Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message
locked post

The Battle of Chancellorsville, Day Three - May 3, 1863 - 157 Years Ago Today - Morning

Posted on 5/3/20 at 8:28 am
Posted by RollTide1987
Baltimore, MD
Member since Nov 2009
71735 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 8:28 am
Despite the success of Jackson's flank attack the previous afternoon, the Union Army of the Potomac still held a formidable position around the important crossroads of Chancellorsville. With the arrival of the I Corps that morning, the Army of the Potomac's overall strength had increased to 76,000 men. The Army of Northern Virginia's total strength on the morning of May 3 was about 43,000 men.

To make matters even more complicated for the Confederacy, Lee's army was very much divided. Jackson's corps, now commanded by Jeb Stuart, was astride the Orange Turnpike to the west of the Union defenses, while the divisions of Richard Anderson and Lafayette McLaws - now under Lee's direct supervision - were astride the Orange Turnpike to the east of the Union defenses. He needed to reunite his forces if he had any chance of survival or victory. To do that...he would need to assault the center of the Union position - which was held by the XII, II, and III Corps.

Hooker inadvertently gave Lee a much needed break before the fighting even started. The area known as Hazel Grove, a raised platform excellent for artillery, was presently held by the Union III Corps. That morning, before dawn, Hooker ordered Sickles to vacate the position and fall back 1,600 yards to the north to a point known as Fairview Hill. Sickles obeyed. The astonished Confederates watched as the Union army vacated one of the highest, most open points on the battlefield and quickly moved their artillery into position on the now empty ground. 30 guns under the command of Porter Alexander would eventually pack into Hazel Grove. Their actions in the morning battle would go on to be decisive.

The Battle of Chancellorsville, Day Three - Morning Phase (May 3, 1863)


Jeb Stuart, in command of Jackson's corps, kicked off the fighting at 5:30 AM as his men advanced through the dense forest toward the Union defenses at Fairview. The North Carolina brigade of James H. Lane was the first to go forward and, within a matter of minutes, the brigade had sustained over 900 casualties assaulting the Union positions in just 20 minutes of fighting. Twelve of Lane's 13 field officers had been killed or wounded and only one of his five regiments - the 23rd North Carolina - could claim any semblance of still being a unit.

Next up was the Stonewall Brigade under the command of Brigadier General Elisha F. Paxton. Within moments of stepping off and beginning the attack, Paxton is shot through the heart and killed. The men of Stonewall Jackson's first command would advance bravely but suffer a similar fate to the North Carolinians. Over 600 of the brigade's 2,000 men were shot down and the brigade was forced to retreat after less than a half hour of combat.

This was the fighting around Fairview - arguably the most intense fighting of the war. From two sides the Confederate army attacked the Union position. To defend the position, the Union army was supported by 40 guns of artillery and the elements of three different army corps. Confederate infantry attacks, coupled with the 50 artillery pieces sighted on Fairview from Hazel Grove and the Plank Road, made this area "hot as hell."

For five hours the two sides battled for supremacy in this small area, and in those five hours something close to 18,000 men fell attacking or defending Fairview - an average of one man falling dead or wounded every second. Despite repeated Confederate attacks against the Union position that were unrivaled in intensity, the Federals maintained control of the position. The tide was soon about to turn.

From their position atop Hazel Grove, Confederate artillerists had a panoramic view of the Chancellorsville crossroads, as well as a view of the Union army headquarters at Chancellor mansion. Battery commander Porter Alexander ordered shells to be lobbed at that general location.

Watching the battle around Fairview from the front porch of the Chancellor mansion, Joseph Hooker - commanding general of the Army of the Potomac - was no doubt caught by surprise when his position came under fire of enemy artillery. He had no time to reposition himself, however, as a shell struck the column he was leaning against. The force of the blast sent him flying and not him unconscious.

Around that same time, the Confederate division of Robert Rodes was making an all out push for the crest of Fairview Hill. This offensive finally succeeded in taking Fairview and Confederate reinforcements streamed into the position so they could hold against a possible counterattack. That counterattack came and, though the Confederates fought bravely, they were forced to vacate the position.

It was now close to 10 AM and Hooker had regained consciousness in the front yard of the Chancellor mansion. Whatever taste for battle Hooker may have had before getting blasted by cannon ball, he had lost it. Still woozy and no doubt suffering from a severe concussion, Hooker turned to his second-in-command, Major General Darius Couch, and ordered a retreat to a new position just north of Chancellorsville. Despite the protests of both Couch and George Meade, the order was reluctantly carried out.

