The Perfect Punk Song

By sound or by a band commonly lumped into punk?

The Decline by NOFX

It's considered post-punk/post-hardcore, but I'd argue for:

Fugazi - Waiting Room

Refused- Summerholidays vs Punkroutine

quote:

---

I didn't say I don't consider it punk. Frankly, most proto-punk is talentless trash, so I much prefer the post-punk bands that actually had talented musicians as players.

---

you're own words were "It's considered post-punk/post-hardcore"

if you just said the name of the song and left it at that, I'd give you the benefit of the doubt.. but you are basically contradicting yourself

quote:

---

"It's considered post-punk/post-hardcore"

---

which are both considered punk in the big picture.. Jesus fricking christ!

quote:

---

Funny, I think that same thing every time you post.

---

The feeling is mutual, sir

quote:

---

lol, that just makes it even worse.
Seriously, find another board to troll.

---

How the frick am I trolling, the post called is "the perfect punk song" and the dude said he doesn't even know if it's considered a punk song..

quote:

---

By sound or by a band commonly lumped into punk?

---

I would say by sound. I was thinking along the lines of “traditional” punk from ‘75-80 (Clash, Ramones, Pistols, Buzzcocks) but it is Punk so however anyone chooses to define is fine.

quote:

---

you're own words were "It's considered post-punk/post-hardcore"

if you just said the name of the song and left it at that, I'd give you the benefit of the doubt.. but you are basically contradicting yourself

---

You're the one getting hung up on it, chief.