re: Dante Moore plans to enter the portal

quote:

---

If TigerKnights is adamant that Nuss is the guy, but the staff decides someone else is better..

---

I love the appeal to authority fallacy, but it's still fallacious reasoning. The Daniels example is cherry picking one where it worked out.

quote:

---

Disagree. If anything NIL makes it easier because the player is still being heavily compensated. I don’t want or expect the coaches to let boosters twist their arm when it comes to personnel decisions.

---

Sure, but what you want isn't the reality. Rich people expect ROI and they like to have influence.

quote:

---

Transfer portal window closes on 1/2. After that point, nobody can enter the portal until after spring camp. That timing is something I’m sure the staff (and many other staffs across the country) are considering when it comes to incoming transfers.

---

I'm not gonna hope for a player to get stuck in a bad situation. Though I imagine if a transfer QB is coming they would be announced with plenty of time for others to transfer out.

quote:

---

I hate to break it to you, but that’s the world we live in today. It’s not exactly new either.

4 of the top 10 teams in the CFP rankings have transfers at QB. 3 of the last 4 QBs to win the Heisman were transfers. LSU has started a transfer at QB for 8 of the past 12 years.

---

Disagree. LSU is a bad example because we have never had success recruiting QBs. That has changed. BK has openly said he doesn't want a revolving door of transfers. 4 out of 10 still means 6 out of 10 do not. I also hope that's not including Caleb Williams because he moved with his coach so it's not the usual transfer situation. Also even if it were true that most of the successful QBs were transfers (it isn't) that doesn't make the inverse true. Most transfer QBs are not successful. It's a risk either way, but at least in house guys you've developed and recruited and know what you're getting.