A half hour later, Lee and Stuart reunited the two halves of the Confederate army amidst the burning wreckage of the Chancellor mansion. Lee's men cheered him most vehemently and a sense of invincibility began to swim over the commanding general. That sensation was about to be tested, however, for at that moment Lee received disturbing news from Fredericksburg. Major General John Sedgwick and his force of 40,000 infantry, had broken through the Confederate lines on Marye's Heights and were marching directly for Lee's rear.

The Battle of Chancellorsville was still far from over...
Posted by Champagne
Sabine Free State.
Member since Oct 2007
56227 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 10:54 am to
Great thread.

One very important topic of discussion that I'd like to learn more about is the topic of Staff Work in the armies of the Potomac and Northern Virginia.

The Commanding General would draft an order and send it to his subordinate commander(s) for execution. What were the mechanics of how this happened? Why was much of the staff work and transmission of orders so shoddy during the American Civil War (ACW)? Did West Point teach Staff Work back then?

I don't think that West Point cadets learned anything about Staff Work back then and I'm not sure that the military systems of the USA and CSA had any professional staff training.

Poor staff work and poor transmission of orders had an EXTREMELY significant impact on just about every important ACW battle that we all like to read about.
Posted by beerJeep
Louisiana
Member since Nov 2016
39254 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 10:57 am to
I always read your post in Dan Carlin’s voice

Great post, as usual.
Posted by Darth_Vader
A galaxy far, far away
Member since Dec 2011
74667 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 11:04 am to
quote:

One very important topic of discussion that I'd like to learn more about is the topic of Staff Work in the armies of the Potomac and Northern Virginia.

The Commanding General would draft an order and send it to his subordinate commander(s) for execution. What were the mechanics of how this happened? Why was much of the staff work and transmission of orders so shoddy during the American Civil War (ACW)? Did West Point teach Staff Work back then?

I don't think that West Point cadets learned anything about Staff Work back then and I'm not sure that the military systems of the USA and CSA had any professional staff training.

Poor staff work and poor transmission of orders had an EXTREMELY significant impact on just about every important ACW battle that we all like to read about.


The concept of what you and I recognize as “staff work” did not exist at that time in either side. It could be described at best as an ad hoc approach. It was the Prussians who really made it a science. This was made evident to the world during the Franco-Prussian War five years after the Civil War ended. But even after this and into WWI and WWII the Germans really were ahead of everyone else. It was their mastery of staff work that helped make the Germans such a formidable force.
Posted by RollTide1987
Baltimore, MD
Member since Nov 2009
71735 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 11:14 am to
quote:

The Commanding General would draft an order and send it to his subordinate commander(s) for execution. What were the mechanics of how this happened?


It really depended upon the general and the circumstances as it wasn't an exact science at the time. Hooker was utilizing verbal as well as written communications from his headquarters at the Chancellor mansion. He was also experimenting with sending orders via the wired telegraph, but those experiments proved to be unsuccessful as he was unable to coordinate successfully with Sedgwick's forces at Fredericksburg.

Lee had a small staff and thus his orders were sometimes delayed and ambiguous. It didn't matter when you had a subordinate like Jackson to read those orders and usually take the more aggressive option Lee gave him. I think people would be well within their right to criticize the discretionary orders Lee often sent out to his subordinate generals, especially once Jackson was dead.

A lot of people criticize Ewell at Gettysburg for failing to take the high ground after Lee issued orders for him to do so. Problem was...no one ever reads the full text of the orders:

"Carry the hill occupied by the enemy if practicable, but avoid a general engagement until the arrival of the other divisions of the army..."

I mean...what are you supposed to do with that? To attack Cemetery Hill would have meant to bring about a general engagement with the enemy as the enemy was on that hill with artillery backing him up. Not to mention the fact that a battle had just been waged that cost both armies a combined 16,000 casualties. That sounds like a "general engagement" had already occurred.

It was rare in the Civil War that you found a general with an incredible staff with virtually unambiguous orders. One of the exceptions? Ulysses S. Grant. His instructions were almost always timely and contained virtually no ambiguities. Very rarely did a subordinate of his not know what to do with the forces under his command when Grant sent out an order.
This post was edited on 5/3/20 at 11:17 am
Posted by ZULU
Member since Sep 2009
1014 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 11:43 am to
They used carrier pigeons
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram