re: HISHE Completely Fixes The Last Jedi And Makes It an Incredible Movie

quote:

---

-Terrible side plot

---

It was terribly executed and too long.

quote:

---

-Using hyperspace travel as a weapon

---

Why do you see this as a negative? The only reason I didn't like it is because of who they chose to make the sacrifice.

quote:

---

-Rose

---

She made some pretty terrible choices, but at least some of that was intentional. Either way, I'd have her hung for treason when I landed.

quote:

---

-Rey being too powerful

---

I disagree.

quote:

---

-Ill-placed bad comedy

---

Be more specific.

quote:

---

There are things about this movie that sucked that don't revolve around your "fanboys don't like it because Luke didn't do exactly what they wanted him to" argument.

---

Those are all opinions. You have nothing objective to offer. You didn't like it. That's fine. I did. That should also be fine.

There are certainly things to dislike about it, but it was a good film regardless.

quote:

---

Agree to disagree.

---

Always an acceptable outcome.

just curious; and this isn't a right/wrong question.

OT turned into "Luke redeems Anakin and brings about the fall of Palpatine and the Empire".

Prequels were "Palpatine corrupts Anakin and they overthrow the Republic, and form the Empire".

Anyone feel like they have a handle on this trilogy yet? I really haven't decided whether Ben/Kylo is heading towards a good, or a bad conclusion. And regarding "Republic/Empire" stuff, I honestly don't think the politics matter very much in this. I get that the Resistance opposes the First Order, but I don't get what they are "for". What would they do if they win?

Yep, exactly where I was going with that comment.

That
Was
Totally
Wicked