27/10 at 1:40 pm
Posted on 8/27/10 at 3:23 pm to tubucoco
quote:
he had to start right away like Harrington did in Detroit his arse would be out the league also from being shell shocked from hearing footsteps
link?
Maybe Harrington just sucked, ever think of that? VY and Ben the Rapist started as rookies and are doing OK. So did Eli and lots of other guys. Rodgers didn't so what. Did that help? Maybe so, but to say he wouldn't be in the league if he had to start as a rookie is laughable and just stupid speculation on your part.
This post was edited on 8/27/10 at 3:24 pm
Posted on 8/27/10 at 3:26 pm to H-Town Tiger
I'd take Rodgers over Brees for sure. Maybe even Matt Ryan depending on how he plays this season.
Having 6 or 7 extra years is huge.
I heavily value age though - I'd have definitely taken Brees over Manning as far back as 2 seasons ago.
Having 6 or 7 extra years is huge.
I heavily value age though - I'd have definitely taken Brees over Manning as far back as 2 seasons ago.
This post was edited on 8/27/10 at 3:27 pm
Posted on 8/27/10 at 3:38 pm to JS87
I actually asked a friend this last night and I might have to go with Rodgers, strictly on the age thing.
Posted on 8/27/10 at 3:40 pm to AlejandroInHouston
quote:
Maybe even Matt Ryan depending on how he plays this season
Matty Ice over Brees. Come on man.
Posted on 8/27/10 at 3:51 pm to H-Town Tiger
quote:
so you'd take Dilfer over Marino?
Dilfer card has officially been played!
Ill raise you Montana over Marino.
Posted on 8/27/10 at 3:55 pm to bomber77
I'll seriously doubt Montana could have done what Marino did with Miami. If you're giving me the 49er's D, Bill Walsh etc, I'd take Montana over Marino, cause he fits that offense better. But in general, IDK.
Posted on 8/27/10 at 3:58 pm to H-Town Tiger
Montana owned the big games. He almost took that sorry chiefs team to the limit.
Marino, great thrower but not even in Montanas league as a quarterback, not close! IMO
Marino, great thrower but not even in Montanas league as a quarterback, not close! IMO
Posted on 8/27/10 at 4:03 pm to bomber77
Let me know when Rodgers wins a playoff game...and Greenbay's overrated Defense stops giving up 50+ pts to elite offenses...<just to throw that in there :D>
I'll take a proven winner in Brees and win NOW plus a few more Super Bowls and then in 3 - 4 yrs draft his protege'.... I'll worry about 6 - 7 years down the road when the time is right...
: )
I'll take a proven winner in Brees and win NOW plus a few more Super Bowls and then in 3 - 4 yrs draft his protege'.... I'll worry about 6 - 7 years down the road when the time is right...
: )
Posted on 8/27/10 at 4:08 pm to bomber77
quote:
Marino, great thrower but not even in Montanas league as a quarterback, not close!
Yep its all QB skill that made the 49er's defense >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Miami's. Alos if he played with Montana I'm sure Mark Duper would be the GOAT and we wouldn't know who Jerry Rice is.
Montana had way more talent around him and frankly better coaching.
quote:
Montana owned the big games. He almost took that sorry chiefs team to the limit.
They lost the AFC CG 30-13. Or are you suggesting that along with the 83 and 1990 NFCCG were not "big games"? I guess the 1986 divisional game vs the Giants that SF lost 49-3 was not a big game either? And the 87 divisional game vs Minnesota when Joe Cool was yanked for Steve Young was not a big game either huh?
Its a team game, Montana played on much better teams. Switch QB's before SB XIX and SF still wins big.
Page 2 of 4
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News