Best material for weatherstripping around old door?

I have an old house with an old door and frame with irregular sized gaps and deteriorating brass spring weather stripping that needs to be replaced.

It is the single plane variety like this,

LINK

but I am also looking at one like this vee shaped one

LINK

I would also consider a foam/rubber/neoprene style, but due to the irregular gap width, I would expect difficulty finding the right thickness and give that would seal well without making the door difficult to close, or getting a memory. And most are applied using adhesive exclusively, suggesting short life.

I'd like it to be robust and as unobtrusive as the bronze springs and well-sealing.

If bronze is still the best way to go, those products above look great, but the shipping is understandingly high (8ft box), and Id prefer to find it locally.

What is the best solution? Locally or on-line? (Baton Rouge)


I am aslo replacing the old sweep and adding an under-door seal.