re: American Idol : Season 10 Thread

quote:

---

FeArThEhAt0307

---

I am loving all the Lion King references

ok MY TOP 9:

PIA
Lauren
Haley
Ebenezer Baptist
Paul McDonald
Casey Abrams
Scotty McCreary
Ashton
Stefano

Stefano is the only guy worth a crap. This will be a girls show, unless a bunch of 12 y.o. girls start turning votes for some of the other guys. Paul will get pigeonholed with his voice.

Well, I called eight of the ten and nine overall.

The only one who didn't make it was Robbie who obviously should have been in over Scotty McCreary, whose a one trick pony.

The wildcard round may be have been the best round I've ever seen in Idol. All six of those people would have made top 12 any other year.

Biggest disappointments are Michelle Rodriguez and Scotty McCreary. Rodriguez is out of her league compared to the other girls, but she is trying to corner the hispanic market.

I really wish they could have used instruments because I think things would have been different. Julie and Tim would have fared much better.

I'd rank them at this point:

1. Pia Toscano
2. Casey Abrams
3. Lauren Aliana
4. Paul McDonald
5. Jacob Lusk
6. Tia Megia
7. James Durbin
8. Ashton Jones
9. Stefano Langone
10. Haley Reinhart
11. Namia Apendapo
12. Scotty McCreary
13. Michelle Rodriguez

If this is truly a singing competition then, the lil 15 yr old Thea (sp?) wins hands down. She is the best pure singer in this group.


Spoilers !!!!



















Finally goggle glasses,jordan and giovanni are gone ! And I just don't understand the one trick cowboy surviving this far ! A LOT of country music fans must be voting?

I actually guessed the entire top 10. Not saying they would have been my top 10, but I correctly guessed who America would pick.

Over all, I think America did a better job than the judges did. I think the judges used the wrong process for choosing their wildcards. They chose people who had good performances on Tuesday and Wednesday. I would have done the opposite. If a contestant sang well, but still didn't make the cut, America must not like them. Therefore, what are the odds that they will be around for very long? On the other hand, contestants like Tim, Julie, and Jordan chose bad songs, but are really good singers. I would have given them another chance to get it right. If they do well, they could have a chance to change America's mind.

Even based on the one's they chose to sing, they only picked 1 of the 3 right (Stefano). America only got 1 really wrong (Scotty) and 1 or 2 others that could have gone either way.

Yep, America definitely did a better job than the judges.

Here we go

quote:

---

CP3LSU25

---

CP3 out against mavs tonight not good

I have that shirt she has on in bright red

Eta: the purple one from the interview