Started By
Message

re: Really think about Les Miles. And how amazing LSU won despite him.

Posted on 6/18/24 at 2:00 pm to
Posted by Salviati
Member since Apr 2006
6794 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 2:00 pm to
quote:

Kirby would be 3-3 against Saban with a 3rd Championship if a couple plays go Georgia's way instead of Bama's, not really to the fault of Kirby. They've almost always looked well-coached and competent against Saban.
Oh this shite is perfect!

In 2012, LSU loses on the final play to Alabama. LSU would have beat ND in the BCSCG except for that one play against Bama.

In 2014, LSU loses in overtime to Alabama. Alabama went to the playoffs with that win.
Posted by 904
Forever under I-10
Member since Dec 2009
960 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 2:44 pm to
quote:


In 2014, LSU loses in overtime to Alabama


I honestly forgot about this game. Maybe you're right, we should be giving Les more credit, because anytime someone makes it to overtime against Bama when their starting QB goes 8-26 for 76 yards (Jennings) is damn impressive

I still think the current versions of both Kirby and BK win 2-4 national championships at LSU if they were to go back in time and become LSU's head coach from 2005 - 2016, and wouldn't need the rest of CFB contenders to implode for any of them in the process. They're both far superior to Miles.
Posted by Run DMC
somewhere in Louisiana it's tricky
Member since Jan 2007
6021 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 2:54 pm to
I talked to several former players that actually were starters at their positions for multiple seasons and they all told me that he was constantly meddling with the offense and would change the offensive game plan on the day of the game.

Also, one of them told me that Les and Jimbo about got in a fist fight in practice and had to be separated because Les was constantly changing things.
Posted by timm6971463
oakdale la
Member since Mar 2008
4385 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 3:50 pm to
He was good at putting together great teams especially defenses he recruited out of this world and the silly complainers on this board tried to ruin his recruiting with just a little help he would of got over the bama hump LA, did make sabin !
Posted by timm6971463
oakdale la
Member since Mar 2008
4385 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 3:50 pm to
He was good at putting together great teams especially defenses he recruited out of this world and the silly complainers on this board tried to ruin his recruiting with just a little help he would of got over the bama hump LA, did make sabin !
Posted by Giantkiller
the internet.
Member since Sep 2007
23523 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 4:03 pm to
I know it isn't popular but I enjoyed watching the Tigers from 2005-2016. Les didn't win as much as everyone would have liked but I just don't get the hatred for him. I came up watching through the Stovall/Arnsbarger/Archer/Hallman/Dinardo years. I saw a lot worse.

The Les Miles Era wasn't as shitty of a tenure as you'd all like to believe. I don't get the vitriol y'all have for him. Sure it was time for him to go but overall - it was a good time to be alive in Tiger Stadium.

Posted by Red Stick Tigress
Tiger Stadium
Member since Nov 2005
18923 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 4:13 pm to
quote:

would of


would've.

The "' 've " is a contraction for have which is a verb. Of is not a verb.

Posted by Spankum
Miss-sippi
Member since Jan 2007
58661 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 4:45 pm to
quote:


Downvoters, please list what Les was good at.



He hired excellent position coaches.
He recruited top-notch players.
He was able to keep a suprising number of those excellent players from leaving early.
He was able to win 10 games basically every year.
He was able to win a National Championship.
He produced the most dominant season we have ever seen (but couldn’t finish)

Dou want me to continue?
Posted by OSchoenauer
Somewhere south of Bunkie
Member since May 2008
462 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 4:46 pm to
quote:

He was a protoypical CEO head coach. We knew it when he was here. He was dependent on his assistants for on field success. He could recruit the living room like nobody's business. Boiling it down to instate kids "wanting to be a Tiger" is disingenuous or ignorance. He played a major role in procuring the talent we had in his era. He was a master motivator as well. That can be huge in a locker room. He builds a culture well. Not without warts but overall pretty impressive. Point is, you aren't as successful as he was here for as long as he was by not being good. Plenty of "smarter" coaches would die for his career.

