re: The Witcher 4 Reveal Trailer

quote:

---

Ciri surviving the Trial of the Grasses in The Witcher universe would indeed raise significant lore issues, as the process is deeply tied to the established rules of the Witcher world. Below are the primary reasons why her survival would violate the lore, based on the established canon from Andrzej Sapkowski’s books, the games, and related materials:

The Trial of the Grasses Is Designed for Male Witchers
The Trial of the Grasses, a mutagenic process involving alchemical concoctions and magical enhancements, was specifically developed for young boys to transform them into witchers. The process is tailored to male physiology, as witchers in the lore (e.g., Vesemir, Geralt, Lambert) are exclusively male. The School of the Wolf, where Ciri was trained, never conducted trials on girls due to the extreme biological and hormonal differences, which would make the trial’s mutagens incompatible or even more lethal for females. The lore explicitly states that the trial’s survival rate is low even for boys (only 3 out of 10 survive), and there’s no precedent for a female undergoing it, suggesting it’s either impossible or highly improbable.

Ciri’s Unique Physiology (Elder Blood)
Ciri possesses the Elder Blood (Lara Dorren’s gene), which grants her unique magical abilities and a connection to the multiverse. The Trial of the Grasses involves mutagens that drastically alter the subject’s biology, often causing sterility and severe physical changes. There’s no lore precedent for how Elder Blood would interact with these mutagens, but given its rarity and power, it’s likely that such a process could destabilize or destroy her unique genetic traits. The trial’s mutagens might either kill her outright or disrupt her Elder Blood abilities, which are central to her role in the story. Her survival would require an unprecedented and unexplained compatibility that the lore doesn’t support.

Historical Context: No Female Witchers
The lore of The Witcher establishes that witchers are male, with no recorded instances of female witchers in the books or games. The trials were conducted by male-dominated schools (e.g., Wolf, Cat, Griffin), and the process was never adapted for females due to its extreme lethality and the patriarchal structure of the witcher guilds. Ciri’s training at Kaer Morhen focused on combat and monster-hunting skills, not the mutagenic trials, because the witchers (Vesemir, Geralt, etc.) knew she couldn’t undergo the process. Her survival would break this established tradition without any canonical explanation.

The Trial’s Lethality and Ciri’s Age
The Trial of the Grasses is typically administered to prepubescent boys, as their bodies are more malleable to the mutagens. Ciri, by the time she’s at Kaer Morhen, is older (around 12–14 in the books), which would make her a poor candidate even if she were male. The trial’s survival rate is abysmal, and older candidates face even higher risks due to their bodies being less adaptable. Ciri surviving such a process, despite her age and gender, would contradict the lore’s emphasis on the trial’s extreme danger and specificity.

Ciri’s Role as a Non-Witcher Hero
In the lore, Ciri’s strength lies in her unique destiny, Elder Blood powers, and her training as a warrior and sorceress, not as a witcher. The narrative deliberately sets her apart from the witcher archetype—her path is tied to her magical heritage and her ability to navigate worlds, not to becoming a mutated monster hunter. Forcing her through the Trial of the Grasses would undermine her unique role in the story and blur the distinction between her and traditional witchers, which the lore carefully maintains.

Lack of Canonical Precedent
Neither the books nor the games provide any examples of a female surviving the Trial of the Grasses. While some fan theories or non-canonical sources (e.g., the Netflix series) might suggest experimental trials or deviations, these are not supported by Sapkowski’s original works or CD Projekt Red’s games. For instance, the books mention experiments on children (e.g., at the School of the Cat), but there’s no evidence of successful female witchers. Ciri surviving the trial would require a significant retcon or invention outside the established lore.

Potential Sterility Conflict
The Trial of the Grasses renders male witchers sterile, a key aspect of their transformation. Ciri’s Elder Blood lineage is tied to her potential to pass on her magical heritage (a major plot point in the books, as various factions seek to control her reproductive future). If she survived the trial, the resulting sterility would conflict with the lore’s emphasis on her bloodline’s importance, creating a narrative inconsistency.

Conclusion
Ciri surviving the Trial of the Grasses would violate the lore due to the trial’s male-specific design, her unique Elder Blood physiology, the absence of female witchers in canon, her age, and the narrative role she plays as a non-witcher. Any depiction of her undergoing and surviving the trial would require significant deviations from established rules, lacking support from the books or games. If this idea stems from a specific source (e.g., the Netflix series or fan content), it could be a creative liberty, but it doesn’t align with the core Witcher lore. If you have a specific context in mind (e.g., a show, game, or fan theory), let me know, and I can address it further!

---

quote:

---

I actually have never beat the Witcher 3. But I did enjoy her as a character.

Totally think she capable of carrying the franchise on.

---

quote:

---

Ciri, by the time she’s at Kaer Morhen, is older (around 12–14 in the books), which would make her a poor candidate even if she were male. The trial’s survival rate is abysmal, and older candidates face even higher risks due to their bodies being less adaptable. Ciri surviving such a process, despite her age and gender, would contradict the lore’s emphasis on the trial’s extreme danger and specificity

---

quote:

---

You know where the AI search gets its content?

---

quote:

---

If you could already sense monsters magically and use Witcher vision-type abilities, why would you risk possible death and DEFINITE sterility just to have those abilities non-magically?

---