Example of why replay in baseball is so difficult

brewers 2 @ Cardinals 1 bottom of the 8th with 2 outs

Holiday at the plate runners on first and third hits a slow chopper up the middle.

2nd baseman can't make the play at 2nd so he goes to first to get Holliday and Holliday slides head first and looks to be safe but umpire calls him out

They review it and Holliday is called safe but what to do with carpenter who was at third before the pitch and may or not have scored on the play had Holliday been called safe originally

Umpires leave carpenter at third costing the cardinals the game tieing run.

I personally think he probably scores on the play but you can't say that for sure and I'm sure I'm biased. Idk exactly what the rule is but I'm pretty sure it's left to the umpire/New York's discretion and I feel like there's gotta be some way to have a concrete rule that is clear to determine what to do with the baserunner in a situation such as this

To be clear, this is not a bitch thread bc it cost the cardinals a run. In fact we just tied it up anyways but the point of this is to point out remaining issues with replay that need to be ironed out