- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: So who is right.....Guilbeau or Byrd?
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:06 pm to L S Usetheforce
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:06 pm to L S Usetheforce
quote:Well if Hatch is the starter and remains the starter, YES, I think the position will be worse than 04. Randall at least was very athletic running. Hatch can run but likley isn't as athletic as Randall. Hatch's passing ability is also going to limit our play calling, much like Randall.
So does anyone on here think that Lee or Hatch will be worse than the in 04 after Mauck left?
Will our qb play be worse than that?
2
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:09 pm to jlsutiger
quote:
Hatch can run but likley isn't as athletic as Randall.
We have nothing to base this off of.........we don't even know what our qbs are capable of.
Did anybody think Colt McCoy or Sam Bradford would lay up 29 and 36tds in the frosh seasons......hell no.
I'm not ready to make any judgements on our qbs until I see them peform in the game!
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:10 pm to L S Usetheforce
quote:
So does anyone on here think that Lee or Hatch will be worse than the in 04 after Mauck left?
That's what I'm preparing for...not worse, but the same.
quote:
Will our qb play be worse than that?
God I hope not.
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:12 pm to L S Usetheforce
quote:
Did anybody think Colt McCoy or Sam Bradford would lay up 29 and 36tds in the frosh seasons......hell no.
Do you think any of our QB's will duplicate performances like those?
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:12 pm to jlsutiger
quote:
Hatch's passing ability is also going to limit our play calling, much like Randall.
Have you seen Hatch throw 5 passes?
How do you know his passing ability is going to limit our play calling?
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:14 pm to DanglingFury
Hatch is pretty athletic. The kid can run pretty good from what I seen in practices and scrimmages. Hopefully, the season will give us more on the running and passing situation.
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:22 pm to Cornholio
Gilbeau has had a stick where the sun doesn't shine basically since CLM came on board. If you read his stuff on a regular basis - as I do in the Alexandria Town Talk - it seems that he is mad that practices are closed to the media. I think this anger - or frustration, or whatever you want to call it - colors his judgment sometimes.
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:24 pm to JPLSU1981
quote:
Gilbeau is actually a very nice guy
You misspelled JACKASS. He's a big douchebag.
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:28 pm to topgun1676
quote:
Hatch is pretty athletic. The kid can run pretty good from what I seen in practices and scrimmages
You get to go to full practices ?
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:29 pm to LSU77
I'll just take D-Byrds word on the situation.
Posted on 8/19/08 at 11:55 pm to Meauxjeaux
quote:Were you at Saturday's scrimmage. Didn't think so. I was. Apparently you also missed the spring game. He threw a lot more than 5 passes. I've also seen the practice footage.
Have you seen Hatch throw 5 passes?
How do you know his passing ability is going to limit our play calling?
Posted on 8/20/08 at 12:08 am to L S Usetheforce
If Guilbeaux is wrong he should be writing Obituaries in Mississippi in Jan 2009. Writing crap to get noticed is just wrong.
He should be run out the state if he is resorting to negative sensationalism. By the way... we had no proven QB to start the 07 season either after JR left.
He should be run out the state if he is resorting to negative sensationalism. By the way... we had no proven QB to start the 07 season either after JR left.
Posted on 8/20/08 at 5:38 am to jlsutiger
quote:
Were you at Saturday's scrimmage. Didn't think so. I was.
Tell you what buddy, let me come watch you work one day on a random day. For any little frick up you make on that one specific day, I will judge your entire work ability because of that mistake you made on that one day I observed.
I know you "snuck" into the scrimmage on Saturday. But to judge an entire season on one scrimmage performance might just be the most ranter of all ranter things I've read here in a long time. That is more like king ranter!
quote:
I've also seen the practice footage.
All hail King ranter of the Universe! As if you have the "upper hand" on the rest of the LSU world that knows ZERO about how these guys are going to work out.
Posted on 8/20/08 at 5:53 am to DanglingFury
quote:
Do you think any of our QB's will duplicate performances like those?
I think it is very possible. The superior talent around those Freshman qb's made that possible. Whoever our strater is will have time in the pocket and open recvrs to throw to. Just a little game of pitch and catch, right?
Posted on 8/20/08 at 6:19 am to Superfly1372
They are just getting their feet wet, and it's against some pretty good players on D. Once they get more relaxed(performing in the first three games), whatever talent they have will be easier to determine.
Crowton, who is known for evaluating and developing QB's, recruited Hatch. Was he THAT wrong?
Guilbeau seems to like to paint negative pictures.
Helms has also said positive things about both QB's. While I expect Helms and Byrd to be "good teammates", they could have said, "they are improving with experience".
Reality is probably somewhere in between. Some plays will look good, while others will show their inexperience.
Crowton, who is known for evaluating and developing QB's, recruited Hatch. Was he THAT wrong?
Guilbeau seems to like to paint negative pictures.
Helms has also said positive things about both QB's. While I expect Helms and Byrd to be "good teammates", they could have said, "they are improving with experience".
Reality is probably somewhere in between. Some plays will look good, while others will show their inexperience.
Posted on 8/20/08 at 6:33 am to JPLSU1981
quote:
Gilbeau is actually a very nice guy, and it may surprise most here that he likes LSU and wants us to win.
I seriously doubt that. Gilbeau, most properly pronounced "Dildeaux", is a liar and a hypocrite. When the LSU quarterbacks perform better than he's predicting this season, he'll act like he never said that crap. He uses every opportunity to criticize the LSU teams and coaches, and then when they do well, loves to jump on the bandwagon.
What a prick!!
Posted on 8/20/08 at 7:01 am to L S Usetheforce
Guilbeau is right
Posted on 8/20/08 at 7:12 am to JPLSU1981
quote:
Gilbeau is actually a very nice guy, and it may surprise most here that he likes LSU and wants us to win.
Sorry, can't buy that. I'm not one of these super sensitive LSU fans whose emotions flash on "Dead Red" every time somebody makes a critical comment about the Tigers, but Guilbeau has demonstarted a consistent m.o. of almost always painting anything about the LSU football program in the dimmeswt possible light.
Anybody who has read the dude's columns over the last 2-3 yrs. should have picked up on that, imo.
Posted on 8/20/08 at 7:15 am to Summer Grove Tiger
Please don't depend on the Fastest Hour guys or Guilbeau and 20 minutes of practice per day to evaluate QBs. Let's leave that to Crowton.
Posted on 8/20/08 at 8:09 am to DEANintheYAY
What is byrd going to say. "The qb's are highly inexperienced, having a little problems with their accuracy and pocket presence.
Page 2 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News