re: The OFFICIAL Rate My Team Thread

Posted by TigerTatorTots

The Safeshore

Member since Jul 2009

80859 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 6:35 pm to imAMAZING

quote:
Did i make a mistake drafting vick in the second round? 12 teamer, .5 ppr, all TDs are six points

Starters
QB - M.Vick
RB - R. Mendenhall
RB - F. Jones
WR - B. Lloyd
WR - D. Bryant
WR - P. Harvin
TE - O. Daniels
D/ST - Chargers

Bench
QB - K.Orton
RB - K. Moreno
RB - CJ. Spiller
WR - AJ. Green
TE - G. Olson

Vick in the 2nd is great value! I am a Felix fan so I like him as a RB2. No standouts on your WR core, but all 3 are good starters IMO. Love Daniels as a mid-late round TE. Good bench, you have solid RB depth. I would probably drop Olsen and pick up another WR for added depth. Overall, I do like your team. One of the better ones I have seen in terms of depth with people who go QB in the first 2 rounds.

Posted by TigerTatorTots

The Safeshore

Member since Jul 2009

80859 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 6:37 pm to dlmast87

I like Pettigrew, if Stafford can stay healthy. Keller and Hernandez also look good in the pre-season games, but you can't read much into pre-season.

Posted by RunningHeel

Richmond

Member since Mar 2011

881 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 6:39 pm to TigerTatorTots

quote:
Awesome team. While your QBs are up in the air, your RBs are amazing for a 12 teamer, and your WRs are amazing! I'd take that team in a 10 teamer. TE and QB are shaky, but your WR/RBs should carry you.

I agree Stafford is the wild card, if he stays healthy I really love my team

Posted by TigerTatorTots

The Safeshore

Member since Jul 2009

80859 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 6:40 pm to RunningHeel

He has a high ceiling so if he can stay healthy, you should be golden

Posted by GRTiger

On a roof eating alligator pie

Member since Dec 2008

63577 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 7:07 pm to TigerTatorTots

12 team league no PPR. 1 QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 Flex, K, D/ST.

QB: Brady, Rothlisberger
RB: Chris Johnson, Shonn Greene, Jahvid Best, Pierre Thomas
WR: Calvin Johnson, Mike Williams (TB), Pierre Garcon, Hines Ward, Mike Williams (Sea)
TE: Owen Daniels, Tony Gonzolez
K: Akers (prob get Longwell on waivers)
DST: Saints

Posted by LSUTigKyl

Nashville

Member since May 2009

1815 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 7:32 pm to CE Tiger

10 team PPR

QB: Romo
RB: Ray Rice
RB: Steven Jackson
RB/WR: Joseph Addai
WR: Roddy White
WR: Vincent Jackson
TE: Marcedes Lewis
D: Eagles
K: Crosby

Bench: Percy Harvin, Maclin, Collie, LT, Brandon Jacobs, Deion Branch, and Mcnabb

Posted by TigerTatorTots

The Safeshore

Member since Jul 2009

80859 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 8:14 pm to GRTiger

quote:
12 team league no PPR. 1 QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 Flex, K, D/ST.

QB: Brady, Rothlisberger
RB: Chris Johnson, Shonn Greene, Jahvid Best, Pierre Thomas
WR: Calvin Johnson, Mike Williams (TB), Pierre Garcon, Hines Ward, Mike Williams (Sea)
TE: Owen Daniels, Tony Gonzolez
K: Akers (prob get Longwell on waivers)
DST: Saints

Good team. If CJ plays, you have a pretty good RB core, I like Greene this year. Best is better suited for a PPR, but as a 3rd RB, he is suitable. Your first two WRs are money, but I really do not like your bench. Not a Garcon, Ward, or Williams fan at all. You should have drafted another position player when you picked Ben because he will never start for you except for Brady's bye. Good TEs, I am a Daniels fan. Overall good team, not amazing, but definitely good.

Posted by TigerTatorTots

The Safeshore

Member since Jul 2009

80859 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 8:16 pm to LSUTigKyl

quote:
QB: Romo
RB: Ray Rice
RB: Steven Jackson
RB/WR: Joseph Addai
WR: Roddy White
WR: Vincent Jackson
TE: Marcedes Lewis
D: Eagles
K: Crosby

Bench: Percy Harvin, Maclin, Collie, LT, Brandon Jacobs, Deion Branch, and Mcnabb

Goodness did you draft with a bunch of mental challenged individuals?? How you have Harvin, Maclin, AND Collie on your bench is astounding. That being said, I would highly suggest trading one of them for a serviceable RB. After Addai, you have no one (not liking LT this year and Jacobs is the #2 man in NY). If you can get a someone like Beanie Wells for one of your bench WRs, your team will easily be the team to beat in your league.

