As if I’m JBE, present to me your strongest argument as to why we should open back up

quote:

---

scientific sources.

---

Are there any for either argument? Like real tested/reviewed scientific evidence?

(no message)

Why must the compelling reason be scientific? Do the arguments against cratering our economy not count?

How about you make the case for continuing the shutdown, please include all relevant scientific sources.

We are 3 weeks past our peak in cases. Phase 1 says 14 days.

quote:

---

That's the thing - everyone is just guessing. Nobody knows anything. The anti-shut down types are also guessing about the economic toll even though they have no concept of what people are going to do when they are "allowed" back out. No concept of whether infections rise again. No concept of whether real herd immunity can be achieved. No idea of when a good treatment may come.

it's all a guess

---

I agree

But we still need more cases to approach critical care capacity, regardless

Our current rates are highly inefficient and will make this last longer irrationally

quote:

---

Why must the compelling reason be scientific? Do the arguments against cratering our economy not count?

---

That in itself is a scientific argument. Please present the relevant facts with citations so I may consider it.

Compare the states current unemployment vs how many have died from this.

There’s your scientific research.

quote:

---

Compare the states current unemployment vs how many have died from this.

There’s your scientific research.

---

Show me the comparison peon I don’t have the time to do your work for you.