re: AMERICAN IDOL Season 13 Official Thread, Spoilers May Be Present

It was an okay night. Malaya is better than what she did tonight. I like MK's voice and I think she's going to get better. Emily's tongue grossed me out a few times. It was distracting. Black Miley was a train wreck. I like pink hair fighter girl. She wasn't as good tonight, though. I hated the Jersey mama. They shouldn't let parents speak it be around the groups. Red lips was pretty good. That's about all I recall.

quote:

---

So 5 girls don't even get a chance to prove they deserve to be there?

---

they seem to be hell bent on being cruel this season. First the bit in the hanger followed by the mysterious bus ride...now they let you get all dressed up, pick a song, go through the voice coach, the hair people, the clothes people, the makeup people and have you sit in a room and HOPE they call your name... i really hate that part.




the 2nd girl "kristin?" i don't even remember her from the earlier episodes...but i really like her.

black miley was horrible...big hair girl with the receding hairline wasn't good...

girl who wants to be a boy was pretty good but, i think they are just trying to be PC by including her/him.

the one girl who sang the same song she did in auditions that she KNEW the judges didn't approve of is good but, i'd send her home just for being hard headed.


the girl who went 2nd to last was another one i don't remember from earlier shows.


oh and it's "jeeena" not "jenna" is getting old... add another e to your name or stfu

The new format is downright strange. I do like that they went live quicker, but the "rush week" thing...I don't even get that. I have no idea what Randy's purpose was. Wasted time it seemed to me.

I think it was silly to pick 15 and then only let us see 10 of them. Should have let all 15 sing and have America vote at the very least. Having them sitting there not knowing if they're going to be picked was lame.

Overall, though, the new judges still make this so much more palatable than last year.

Yeah, when Emily sang the same song that Harry told her didn't fit her, I thought it was a dumb choice for her and I kept thinking "pole dancer" throughout her performance, especially when she stuck out the Miley Cyrus tongue. I was grossed out. She lost me at that point. Has a good voice, though, so if she comes back with better song choices, she could get me back.

I don't think they picked MK to be politically correct. I think MK has a lot of potential and is different from all the big voices. Her tone is smooth and I like it. It's a nice change from all the belting, screaming, screeching and yelling.

If they don't put cutie patootie through, I may quit watching.

That boy good.

he was good... but they'll probably throw in Abba week this season so mmmmmkay has a shot.

Does that mean the other Bama boy doesn't make it... I thought the other one was better imo.

That sounded bad. Flat and pitchy. J Lo will love it.

Let him sing again

I like this boy, Sam Woolf