re: Let's Talk About The Great Great Rafael Nadal

quote:

---

Ultimate opinion. Fed is the greatest overall player and greatest grass court player

Nadal is the greatest clay court player and third best overall player

Djok is the second greatest overall player

---

For me, it's tough to make an argument that Fed at his absolute best beats Djoke at his absolute best.

I agree that these three are 1, 2, 3. I think it has become difficult to come to any other conclusion.

When evaluating how to order said 1, 2, and 3, I think the conversation is essentially meaningless unless we first agree on what questions we are attempting to answer. If we are using what I commonly refer to as "the alien test", I would actually be inclined to take both Nadal and Djoke over Fed.