re: Better to buy WiFi extender or a whole new router?

quote:

---

I had an older ASUS dual band router and was thinking of replacing it with a mesh system like Google's. Instead I went with a better router (Netgear AC 1750) and am really happy with it. I have solid coverage throughout my house at roughly 2100 sq ft even with less than optimal router placement. I've heard really good things from friends/co-workers about the mesh systems, but I think you pay a bit of a premium. If you can swing the cost, then go for it and you'll likely be set. I could have afforded to go that way, but am happy I saved about $180 for more than adequate performance and features.

---

This.

A really nice router solves 90% of wifi issues, and is usually cheaper than mesh. Mesh will be great in 5-10 years, but the tech isn't there for multi-4k streaming/gaming/etc.

A nice router+a not as nice router covers my entire property with solid wifi, including a basement and backyard.

FWIW, I think sometime down the line mesh will be built in to devices like echos and what not, most likely bouncing signals from a better central router. Making mesh-dedicated devices themselves obsolete. Never skimp on a router it's now the most important non-built in household item outside of the refrigerator, air conditioner/heater, television and oven.