re: SVP -"If you're LSU, and you beat Georgia, and you're not #1, that makes no sense at all"

quote:

---

the problem is the committee picks and chooses when they want to use eye test vs resume for a given team. If you're using the eye test, well then there's no explanation for Bama's ranking. There's just no set criteria, system etc.

give me the BCS over this shite...yes I realize we'd still be #2 there but at least it was a more transparent, non biased system.

---

Totally agree. To be fair to the committee chair, he's speaking for 12 other people. It's not easy to sum up those hours of conversations and a secret ballot in a few sound bites.

I'd much rather have the BCS. At least your know what goes into it more.

Personally I'd like all computers with all metrics used to be clearly defined. You might get an outlier in the Top 4 once and blow up the whole system though.