re: Amazon Echo vs Google Home - Which is best?

quote:

---

The Fire TV already has a row of its interface dedicated to NetFlix recommendations. It's stuff you've been watching on NetFlix.

---

Yeah, installing and signing in to an app on a given device gives it permission to watch what you do, assuming the app allows it.

quote:

---

Your remote control doesn't require personal authorization to turn on your TV.

---

My remote control doesn't work in the background, and it can't control anything other than my TV (or other devices that I explicitly tell it to in the case of a universal remote). Allowing another person physical access is authorization enough.

quote:

---

Maybe out of the box is the wrong phrase. Perhaps during a setup wizard or when you install an app you give permission not only to let your FireTV access the app, but you can also authorize your echoes.

---

So you agree now that installation and setup of app/device integrations is necessary? This is the crux of my earlier reply.

quote:

---

I'm just talking about giving the combination of FireTV and Echo devices access to knowing what you watch on NetFlix/Hulu/Plex/etc.

---

And that would be great. It just can't be automagic. App installation and setup required.

quote:

---

Having an Android phone and using the Google ecosystem gives Google way more access to much more personal information than we're talking about with controlling media playback.

---

I'm not necessarily worried about who has what personal or non-personal data. I am just saying I would have some questions if a device could worm its way into my other devices and app data without my knowledge and permission.

quote:

---

I really think you're underestimating Joe Six Pack's willingness to trade control for convenience.

---

Oh, I know the average person would think it's awesome. That's why I think it's important that those of us who have an idea how things work need to stay on top of it.

quote:

---

This new world where your shows come from so many different services that often have their own unique interface can be cumbersome to navigate.

---

I know it can be tough, in my house we use Plex, Netflix, Prime, Youtube, Sling, and Tablo. Even though my 4 year old can find exactly what he wants by navigating all but Sling and Tablo, it would definitely be easier to find what you want with a universal interface. I think it will happen eventually, but it just won't (or shouldn't) be automagic.