quote:

These revisionist history post are just flat out comical. Les needed to go but at the end of his tenure LSU was still winning as they were 9-3, 8-5, and 10-3 the previous three seasons. It wasn't always pretty but it was effective and LSU offenses under Les are still in the Top 10 offenses in LSU history. Les led LSU to a long and sustained peak for 10-11 years where they were a Top 5-10 team in the NCAA. Plus all coaches get carried by the talent they have, you don't think those yearly Top 3 recruiting classes haven't helped Alabama and Georgia?

There was a time when I was undecided.
I couldn’t figure out whether Les Miles was the luckiest doofus in CFB . . .
. . . or whether he was craftiest football coach LSU has ever had.
Now I still can’t claim to have it all figured out, but I think I may have latched on to a few things:

1) -- Les Miles loved him some LSU.

2) -- There was a time when Les Miles thought that coaching football at LSU was just about the most fun he could have with his clothes on.

3) -- Les Miles loved his players. His players (mostly) loved him back, and once they bought in, they would (generally) run through walls for the guy.

Those who did not buy in would (generally): A) transfer out, or B) do something stupid enough to get dismissed.

4) -- Les Miles loved LSU fans. He loved their passion for the team. He was not bothered by vociferous expressions of frustration. He welcomed it, in fact, because it meant that the fans were paying attention.

You see . . .

5) -- Les Miles was an amateur psychologist of high gifts. His entire public persona -- his tiny hat, his grass-eating, his vague, near-incomprehensible coach-speak and non sequiturs, and everything else that made the media call him “quirky” -- all of it was conscious, all of it was deliberate, and all of it was very, VERY carefully crafted.

You see . . .

6) -- Miles was a highly accomplished troll. In fact, Les Miles elevated trolling to a high and holy art.

7) -- Miles thought that trolling the media (local and national) was the second-most fun he could have with his clothes on.

Remember that the proof of any troll’s craftsmanship is that the trollees do not realize that they are being trolled -- and in this case, all they saw and heard (and reported on) was the “quirkiness”.

8) -- Miles may have had fun with his trolling, but it also had a serious, well-considered purpose: Les Miles was actively and deliberately creating opportunities for observers to underestimate him, and to underestimate the team.

This had three effects:

A) -- it lowered fan expectations, which made the fans happy when the team exceeded them.

B) -- it lowered media expectations, which made pundits -- local and national -- more likely to ascribe LSU wins to luck & deception, rather than to the expertise of the position coaches.

C) -- it was intended to sow seeds of uncertainty in opposing coaching staffs (although this last effect had a tendency to diminish as the years (and seasons) would accrete).

Every season, we saw things that were deemed incomprehensible, and that caused Chernobyl-like meltdowns here.

Yes, he was a dinosaur, and had to go.

Yes, I would have been OK if his replacement had been Bugs Bunny.

Nevertheless, at the time, I came down more on the “crafty” side than the “doofus” side, until the revelation of his (again, incomprehensible) extracurricular activities -- which demonstrated that he was undoubtably a moron, too.





Posted by Traveler
I'm not late-I'm early for tomorrow
Member since Sep 2003
25635 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 4:47 pm to
Les won more games with talent on the field than he did with game time strategy.
Posted by Tigers0918
Member since Feb 2020
1469 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 4:48 pm to
I always felt that the 2008 year with Lee at QB broke him a bit.

After that, he really relied on QBs just not throwing INTs and becoming so incredibly conservative. It would still work at times and was the perfect recipe for winning 10 games.
Posted by Tiger Ugly
Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2008
16655 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 5:02 pm to
[quote]5) -- Les Miles was an amateur psychologist of high gifts. His entire public persona -- his tiny hat, his grass-eating, his vague, near-incomprehensible coach-speak and non sequiturs, and everything else that made the media call him “quirky” -- all of it was conscious, all of it was deliberate, and all of it was very, VERY carefully crafted.

