re: Please help settle argument!!

For comparison sake, here's the 2001 NFL Draft assuming you made a team 2-deep of the first two players taken at each position:

QB: Michael Vick/Drew Brees
RB: LaDainian Tomlinson/Deuce McAlister
WR: David Terrell/Koren Robinson (Reggie Wayne and OchoCinco both taken later)
TE: Todd Heap/Alge Crumpler
T: Leonard Davis/Kenyatta Walker
G: Steve Hutchinson/Bill Ferrario
C: Dominic Raiola/Casey Rabach

DT: Gerard Warren/Richard Seymour
DE: Justin Smith/Andre Carter
LB: Kendrell Bell/Tommy Polley/Dan Morgan/Jamie Winborn
CB: Nate Clements/Will Allen
FS: Idrees Bashir/Bhawoh Jue
SS: Adam Archuleta/Tony Dixon

K: Bill Gramatica
P: Nick Harris


Interesting.

They wouldn't win 1 game. In fact, by year five they would still suck. Most prospects in a draft last 3 or fewer years in the NFL. The first round is often a wasteland.