re: Weird iCloud restore problem

they both had icloud accounts already. So the old phone used daughter 1's icloud account (D1). That backup is restored onto D1's new phone.

Daughter 2 (D2)'s new phone has been wiped clean. She is signed in with her existing icloud account. This account was not associated with the old phone or backup.

Both phones go to the same text window on my phone. Even with imessage turned off on all 3 phones.

edit - with imessage off it works