As I alluded to earlier, i've heard this suggested and even stated strongly as you have....all due respect....I don't buy it. I've seen him in situations behind the wall where he didn't have to play this game and he was basically the same.
Posted by SlaughterDale
Slaughter
Member since Jan 2018
449 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 5:07 pm to
quote:

microcosm of Les' first 6 years or so at LSU


what a shite show that was. You really think Les would have learned from the ole miss game the year prior. My goodness
Posted by 904
Forever under I-10
Member since Dec 2009
960 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 5:33 pm to
quote:

what a shite show that was. You really think Les would have learned from the ole miss game the year prior. My goodness


It was honestly worse than I remembered from being in the stadium. The 2010 Tennessee game was the only sporting event I've ever watched where I was legitimately pissed off after winning.

Yes he has a good overall record and a natty in 2007, but I refuse to believe that a competent head coach can botch that situation so badly, much less a potential HOF worthy candidate. So many poor decisions and frickups in 35 seconds of gametime, only to confuse your opponent so thoroughly that you somehow pull the W straight out of your arse. Thankfully T-Bob was the only one thinking that day to save ole Lester.

This post was edited on 6/18/24 at 5:39 pm
Posted by 904
Forever under I-10
Member since Dec 2009
960 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 5:37 pm to
quote:

You really think Les would have learned


And this was the problem. The only thing he learned was to not trust his players abilities after the 2008 pick-6 fest. The man never adjusted from one game or season to the next in any meaningful manner.
Posted by LosTigres251
Plano
Member since Mar 2018
1609 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 7:27 pm to
quote:

He really really was a poor poor coach.


Ok keep telling yourself this.

After 12 years in charge of anything your record is what you are.

This post was edited on 6/18/24 at 7:41 pm
Posted by Jim Rockford
Member since May 2011
102491 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 8:20 pm to
Those of us who lived through the Hallman years know what a bad coach is. Miles had his deficiencies, a lot of them, both personal and professional But he won a title and left the program healthy enough for Orgeron to step in and win another one in short order. A terrible coach would have imploded by year three or four, not stayed twelve years with a winning record.
Posted by Brettbest308
Central
Member since Dec 2023
82 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 8:42 pm to
He didn't put pussy LSU defenses on the field !
Posted by Ebridg3
Baton Rouge, La
Member since Sep 2016
2571 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 9:55 pm to
quote:

This Les lawsuit has me reminiscing about his tenure.

He really really was a poor poor coach.


Yet despite him at the helm the talent won him a NC.


I have spoke to a quite a few of his former players and I ask them all the time about their recruitment by him.

They say he spoke and was exactly as he put forth in the media- aloof and disconnected.


I follow up and ask, “yet, you still chose to play for him?”

Most answer, “I wanted to be a Tiger.”


The guy was a product of nothing more than the LA home talent wanting to stay home despite the person at the helm being a bumbling idiot.


The guy made generational money for his family literally being a moron.


America.


This is the most nonsensical post I've ever encountered on TD. He became a media sensation, having defeated Nick Saban and Urban Meyer directly. He might have secured two National Championships if not for some questionable situations, for which he is only partly responsible. Since around 2014, I've wanted him gone, but in retrospect, he didn't care about popularity; his objective was victory. He had a strategy that was effective more often than not, pulling off wins in the final seconds of many games—too frequent to attribute to mere luck. His bold time management sometimes backfired, but overall, he was a competent coach. Brian Kelly has yet to put together and complete a Les Miles esque recruiting class and Ed O was hit and miss with it. We've yet to have a coach as good as Les was stastically since Les was here.
Posted by BallCoach
Member since Jun 2024
50 posts
Posted on 6/18/24 at 9:55 pm to
He called every fake kick and recruiter every All American. Twice the coach of Anyone since.
first pageprev pagePage 4 of 9Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram