re: Another Guilbeau gem

quote:

---

This article is a demonstration of this writer's ineptness and lack of knowledge.

---

quote:

---

He's demonstrating his lack of credibility.

---

Where's the factual mistakes in this article?

quote:

---

Where's the factual mistakes in this article?

---

There are none, what is the point of pointing out those facts?

See my post at the bottom of page 2

Tiger fans can expect GG to prominently and favorably mention Nick Saban in his articles for so long as Saban is a hot button for tiger fans.

AND, for so long as his love for Nick goes unrequited.

quote:

---

the article in question does nothing to promote Saban

---

It was ONLY written to promote Saban.

quote:

---

The Saban-hate on the Rant is amusing though.

---

The Saban-love on the Rant is a little disturbing,though.

LSU released a statement regarding LSU players in the NFL.

GG presented the FACTS.

Good grief, y'all hate Saban even though he won championships and built a solid recruiting foundation.

He was stupid for leaving and he's an arrogant fool, but let it go.

DiNardo and Hallman deserve the wrath, not Saban.

quote:

---

but the article in question does nothing to promote Saban or belittle Miles imo.

---

Then what is the point of the article? Were there any factual errors in the LSU press release in need of correction? Did the LSU PR mention any coaches other than the current one?

quote:

---

The Saban-hate on the Rant is amusing though.

---

I agree, equally amusing is the deification of Nick Saban by some fans and media types.

quote:

---

The guy did a job for LSU

---

Did being the operative word. He is no longer the coach at LSU, so there is no reason to expect a press release by LSU to praise his accomplishments especially considering he currently coaches a division rival. There is only one reason to point out that players, such as Glen Dorsey and Tyson Jackson that were coached for 3 and 4 years respectively by Miles, were signed by Saban. The NCAA and presumably the member schools take the POV that players sign with the schools, not coaches anyway.

quote:

---

But H-Town your "facts" presented just shows your bias against a coach who once cheered

---

Really? How so? Are any of my facts wrong? I am not biased against Saban, only Saban worshipers and those that engage in all or nothing thinking.

My only point is that Saban needed LSU as much if not more than LSU needed Nick Saban.

quote:

---

Oh, GG did mention other former coaches too, not just Saban.

---

Right, in part to compare and contrast. The LSU PR did not mention any former coaches, only the current one. The PR says 47 former LSU players are in the NFL and 22 were coached by Miles. Obviously, someone else coached the remaining 25. If the PR had mentioned Archer, Hallman and DiNardo, then there would a reason to point out the players coached by Saban. But that is not the case, so the GG article is just another gratuitous slap at Miles.

quote:

---

Sounds like critism to me....

---

Not to Miles, but keep drinking kool-aid.

quote:

---

Like this one???
"Saban clearly started NFL's Bayou Pipeline"

---

While LSU has always produced NFL talent, the fact is LSU has become a pipeline of NFL talent this decade.

What's the damn problem of acknowledging that and who started it?

quote:

---

Not to Miles

---

i never mentioned Miles you did... its critism of LSU press release isn't it???

quote:

---

keep drinking kool-aid

---

sounds like you're drinking the GG kool-aid..

you said:

quote:

---

While LSU has always produced NFL talent, the fact is LSU has become a pipeline of NFL talent this decade.

---

GG said:

quote:

---

Saban clearly started NFL's Bayou Pipeline

---

i see reading comprehension is not one of you strong points...

But don't let facts get in the way of your argument....

quote:

---

What's wrong with LSU releasing a PR stating the FACT that 21 current NFL players were coached at LSU by Les Miles?

---

but to GG, what's an LSU article without a mention of Saban in it.....