- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Who's the better QB: Mahomes or Peyton Manning
Posted on 11/5/25 at 9:43 pm
Posted on 11/5/25 at 9:43 pm
21
Posted on 11/5/25 at 9:49 pm to boomjosh
Until Mahomes does what Manning was doing in his 15th season, it's Manning. Longetivity gets the edge for now.
Posted on 11/5/25 at 9:49 pm to boomjosh
Manning, especially for longevity
Mahomes is only 30 and already fading
Mahomes is only 30 and already fading
Posted on 11/5/25 at 9:51 pm to castorinho
quote:
Longetivity gets the edge for now.
I’ll allow you some latitude for this one
Posted on 11/5/25 at 9:53 pm to The Boat
That's a lot of degrees
Posted on 11/5/25 at 9:59 pm to boomjosh
I’m taking Mahomes all day. Look at the ring count!
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:00 pm to boomjosh
Unpopular opinion incoming. I’m taking Mahomes. Way more athletic, already has more super bowls, and treats his teammates better. Sorry.
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:03 pm to JohnnyRebel
quote:
already has more super bowls
He didn't have to play prime Brady
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:05 pm to The Boat
quote:
The Boat
No cap
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:06 pm to whatiknowsofar
I don’t care, he’s had to deal with Josh Allen. Mahomes is the better QB, especially out the gate. Payton Manning is the king of hospital balls, and the fact he couldn’t deal with prime Brady, but his little brother could on the biggest stage… well, I rest my case.
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:11 pm to The Boat
quote:
Mahomes is only 30 and already fading
What an awful take
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:20 pm to boomjosh
Joe Montana
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:20 pm to JohnnyRebel
quote:
don’t care, he’s had to deal with Josh Allen
Who isn't as good as Tom Brady. Or those pats teams
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:21 pm to boomjosh
Manning
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:31 pm to whatiknowsofar
quote:
Who isn't as good as Tom Brady. Or those pats teams
I agree, but the point is, Mahomes is beating the best competition in his era, and Peyton didn’t. You’re arguing Peyton would be better than Mahomes if Brady wasn’t there, as far as rings go, and you’d probably be right. But I also notice how you didn’t respond to the rest of what I said in that post. Why not?
Like others have said, the only argument is longevity, which isn’t a good argument, because we don’t know how long Mahomes will go.
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:34 pm to JohnnyRebel
quote:
But I also notice how you didn’t respond to the rest of what I said in that post. Why not?
Because using super bowls is a dumb way of measuring how good a qb is vs another. It's a team stat
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:35 pm to boomjosh
Well manning is the goat so…
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:39 pm to boomjosh
Manning. How much of Mahome's success is because of Andy Reid?
Posted on 11/5/25 at 10:39 pm to whatiknowsofar
Okay, so how is Peyton Manning a better QB than Mahomes?
Longevity is all he has over Mahomes. Is that what we’re measuring on? Please tell me the non-dumb way to measure two different era great QB’s. It’s all dumb. This thread is dumb, but I’m entertaining it.
Longevity is all he has over Mahomes. Is that what we’re measuring on? Please tell me the non-dumb way to measure two different era great QB’s. It’s all dumb. This thread is dumb, but I’m entertaining it.
Page 1 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News