Posted by bringonusc

Owasso, OK

Member since Aug 2007

3767 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 8:19 pm to TigerTatorTots

10 man/standard

I had the 3rd pick.

We start QB, (3) WRs, (2) RBs, Flex, TE, DEF, & K

QB: Phillip Rivers (3)
RB: Jamaal Charles (1)
RB: Daniel Thomas (6)
WR: Mike Wallace (4)
WR: Roddy White (2)
WR: Desean Jackson (5)
TE: Owen Daniels (8)
K: Garrett Hartley (16)
DEF: New Orleans (12)

Bench:
QB: Eli Manning (15)
RB: Mike Tolbert (9)
RB: Fred Jackson (10)
WR: Kenny Britt (11)
WR: Steve Johnson (7)
WR: Steve Smith (PHI) (13)
WR: Lance Moore (14)

Posted by TigerTatorTots

The Safeshore

Member since Jul 2009

80859 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 8:28 pm to bringonusc

quote:
10 man/standard

I had the 3rd pick.

We start QB, (3) WRs, (2) RBs, Flex, TE, DEF, & K

QB: Phillip Rivers (3)
RB: Jamaal Charles (1)
RB: Daniel Thomas (6)
WR: Mike Wallace (4)
WR: Roddy White (2)
WR: Desean Jackson (5)
TE: Owen Daniels (8)
K: Garrett Hartley (16)
DEF: New Orleans (12)

Bench:
QB: Eli Manning (15)
RB: Mike Tolbert (9)
RB: Fred Jackson (10)
WR: Kenny Britt (11)
WR: Steve Johnson (7)
WR: Steve Smith (PHI) (13)
WR: Lance Moore (14)

Slight reach on Daniel Thomas, but great value on Britt in the 11th, Stevie Johnson in the 7th, and Moore in the 14th. Your WR core is absolutely sick. For Britt to be your 5th WR, the is just nasty. Your RBs on the other hand, are pretty weak. I don't like Daniel Thomas being a RB2. I would move one of your WRs for a good starting RB. If you are able to get a decent #2 Rb, this team will be awesome.

Posted by GRTiger

On a roof eating alligator pie

Member since Dec 2008

63577 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 8:59 pm to TigerTatorTots

Thanks for the feedback. My thinking with Ben was a trade option. Probably tie him to Gonzo and bench WR for a riskier QB and a decent WR. Way too many WR taken early in my draft.

Overall I was happy. The 7/6 draft spot sucks.

Posted by lsuguy13

RIP MATT

Member since Mar 2004

9509 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 9:28 pm to GRTiger

12 team league non PPR 1st pick

QB- Tony Romo
RB-Arian Foster
RB- Steven Jackson
RB/WR-Fred Jackson
Flex- Hakeem Nicks
WR-Brandon Lloyd
WR Kenny Brit
TE- Brandon Petirguw
D- Bears

bench
AJ Green
Michael Crabtree
Rashad Jennings
Jacoby Jones
Randy Moss so far

lemme know what yall think

i need another rb but dont know who

prob tate to handcuff

Posted by TigerTatorTots

The Safeshore

Member since Jul 2009

80859 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 10:18 pm to lsuguy13

quote:
12 team league non PPR 1st pick

QB- Tony Romo
RB-Arian Foster
RB- Steven Jackson
RB/WR-Fred Jackson
Flex- Hakeem Nicks
WR-Brandon Lloyd
WR Kenny Brit
TE- Brandon Petirguw
D- Bears

bench
AJ Green
Michael Crabtree
Rashad Jennings
Jacoby Jones
Randy Moss so far

Not bad at all. Solid QB, Solid starting RBs, Solid starting WRs. Sleeper potential TE. AJ Green as a 4th WR is pretty good too. Your RB depth is horrible, you need to drop Randy Moss and add someone for depth. Aim for someone who has the potential to be a good starter if the guy infront of him gets hurt.

Posted by steakbombLSU

H-Town

Member since Feb 2005

5423 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 10:49 pm to TigerTatorTots

10 team standard, still drafting so no d/st or k yet.

qb philip rivers
rb chris johnson
rb deangelo williams
flex benjarvus
wr mario manningham
wr santonio holmes
te vernon davis
d/st
k

bench
ochocinco
cj spiller
malcom floyd
willis mcgahee
eli manning

This post was edited on 8/22/11 at 10:51 pm

2 ...

Posted by TigerTatorTots

The Safeshore

Member since Jul 2009

80859 posts

Posted on 8/22/11 at 10:53 pm to steakbombLSU

quote:
10 team standard, still drafting so no d/st or k yet.

qb philip rivers
rb chris johnson
rb deangelo williams
flex benjarvus
wr mario manningham
wr santonio holmes
te vernon davis
d/st
k

bench
ochocinco
cj spiller
malcom floyd
willis mcgahee
eli manning

Who on earth did you draft in the 2nd-7th?