re: Porter to Memphis according to Joe Schad

quote:

---

and he did break his fricking ankle on the play

---

He lost the ball way before the got rolled up on his ankle.

quote:

---

He lost the ball way before the got rolled up on his ankle.

---

no he didn't

and please point out all of KWs other fumbles to show his fumbling problem

quote:

---

How did KW end his career. Oh yeah, on another fricking fumble

---

fricking rantards...

I have a feeling that Keiland is going to have a pretty good NFL career. Les wasted his last 4 years.

Well...CONGRATS TO COACH PORTER!

Wish him the best in the new gig.

quote:

---

what matters more: practice or games?

---

You practice like you play most of the time.

quote:

---

and he was our #1 back to end 2006. why do people forget this?

---

So you think average yards per game makes or breaks a running back. So blocking, effort, attitude, intelligence, ball security, etc. don't matter? Would you rather a guy that gets 120 yards per game and picks up his blocks and knows how to line up or a guy who gets 200 yards per game but misses blocks half the time and his grip on the ball may lead to a fumble in a critical situation?

quote:

---

You practice like you play most of the time.

---

dude

what matters more: practice or games?

quote:

---

So you think average yards per game makes or breaks a running back

---

keiland williams would not have rushed for -1.3 yards per carry against AU

quote:

---

So blocking, effort, attitude, intelligence, ball security, etc. don't matter?

---

blocking: he was our 3rd down back and was as good at hester in pass protection
effort: the frick?
attitude: always was positive even though he was fricked for 3 of his 4 years
intelligence: the frick?
ball security: hester and scott fumbled more than keiland did in games

quote:

---

what matters more: practice or games?

---

both have to be taken into consideration but I personally think practice matters more. That doesn't matter.

quote:

---

keiland williams would not have rushed for -1.3 yards per carry against AU

---

we will never know, but that doesn't matter.

quote:

---

blocking: he was our 3rd down back and was as good at hester in pass protection effort: the frick? attitude: always was positive even though he was fricked for 3 of his 4 years intelligence: the frick? ball security: hester and scott fumbled more than keiland did in games

---

Again, none of this matters. I wasn't using traits that players on the team have, I was speaking generally. You seem to care more about stats and flashiness and don't care about the less noticeable things that also play a massive role in a player's ability.

I agree with you that KW should have gotten more carries. I agree with you that he was probably the best rb at points in his career even though that is subjective. Maybe you should re-read the thread. We were talking about porter's ability to coach running backs, especially the little things like blitz pick up. We came to a consensus that he was a great recruiter but an average at best coach. He possibly prevented the growth of the rbs and KW could have possibly been a beast with better coaching. KW had all the potential in the world but the little things probably kept him off the field (like it or not it is Mile's MO).

quote:

---

I will bet posting privileges for a lifetime he lost the ball before his ankle got rolled. Anybody have the game on dvr?

---

Don't Afreaux out on me.

quote:

---

nhsj012

---

Stop now. You aren't helping yourself.

You've been SlowFroOwned in here.